Who is who? - Page 4

Jee nehi. I read 1333 pg long epic by Kaasiraam Das. Not pdf nor english. Sanskrit version epic. May be you read the pdf child version where adult complecations are not included.

Kaasiram das is the best and most trusted one. I've collected that old book from the temple's library. Not from online etc.

Because Gandari's abusive marriage and tortured life was the core reason of Shakuni's outburst.

I have collected that from temple and took help from purrahitjee to read the entire book. Parva no yaad nehi. But when I will go to temple I will ask or search.

Kaasiram Das? Hope you know Mahabharata is composed by Ved Vyasa right?

I was saying about Mahabharata not any random poem by others

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Kaasiram Das? Hope you know Mahabharata is composed by Ved Vyasa right?

I was saying about Mahabharata not any random poem by others

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

So 5000 page is the child version of 5000 pager text? Ok if you want to believe that

As I said Shakuni had never an outburst

About adult complications its filled with it

Mahabharata is divided into 18 Parvas so now that you have read can you tell which Parva does Bheeshma arrests Gandhari's father and what was his name

Originally posted by: jhalak7

Jee nehi. I read 1333 pg long epic by Kaasiraam Das. Not pdf nor english. Sanskrit version epic. May be you read the pdf child version where adult complecations are not included.

Kaasiram das is the best and most trusted one. I've collected that old book from the temple's library. Not from online etc.

Because Gandari's abusive marriage and tortured life was the core reason of Shakuni's outburst.

I have collected that from temple and took help from purrahitjee to read the entire book. Parva no yaad nehi. But when I will go to temple I will ask or search.

The only Mahabharata exiting is Vaishampayan narration of Vyasa Mahabharata to Janmejaya(I hope you know who he is). The link that Pete shared was from a 350 years old manuscripts translated by KMG 120 yearz back I don't know how old this book you said is

KaamsiRam Das or anyone else is only a retelling and not reliable

Temple's library includes retelling that doesnt mean that its actual Mahabharata.

Again Shakuni never had any outburst against anyone. Parva number nhi Parva ka naam poochha tha.

Ok at least tell me which Parva contains Bhagwat Geeta

Originally posted by: jhalak7

I guess you read the bengali story version published from kolkata. That one is 5000 pg long. My frnd has one.

Story version? Behen thats the translation of Ved Vyasa Mahabharata to English

There is no Mahabharata by KansiRam there is only one by VedVyasa

You still want to take a random retelling as real then your choice

P.S. i can also share with you Geeta press book link it has both Sanskrit Shlok and their translation

Now if you think Geeta Press is also fake then your choice

Originally posted by: jhalak7

Kaasiram Daas is the most trusted brand name for Mahabharata . Offcourse I know Vyas wrote it. 🙄

If Vyasa wrote Mahabharata then how come a poem by Kaasiram become actual Mahabharat?

I am talking about Ved Vyasa Mahabharata and you about one written by KaansiRam so you decide whom you think as real

Could one of you please help explain

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Story version? Behen thats the translation of Ved Vyasa Mahabharata to English

There is no Mahabharata by KansiRam there is only one by VedVyasa

You still want to take a random retelling as real then your choice

P.S. i can also share with you Geeta press book link it has both Sanskrit Shlok and their translation

Now if you think Geeta Press is also fake then your choice

Ask your local priest about Kaasiramdaas Mahabharata and Krittivyas Ramayana. They know best.🙏

Originally posted by: jhalak7

English version is editted. You will never find the true story there.

Ask your local priest about Kaasiramdaas Mahabharata and Krittivyas Ramayana. They know best.🙏

Where do you find a edited version which is longer than the original?

Had it been edited it should have been shorter not about 4 times.

And if you think KamsiRam and Krittivyas are more reliable than VedVyasa and Valmiki then no one change your opinion

I think you are Bengali these versions are famous there. But if you do even slightest reseach you will know they are retelling including folklore and stories from Puranas.

Mahabharata by Vyasa is the only unadulterated one

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Where do you find a edited version which is longer than the original?

Had it been edited it should have been shorter not about 4 times.

And if you think KamsiRam and Krittivyas are more reliable than VedVyasa and Valmiki then no one change your opinion

I think you are Bengali these versions are famous there. But if you do even slightest reseach you will know they are retelling including folklore and stories from Puranas.

Mahabharata by Vyasa is the only unadulterated one