Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1

TSMSPJ ep:20 :25.4.17: My Impression: Challenging divinity

To challenge any creed whether one belongs to that faith or not, is totally unacceptable in the civilized world order. One is expected to show respect and tolerance towards it, as to discriminate against a person's religious conviction can be seen as an encroachment of civil liberties. However it is not unknown that in the name of religion, politically many wars, battles have been ravaged across the world. Common faith in an area is also a powerful tool that can be used by influential families to wield power over the masses, to maintain supremacy over the area. Moreover in the name of devotion many citizen and human rights too are violated publically and at mass. For whereas, religion instructs and disciplines it also gives rise to devout fervour that may teeter on the borderline of fanaticism..where by mob mentality can take over the zealous devotee , and slaying others who are seen to go against their creed becomes justified in the name of religion. Pity, as this blind one's truth faith. For no faith preaches violence against fellow human beings. If yesterday's episode was seen as a celebration of a popular faith festival Shivratri . The devotes give their all in terms of devotion and praise to their much loved deities Shiv and Parvati. Today's episode is about having faith in one's creed, scriptures and the manner in which a believer interprets and understands the divine message.

For Kanak, it's her faith that is to be woven into a situation, whereby to be called upon to be in role of Parvati in Uma Shankar's wedding is a divine move ,which will help her to access to the one who usurped her Bhabo's shop. Her faith chivvies her along to dress up in the required costume of goddess of Parvati. For Uma it's a clear sign from the gods that this girl kept crossing paths with him and she is chosen to be his life partner. For Maasi too, this wedding is seen as a gift fromLord Shiva to Uma for his ardent worship of his Lord. For Suman and Palomi too , It's a matter of their faith that this marriage is unlikely to happen, as the chances are the girl will disagree to this marriage. For Palomi, she has lost the race to win over Uma's love. Not even Maasi takes into account her silent love for Uma, its dismissed as not all dreams are fulfilled! Such is how providence writes people's fate ,all have to accept the dictates of faith! Even young Shiv can see that it's no coincidence that Kanak is destined to marry his brother! Kanak is surrounded by people like Palomi , Suman ,Saraswati who all believe that this is no amateur dramatics but reality.. there is a wedding taking place and she as the bride in role is bride in reality!

Gross misunderstanding! Kanak speaks the truth before all, her real purpose in donning the role. But Things get serious for Kanak when she realizes that her yes to the role of Parvati is not limited to play acting but a real life wedding scenario where she is expected to marry some guy Uma Shankar who she known's not from Adam! The women had done enough talking now, Uma dressed as the groom has to literally get up and confront Kanak and her conflicting views. He forces her hand, clearly, pushing her publicly before all to do something that one she is not inclined to do otherwise. As far as he can see by god's will they both have been ordained to be married as husband and wife! Where religious beliefs come across opposition by human and civil rights! Kanak accuses him of doing anything in the name of his lord!! She looks with ridicule at the mute masses! She is the only one who is and will defend herself! Kanak can see that no one daren't question creed! For no one wants to be condemned as a blasphemous and profane ! It's too risky! Besides all the bystanders are devotees of the same god she supports too.. but her lord Shiva is also just , merciful and compassionate! His force takes into account a believer's vulnerability!Uma attempts to assure her she is the only woman! one he has looked at! But Kanak fights back! many men have looked at her too , did it mean? that god meant for her to marry all of them! She cannot see the rationale in this man! All she can feel is the horrid term of being coerced into a forced marriage!! This man lives in the dark ages! Heretical in his beliefs! Recognizes and respects not, that where either one or both people do not give their consent for marriage it is seen as forced marriage! That operates outside the law of the land! Here one can see the dangerous division between understanding and interpreting the scriptures at logger heads with human rights! With the crowd cussing her! Kanak motivated by her inner sense of what is right and wrong walks away from this proposal she rejects vociferously, and publically! Uma stops her again.. this time using the lines that they were destined to meet and wed.. he fights his case calmly. Force must not be applied. Rather talk her out of her decision, like he did with Payal. He hopes the box of her belongings, her memories that he went by, at arriving at the conclusion that she is the one ordained for him, will impress her, that he is far from fluke! Her garland ,in kerala, her bangle, and his ring on her finger! and her being here today, colored in vermillion and both of them captured in the one garland.. is a sure sign of the gods their marriage has been decreed by the heavens! Kanak appears to sway, by the exhibits and the recount of fresh events.. will she be convinced by the two edged sword of destiny and religion that he holds above her head?? Plus his wooing , he knows all he needs to know about her..smooth operator..a master of oratory is the imposing Uma Shankar. No! means no! Kanak is not impressed by his arguments.. yes she is overwhelmed! But for her this whole wedding is not some work of divinity!! Kanak churns up the issue of mutual consent for marriage.. how come god only gave him a signal, but failed to give her the same sign?? Well Uma has a way out of her questions, they both have been given the same sign from god.. the only difference is he is able to discern it, while she fails to comprehend it!Is Uma playing with words to gain what he wants? is saving his face before the crowd, and his family part of his battle with Kanak too?? he beavers on in convincing her.. she was becoming a spectacle, and showing signs of cracking up! Men were cat calling for some use of force!! Kanak has to give her decision! Sorry! she cannot go through this strange, coerced ceremony ! she strangely feels duped! caught into a situation! She does not believe in this kind of forced agreement..she makes her exit!

