Anshuman : ??????????????? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

1.9k

Users

9

Likes

83

Frequent Posters

Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ilovepyaar

I disagree - what Tanya said to him before he went down on his knees was directed towards his ego. She tells him that he still hasn't lost his ego. Ego is a harmful thing. This isn't about self-respect. Right now, her life was in danger, and if he stubbornly refused to go on his knees and just left the matter, Tanya's life would have been in danger from his perspective. See, when Anshuman fell to his knees, he did that with no ego. Anshuman has lost the ego that used to be one of his fatal flaws - now it is no more.
you have interpreted the whole sequence with reasoning , Anshuman shed his ego and and wanted to convince her of his intentions .He is better person now with humility

When Tanya saw Anshuman on his knees, she looked surprised too and it didn't seem like she wanted to see Anshuman in that state. She looked confused, she even looked upset that Anshuman did that. She didn't like it. If she liked it, she would taunt him and say something like "look you're on your knees". What she said though, was okay she would go with him.
Tanya looked surprised and she would never had thought that Anshuman will do this . I agree with and your perspective . Anshuman is not the same one now , he is changed person no doubt . She did mocked him like before

We aren't used to seeing this on Indian TV which is why it seems so rare. Real life is filled with people like Anshuman who will forgive, who will forget, and who will drop their ego to save someone's life. Real life is also filled with people like the old Anshuman. There are different kinds of people inthe world, and I have seen both kinds. Anshuman is an advanced being now -
I am watching the old episodes as had not seen before. He was committed to Tanya that time , but one change with time .And Pakhi,s selfless love changed him where she never asked him anything in return and trusted him .
he isn't the same old Anshuman. His character has developed. Remember, Tanya mattered a lot to him at one point in time. Even if she didn't, he would still do it for the sake of humanity. Whether he gets down on his knees and begs or not isn't part of the bigger picture. The bigger picture is the immense amount of development that his character has undergone, which might even lead to Tanya's own redemption.



I am least bothered what i have seen as rarely watch any . Yes when i think your logic then you realize that for Anshuman , it was more important to save Tanya . And i am not interested in watching run of the mill kind of hero . Here he feels himself responsible for Tanya and Tanya also said what she did was at the heat of the moment . I want Tanya also changing her attitude when she will realize that Anshuman is genuine . I also hope that this track will bring change in Tanya and i do not want a negative character going on , life changes us when she will look at her Anshuman,s efforts ,to save her without any selfish reasons . Pakhi,s letter were also has big hand in the change in him where he is with peace himself .
Thank you

Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: saveeta24

"You also are self respected person and CVs really went over melodramatics . It does not go with Anshuman,s character . yes he has mellow down , it does not mean that he has beg with folded to Tanya to listen to him"..


I second you on this ..agree they want to show Anshuman as a changed person but this bit completely goes against his character.creatives who never goes OTT in drama failed this time.. it was over dramatized with Anshuman begging on knee to a Tanya Rana..if its pakhi i do understand but Tanya its not something to digest. bad execution of this issue of Tanya..Anshuman..

When we look at different perspective , Anshuman is also responsible for Tanya where he never came clear with her as he himself did not know wwhat he wanted and Tanya had asked him many times . So now Anshuman is not the old one , what not he did at Pakhi,s place to get her forgiveness. Here he wronged Tanya and so wanted to save her and Tanya is not believing him . He did what she asked as she challenged him about his ego . She does not know that Anshuman has changed ,and he has already left his ego behind.now when you look back ,he did to convince Tanya .and as i read someone,s logic about this whole , i agree with her . Tanya was part of his life for a long time and he was supposed to be in love with her , She did what she did at the heat of the moment when she came to know what Anshuman wanted . As she told him that was at the heat of the moment . Anshuman same did with Pakji at the heat of the moment . I want to see Tanya as she is part of this story ,

As you say let Tanya learn her lesson of life by herself why Anshuman hellbent of saving her ...well it was unrealistic for me that particular scene..
What i meant to say that Anshuman first collect the proofs and then go to Tanya to convince her and today he had the proof but misfired ,He has to convince Tanya that he is doing all this to save her. As for hellbent on saving her , why should not he be , he also was commited to her for so many years and even told her to take the challenge from Pakhi as he was with her . For the last moment Anshuman did not told Tanya . Look from Tanya,s angle . Giving her all proofs then the ball is in Tanya,s court what she does .

Since this separation and Delhi track my interest for this show has reduced from 100% to 90% ..its not about the actors but its the creatives that are disappointing me here going haywire with the execution of this track..i miss that gripping touch..that powerful scenes .dialogues but here its like filler Epi with less consistency..

You can not leave Tanya,s character hanging on the wire , she is major part of the story . Her story has to be told . I am not intersted in only watching hero heroine romance , thats why TP is special to me as all characters are important at there on place . Deepika has carved her own place now .
I mostly forward Tanya scenes the advantage of watching online and i hope i dont have to skip other scenes later..creatives should not drag this track anymore as its started to be visible now..



Now when i look at Tanya , here shown the Growth of Anshuman,s character where he has shed his ego and also is guilt ridden for both the women he has wronged , So wants to redeem himself what he did to Tanya . He is more gracious , humble and you can read care in his eyes now . And do not think Tanya,s track is dragging . CVs comes out with logic always . So lets waut and watch .


Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: HopeAndBelieve


It feels like a cycle, all I can say is wait. That touch will be back very soon, when this track ends, and the mother and son reunite. The emotions, the feelings, they'll return, I have high hopes that they'll execute the episodes coming in the next week very well. As for the interest level, I couldn't agree with you more, while the actors have done a fine job, the story has slipped a bit. It hasn't been the story that we all came to love in the past months. Some episodes did feel like fillers or it could be the scenes being stretched out more than needed.



As you said CVs have never failed the viewers and always come back with logic . Here in Tanya,s track , its the Anshuman,s growth as a human being and Tanya is part of this story , so loose ends has to be closed . Yes i was confused at Anshuman,s act but he wants to do something to clear his guilt by saving Tanya .

Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: alveera

seriously that kneeling part was bad, bad, bad. i was like yelling dunn do this anshuman while watching it, that was quiet over the top and dramatic. dunn know why they are showing this anshuman tanya track, it's like they need some time to develop paakhi, anuja track, but hopefully anshuman will meet his mother soon. now i want pakhi anshuman back ASAP.



Now i can understand Anshuman,s thinking , he tried but Tanya was not convinced then she challenged his ego and Anshuman left his ego and did what Tanya asked him to do and she was just speechless and was serious . She knows Anshuman very well that he will never bow himself to anyone . Anshuman is also responsible for Tanya,s situation today to some extent and why to do away with her . Why not to see Tanya,s growth in her nature , in all this . Find her different from other negative characters , Logic was always behind her actions . And its a story not a just love story so all characters have their own importance .


Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15
Thank you ilovepyaar , you have given logic to Anshuman,s act as i also was confused and after reading your comments watched the show again .
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: div26

I completely agree with you. The first part on the episode was according to me really bad. I watch Tumhari Pakhi online, from the first episode and today for the first time, I forwarded a scene



Hindi shows has fed the viewers with over the top negative characters where sometimes there is no logic . Here Tanya,s character was presented with logic , she was Anshuma,s girl friend for so many years and was committed to her to marry her . His first marriage came accidentally and to save his image he agree to bring his first wife . He never came clean with Pakhi or when he was changing and was attracting towards Pakhi , he never told Tanya and if she asked ,he denied . Anshuman,s character is not like a perfect hero , he he is with flaws . I like to see Tanya,s character,s growth where he could prove to Pakhi that he is changed person and that is because of her . Logically now i do not think so .

PRINCESS_ALISHA thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#17
i was upset from the time he was worried for her.
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Ilhamez

Yes i somehow agree with u
At the end of the day i will not wait from anshumzn to think like me
I can totally understand why he does this
But if u asked me about my opinion then i would disagree with what he did today
He can help her but no need to ho so far with it!
As u said cvs went so far with this ,they could show us everything else but no need for him to sit on his knees just for her to listen to him and to make us understand that anshuman has changed and he is no more that man with ego!

Yes i agree that was shown his growth from past Anshuman to this new Anshuman who is more human and better person
I watched as a person i would not do this but when he did that i was like fine u think this is what u should do then i have no right to stop u 😆
I really loved the part when pakhi said that she has option to go back and she can whenever she want
It means she is sure she will go back but trying to forget is so hard esp for a person like pakhi!
Nice post!



Here Pakhi took her time and introspected the whole scenario and seen Anuja Ji and her situations are totally different . Here she wanted by husband and her child where both loves her .
So Anuja Ji ,s situation , her past may realize her the love of Anshuman .


ilovepyaar thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Neerjaa



I am least bothered what i have seen as rarely watch any . Yes when i think your logic then you realize that for Anshuman , it was more important to save Tanya . And i am not interested in watching run of the mill kind of hero . Here he feels himself responsible for Tanya and Tanya also said what she did was at the heat of the moment . I want Tanya also changing her attitude when she will realize that Anshuman is genuine . I also hope that this track will bring change in Tanya and i do not want a negative character going on , life changes us when she will look at her Anshuman,s efforts ,to save her without any selfish reasons . Pakhi,s letter were also has big hand in the change in him where he is with peace himself .
Thank you



The CVs wouldn't introduce this without reasoning. Majority of the Indian tv serials these days show people lashing out in anger at their past relationships. In other shows, if the hero has an ex girlfriend who is now negative, he will treat her very poorly. The CVs could have done that here too. In fact, I was expecting it, because I didn't expect an Indian television serial lead to treat negative characters like humans too. But here they showed something different, and this is where I have to applaud the CVs. This was the final test for Anshuman. The old Anshuman would never have bowed down to someone like Tanya. This is the new, changed Anshuman.

The new Anshuman realizes that he didn't only hurt Paakhi, but he hurt Tanya a lot too. Anshuman lead Tanya on, filled her brain with false hope, lured her into his house, into his life, despite being unsure about everything. Anshuman is also responsible for Tanya's situation. Yes, Tanya is to be blamed the most, but Anshuman shouldn't be freed of the responsibility for her situation either. If Anshuman told her from the beginning, if he didn't lead her on, if he didn't ask her to do things she wasn't used to (live in his house and balance budget, acting like a typical wife/mother), she might not have been like this. Anshuman knows his mistake, he knows he wronged her, and he knows he hurt Tanya a lot. What she did wasn't right, and Anshuman isn't standing up for her mistakes, but he's standing up for his own.
Edited by ilovepyaar - 11 years ago
Neerjaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: PRINCESS_ALISHA

i was upset from the time he was worried for her.



Hindi shows has either the the black or white characters . nobody is totally black or white , means not perfect . are with some flaws . Here every character was not perfect , Why we want negative character to be remain negative . For a change expecting this time to show Tanya,s growth . she is shown to be written books and oxford return . So wants her to be changing her attitude while watching the change in Anshuman .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".