Tanya and Trish not up for comparison!

xGlamour_girlx thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
They r so different. I dont know why u guys keep comparing them so much. physically u can't compare them because trish has a very pretty face when Tanya looks plain. But Tanya seems to have a nice sweet aura about herself that trish lacks. So both are very beautiful in their own ways whatever u prefer. I noticed trish fans sayin eww tanya is ugly well guess what? inner beauty counts to a lot of people, and tanya fans love her more than trish fans could love her. (And unfortunatly in the soap world shalini is still a more popular and more loved actress)
they are both at fault no one is inncoent. they both have good sides and bad sides. if you point at tanya for ruining someones life then trish is ruining raj's life. tanya is not opening her mouth, neither is trish. but tanya has been pressured to keep quite too and the girl is weak. trish is strong but she is keeping quite to serve her own purpose.
then comes what they went through
trish never believed in love. finally she fell in love. she would've gone against her mother for him. but he ended up marrying her sister and he told her he didn't want to marry a girl like her. she thinks they had a thing going on behind her back. if that happened to me i would ask my sister right away why would she do that. it doesn't make sense. even if 2 sister dont get along it doesn't happen like that. but she has to act like a mean ** so whatever.
But her pain is heartbreak and betrayal
Tanya was raped. She was raped by a guy she hates more than anything. She was physically invavded and brutally violated. and she is scarred for life. she wanted to kill herself rather than live with the knowledge. do I need to describe the rape more?? I feel like its not going through to some ppl. I am sure it left a scar on her heart too. to add to that pain her family thinks she betrayed her own sis. it's evident tanya loves her family dearly. more dearly than trish loves her family. after that only to add salt and pepper to her open wounds she gets to see her sister get hurt more. Even though trish doesn't care what her sister is feeling tanya does. And she cries about it. The fact that she is too weak to do anything is another matter.
So stop comparing them!!!! they r going through 2 different things. Trish has a better chance of happiness than tanya does. the fact she cant move on or will not move in is another story but for now she is at a better place than tanya . She also went through less pain than Tanya.
if ur problem is u want trish and raj together. Only time will tell what happens. knowing the story is about vivaah they wont break it. No matter how much u pray for it. and tanya/yuv jodi is getting popular. they already shared few awkward moments which points toward a romantic storyline. and trish and raj are getting romantic too. they already slept with each other. so even though its totally ur choice better to enjoy the storyline as it is, since it doesn't look too good for trish yuv fans.

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

603

Users

6

Frequent Posters

minuu thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
I totally agree with you, Both sisters Tanya & Trishna are different in there Ways, So they shouldn't be compared together at all!
gp00 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Yes, they are different. I think we can establish that from all our topics and responses. But I compare and not in terms of pretty and ugly. Why compare? Because all their lives are interconnected. Tanya and Trishna are interconnected one, because they are sisters, and two, because Yuv and Deep are life-long friends, brothers really.

Comparison is not an unnatural or bad thing. We compare our views versus those of others, when in world politics, something bad happens we compare two leaders. When your literature professor tells you to compare two completely different people. When you look at someone's dress versus yours. When you look at what you have versus your relative or friend.

I want to reiterate one thing so it is clear: noone thinks the two are the same or comparable. But they are connected and shaping each other's lives. Bringing happiness or pain. And in our perspectives, you see that we all think what they did is right or wrong. We're judging their actions. And I think that is illuminating.
Multani90 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
I agree with gp00, yes Trish and Tanya are two different people, each have thier own way of absorbing things, and each of them have different traits, and deal with problems in different ways. But they are interconnected, they have known each other for all of the life, they are sisters, so when one does something, most of the time, well I believe more than most of the time, the other one is greatly effected. So, I feel that it is inevitable by human nature, to compare! Its not like we are doing a bad thing, its a part of analysis. I mean we are dealing with relationships, and a relationship has more than one person, so I think it is natural to look at both of them, and make a opinion on who is at fault and who is right! But regarding Tanya and Trisha, both have their strength and both of have thier weaknesses.
Edited by Multani90 - 16 years ago
twilightlover thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
i agree they are differnt but it is natural to compare
Chahat17 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
As long as the comparison is healthy and it doesn't turn ugly...i don't think it should be a problem for anyone....comparison is something done everywhere all the time...so its very normal...n nothing wrong with it...I just don't like it when people put their biased opinions forth and start to defend their favorite character or tracks by wrong clarifications and start a heated argument....i think we should always keep our morals and values in mind, whenever we post an opinion !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".