Kareena vs Priyanka vs Vidya

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

Parineeta

Paa

Kahaani

The sky is pink

Kismat Connection (It’s not even bad and doesn’t deserve to be in same category as other 2 craps.)

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA I liked paa film most but pc's role in aitraaz was great

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI all are amazing

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

Parineeta

Aitraaz

Jab We Met

The Sky Is Pink

For Priyanka's iconic role I would put Barfi instead of Fashion. It is a shame, she didn't win awards for that iconic performance.

On topic:

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

Vidya was pitch perfect in that movie. KKK was good in Refugee, solid debut. PC unfortunately had a pretty small role in a forgettable movie, but she made a mark.

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA

PC was hands down amazing.

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI

Although KKK was iconic in that role but Vidya made Kahaani. I would put PC's Barfi here instead of Fashion and she was pretty amazing.

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

Hands down PC.

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

Vidya's worst is anyday better. PC had pretty bad roles in romantic comedies aka Aap Ki Khatir etc. KKK except MPKDH, has not had as bad roles.

I would like to choose Kareena in MPKDH as the most WTF role, but unfortunately, I think I have seen her acting like that in a few other movies 😆

You guys, I totally should have put Barfi in there instead, eek. Forgive me.

Bonus Rounds:

2009-2010

KURBAAN vs KAMINEY vs ISHQIYA

2010-2011

WE ARE FAMILY vs 7 KHOON MAAF vs NO ONE KILLED JESSICA

2011-2012

HEROINE vs BARFI vs THE DIRTY PICTURE

2015-2017

UDTA PUNJAB vs BAJIRAO MASTANI vs TUMHARI SULU

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

Best Debut:

REFUGEE vs THE HERO vs PARINEETA

(Didn't feel like it was her first movie)

Best Breakthrough:

CHAMELI vs AITRAAZ vs PAA

(Paa wasn't really a role where Vidya had much to do.. Chameli is overrated)

Iconic Role:

JAB WE MET vs FASHION vs KAHAANI

(Vidya ate everyone in this one)

Latest Role:

GOOD NEWWZ vs THE SKY IS PINK vs SHERNI

(haven't seen any of them)

*Bonus* Best WTF role:

MAIN PREM KI DIWANI HOON vs LOVE STORY 2050 vs KISMAT KONNECTION

(Kismat Konnection wasn't anywhere near the other two)

Originally posted by: Rekha_ji

Bonus Rounds:

2009-2010

KURBAAN vs KAMINEY vs ISHQIYA

2010-2011

WE ARE FAMILY vs 7 KHOON MAAF vs NO ONE KILLED JESSICA

2011-2012

HEROINE vs BARFI vs THE DIRTY PICTURE

2015-2017

UDTA PUNJAB vs BAJIRAO MASTANI vs TUMHARI SULU

haven't seen UP or TS