broom mistake

hey guyz in book 5 when gred and forge soory fred and george r leaving hogwatrz they point their wandz at umbridgez office and say ACCIO BROOMZ whereas in book 6 when harry and dumbledore cum back and see da dark mark they had to hurry but instead of saying accio broomz they say accio rosmertaz broomz .

in book 5 freg and george when ordered the broomz harryz firebolt could have easily cum instead of fredz broom or viceversa.

i no it dusnt matter but still........

No dear.. They were calling their own brooms , Fred and George, I mean.
But Harry was calling somebody elses brooms so he had to specify it.

ya in book 6 they wanted rosmerta's brooms not theirs

i agree with bluelotus!
btw, in gof,harry shouted ACCIO FIREBOLT!


so why did not fred n george shout the names of their brooms? 😕 😆

Originally posted by: lakshmi ram

i agree with bluelotus!
btw, in gof,harry shouted ACCIO FIREBOLT!


so why did not fred n george shout the names of their brooms? 😕 😆

Could have been a Non-verbal spell. You have to concentrate on the article you desire and it comes to you.

yeah i agree wid bluelotus but mystica jk invnted and introduced ninverbal spellz ib bk 6 soo

Originally posted by: vivacious_virgo

yeah i agree wid bluelotus but mystica jk invnted and introduced ninverbal spellz ib bk 6 soo

There are lot of instances of non verbal spells. Sirius and Lupin use it in book 3 when they change Scabbers into Pettigrew. I think there are many other instances too when professors and others use non verbal spells. Rowling introduced it properly in Book 6 because Harry has to learn them only in year 6 not before.

Well, Hogwarts students learn about non-verbal spells in year 6. Fred and George were in their seventh year - so they would have already learnt and fully practiced non-verbal spells.

fred and george???? 😆 hmm.......something to think about!


😉

i agree with bluelotus and mystica 😃