Pia being redeemed? No way!

When the Dubai affair happened, and Pia was being a pest, I actually thought that the storyline could have been saved by showing that it was either all a dream on Pia's part after she hit her head, or it was a plan by her all the time to get Bani her rights as the beloved wife of Jai Walia.

I really thought that she could have been redeemed if she conffessed that her aim had been to make Jai suffer all along and to get him to realize that he did in fact love Bani ...remember he was still confused about his feelings towards her.

The character of Pia up to that point had been one of a selfish sister who was spoilt beyond reason by a doting sister who assumed the roles of both mother and father... We all loved the sisterly genuine love that existed among them and tolerated Pia's antics.

So it was quite reasonable to expect the outgoing Pia hatch a plan to have Jai believe that he had committed adultery and live in fear of losing the love of his life, Bani because of her love for her sister

However, the writers made Pia into such a despicable character... one who was immoral, bitchy, scheming, disloyal, cunning, contriving....a total neemakharam... the list is endless.Her attitude towards Bani sent us into shock... we wanted to literally kill her!

We could not above all stomach an incestuous relationship between Jai and Pia....perhaps we may have tolerated an affair between Jai and Roshni since he considered himself divorced....

To try and redeem Pia now is totally hopeless... We may at some point feel sorry for her, but the truth is that unless Jai is totally redeemed and we are showh the the ONS did not in fact take place and that perhaps Pushkar or anyone else is the father ( if she is indded pregnant) we will never accept Pia's redemption.

First we need to see a total redemption of Jai and all the disgusted members of this forum may return and the revered ratings will once again rise.

Absolutely, agree with everything you have said.
The writers destroyed Pia's character with the ONS and with their characterization of her post ONS. She is absolutely irredeemable. I can't even stand seeing her on screen. The memory of how disgusting, vile, despicable, immoral, the list can go on is too fresh to think of her in any kind of positive light.

Maybe if she had some incurable tumor and I knew that she would die then maybe I might consider forgiving her disgusting behaviour.

Yes it is the story of 3 sisters but who said they all have to be alive or living near each other. In real life do we see out married adult relatives this much?

Redeemption of Pia, an impossible thing in all probability, the only person who needs to be completely redeemed is Jai Walia, from the who ONS rape fiasco and being the father of Pia's child (which is so disgusting, a man father the kids of two sisters one in love and one b being raped🤢)

The only way to redeeem Pia, by getting rid of Pia's character once and for all, death would be her redeemption. By dying she clears Jais name.

The TRPs always take always go down or more like take a dive downwards when ever she is around, even if she is not in the frame with them or in them. Its so clear that the audience, the viewers donot wnat to see her at all.

Thus redeem Jai and thus kill of Pia, as her killinng herself will be her redeemption and nothing else.

Love

Krishna

Originally posted by: scifichick

The writers destroyed Pia's character with the ONS and with their characterization of her post ONS. She is absolutely irredeemable. I can't even stand seeing her on screen. The memory of how disgusting, vile, despicable, immoral, the list can go on is too fresh to think of her in any kind of positive light.

would the same be said if she was splitting up eg. Rano and Sahil, rather than Jai and Bani...?

somehow i doubt it.

agreed, she is everything you say above, but relatives have done worse in other shows, yet the vitriol spewed against them has been far less than against this character?

rather than her character, i'm inclined to believe that this is because of who her evil intentions were aimed at.

Originally posted by: kubare

Redeemption of Pia, an impossible thing in all probability, the only person who needs to be completely redeemed is Jai Walia, from the who ONS rape fiasco and being the father of Pia's child (which is so disgusting, a man father the kids of two sisters one in love and one b being raped🤢)

The only way to redeeem Pia, by getting rid of Pia's character once and for all, death would be her redeemption. By dying she clears Jais name.

The TRPs always take always go down or more like take a dive downwards when ever she is around, even if she is not in the frame with them or in them. Its so clear that the audience, the viewers donot wnat to see her at all.

Thus redeem Jai and thus kill of Pia, as her killinng herself will be her redeemption and nothing else.

Love

Krishna

can't agree with you more. In today's episode Pia took 180 degree turn and said nice stuff for her sisters and love blah blah,which is very difficult for me to digest. She never ever realized her mistakes, in fact she was proud of it. I agree with you, only death can redeem reptile's character.

pia redemption not now not ever, yeah jai cud have been redeemed in a gr8 way but all this nonsense of pia being redeemed is impossible....she always want jai & his money

Redemption of pia is really Impossible because creatives are very badly destroy her character.even viewers donot want to see her on screen.neither her good side nor her bad side(defenatily not).it was not shown yet that she is relizeing her mistakes.
For viewers point of view nobody intersed in pia's redemption.they only want Jai's redeption.which is also seems impossible right now beacause Pushkar is ready to become foster father of Pia's kid(jai's kid)
EVERYTHING IS IMPOSSIBLE IN KS NOW

Redemption implies that her actions were to some extent justified...
Thuis can never be so. The original character of Pia may be forgiven but the creatives turned her into a monster.
If she had committed the act with Ranveer, Sahil, Tony, anyone else, she could have perhaps been forgiven. But Bani has always been willing to give her life for her and to do that to her is unforgivable.
Jai also is like a father figure to her so it makes it even more offensive.... incestous.
Pia hurt Jai so much when she rejected his love. Now when she selfishly wants it she is ready to destroy his and Bani's life. We cannot stomach that.
That is not to say that her character cannot atone for her sins and change.
She can be forgiven to a little extent.... But total redemption? Never!