While he continues to give her the guilt that she is going against the signs of the gods!! But she rejects his pleas, he can marry someone else! She cannot marry him, let her go! Uma grabs her hand and orders her, he has chosen her! and he shuns her beliefs But tells her he believes in god's plan! and right now! he will fulfill gods plan! Uma forcibly carries her over his shoulder walks towards the mandap. Kanak slaps, bites, resists his assault which he and all around him see as carrying out the will of god... none speaks ..it would be going against their faith. A helpless woman is forced to be party to carrying out the will of the gods??

In his proud, mighty arms the circumambulations are conducted around the sacred fire before many witness, while Kanak quivers and squirms like a fish gasping to survive! Kanak screams in protest.. she receives her baptism of fire .. a severe ordeal! A test lumbered on her! she screams to the heavens.. surely this cannot be the doing of divinity?.. but then, the gods know why they allow such shocking mayhem?? For out sorry situations god makes room for redemption of two souls made for each other.Uma will put the sacred mangalsutra around Kanak.. she tells him. She does not give consent to this marriage ,which stands as a forced one! She flees straight to a public phone booth!

Yes it was an episode, bold and controversial.. to question someone's faith is not a comfortable idea as people feel very strongly about their personal beliefs and convictions. Also the whole issue of forced marriage was tackled with the in your face approach to show the impact boldly. May I add that issue of forced marriages is not just limited to one area of the world but is practiced in many countries under the canopy of child marriages too. hamlet53 26.4.17

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

48

Frequent Posters

SilverBell thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Wow..
Hammie Again Your Writing Just Magic.
I Didn't See The Episode. Don't Want Too.
Forceful Marriages Aren't My Kind.
Its Too Soon For K&S To Get Married.
and When They Did.. He Forced Her.. and That's Not Right In My Option.
Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Wow..
Hammie Again Your Writing Just Magic.
I Didn't See The Episode. Don't Want Too. ohhh come on just sit! and dekh! kankar gives as good as she gets... if nothing else his image gets a dent.,
Forceful Marriages Aren't My Kind.
Its Too Soon For K&S To Get Married.
look.. you dont want love shove happening slowly.. I want to hear them talking..hoping ofcourse he doesnt swamp her with his lectures!

and When They Did.. He Forced Her.. and That's Not Right In My Option.
this is such a profound line... hummm.. well methinks they will have to make room for each others veiws.. lovely to read your comment... much love hammie..

Anjali33 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Right from Sooraj n Sandhya's marriage, not a single marriage happened where both bride n groom were happy..😆
Uma forcing Kanak for marriage..It was horrible to watch..But but but..D people around them applauding n throwing flowers was even worse😕 I mean..R u ppl nuts or wat!!
Etna_Dia thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
What a beautiful analysis, really engaging... I am speechless. I highly appreciate your personal thoughts regarding faith and the role that it plays in our society. This made me ask myself the question: can we really condemn Uma and the people who assist at this wedding? Certainly, if we accept as standards the modern moral and the laws, what happened was so illicit, but at a closer look, seeing things from the other side, what Uma and the crowd did was not the result of pure evilness, but they acted according to their beliefs. When you grew up with a certain perspective of life, sometimes one can't not even visualize a different manner of seeing and understanding reality. How Uma will slowly accept a different point of view than his and admit that what he did to Kanak was unfair... this will be the charm of the journey ahead...
Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Anjali33

Right from Sooraj n Sandhya's marriage, not a single marriage happened where both bride n groom were happy..😆

