Originally posted by: shrutibali
when asked by mini as to who shud be voted out...alisha named jolly and her reason was "she is a good singer but she doesnt work for me"
uuhh..question: if she is a good singer why doesnt she work for u????
seriously i am sure this woman judges on looks and not talent..jolly was GOOD yesterday and she even impressed anu malik...why doesnt alisha like her??
i agree! i really don't understand Alisha and MANY of her comments. But to me, her bias against Jolly also seems to stem from the fact that she got "direct entry" into the galas. I really don't understand why Alisha was so upset over her arrival (when they first introduced Jolly in II3)...I mean come on, the girl cleared all the auditions and piano rounds in II2 and EARNED her way into II2 Galas. Now it was unfortunate that she got so sick that she couldn't participate in a single gala, which is why Sony or Indian Idol (or whoever had the power) took the call and promised her a spot in II3 Galas. So what's the big shock? Maybe someone should have told the new judges about the "promise" given to Jolly earlier.
PS - I agree with Anu Malik that in II2, Jolly was NOT good. But man has she improved this time around!