Uma forcing Kanak for marriage..It was horrible to watch..But but but..D people around them applauding n throwing flowers was even worse😕 I mean..R u ppl nuts or wat!!


hellooo Anjali..😊 firstly love your Ved// Mayanak Arora..dp..😃..yes that's true but it lacked high drama which Uma/ kanak 's brimmed with.. regards people.. I suspect they were either held by his might or popular relgious flow.. there was not one strong enough to challenge what transpired ,except Kanak... thanks for reading and commenting , Anjali..lets see what's in store for Kanak,now that she has done a runner... love hammie
Hamlet53 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Etna_Dia


helloo Etna,,😊 how lovely to hear from you..
What a beautiful analysis, really engaging... I am speechless. I highly appreciate your personal thoughts regarding faith and the role that it plays in our society. This made me ask myself the question: can we really condemn Uma and the people who assist at this wedding? Certainly, if we accept as standards the modern moral and the laws, what happened was so illicit, but at a closer look, seeing things from the other side, what Uma and the crowd did was not the result of pure evilness, but they acted according to their beliefs. When you grew up with a certain perspective of life, sometimes one can't not even visualize a different manner of seeing and understanding reality. How Uma will slowly accept a different point of view than his and admit that what he did to Kanak was unfair... this will be the charm of the journey ahead...
wow.. you show your approval for my impressions ,so clearly.. mind you Etna.. commenting on creeds ,globally is like walking on egg shells..reactions have to be seen in the light of other factors. Uma and kanak's wedding.. followed all the basic formal faith requirements.. only the moral issue of mutual consent was.. not taken into account,thus showing faith and orthodoxical traditions in a negative light.. thanks for sharing your valuable thoughts Etna... love hammie

swansong thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Hammie hammie hammie,
Cant blv I m one day late to comment on this fantastic take.I loved loved loved loved n loved ur beginning para.faith vs humanity.faiths were bestowed upon humans to save humanity.but when someone gets blinded by faith, he forgets his actions are violating the laws or righteousness and humanity.as u say there is a thin line between this two concepts but I blv humanity comes first.cz faith rules are interpreted and delivered by human and the feeling of humanity ks what God gave me inside when he made me.this is direct in between me n him.no interpretors.I feel bad for polami, n worse for kanak.Uma shankar was as usual hot, resembling those Greek Gods.though he was acting villain here but never stopped eyeing him.

Keep writing hammie.love all of ur musings.
Edited by swansong - 8 years ago
NusiSg thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#9
Hammie brilliant as usual.. u put in some valid points how ppl are being hanged in ths modern age also on the name of religion. .
Well the forced marriage was not needed at all..n also that's not the only way left fr leads union..bt I wonder y cv's chose ths way... they might want to highlight ths practices done in our societies commonly .. khair.. we've seen already US can cross any limit n sacrifice anything on the name of religion. .wat he did with payal was absolute disgust n now wat he did with kanak is plain brutal n heinous. ..at least in ths modern age we can't accept ths sort of atrocities... it's jst like ston someone to death fr blasphemy!
the dangerous division between understanding and interpreting the scriptures at logger heads with human rights

Well u absolutely nailed it here ham..US a has a long way to redemption n kanak seems not ready at all right now bt it will be interesting to watch their journey frm now on..!!

Love reading here n seeing ur threads being recognised by readers. .ur hardwrk deserve every bit of appreciation without a doubt. .happy writing mate..😳
swansong thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: NusiSg

Hammie brilliant as usual.. u put in some valid points how ppl are being hanged in ths modern age also on the name of religion. .

Well the forced marriage was not needed at all..n also that's not the only way left fr leads union..bt I wonder y cv's chose ths way... they might want to highlight ths practices done in our societies commonly .. khair.. we've seen already US can cross any limit n sacrifice anything on the name of religion. .wat he did with payal was absolute disgust n now wat he did with kanak is plain brutal n heinous. ..at least in ths modern age we can't accept ths sort of atrocities... it's jst like ston someone to death fr blasphemy!
<font color="#cc0000">the dangerous division between understanding and interpreting the scriptures at logger heads with human rights</font>

Well u absolutely nailed it here ham..US a has a long way to redemption n kanak seems not ready at all right now bt it will be interesting to watch their journey frm now on..!!

Love reading here n seeing ur threads being recognised by readers. .ur hardwrk deserve every bit of appreciation without a doubt. .happy writing mate..😳



Badi k bacchi k amma, kaha mar gyi thi?
Hammie unresd ur post plz annotate.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".