Why alia couldn’t match deepika, katrinas peak?

Lack of good looks or aura?

She was able to get all the best opportunities by why did she fail to make it as big? 
Seems like for actresses, acting will always be secondary..you need the glamour quotient to be a true superstar.

She doesn't grab your attention like Kat or Deepika would, the IT factor.

Alia failed because she just doesn't stand out, either in looks, acting, or screen presence. Her acting is bearable and not exceptional. Looks wise, she is average and screen presence is also average. She can't capture the imagination like Deepika could/does.

Having said that, Alia is better than Katrina. 

Katrina - 0 in acting + 9 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 7 in acting + 9 in looks+ 10 in screen presence

Alia - 7 in acting + 4 in looks+ 6 in screen presence

These are just my rankings based on my personal opinion.

there is something about Kat &DP that grabs your attention. Call it looks, call it glamour, I dk. But there is something about them. 

&this is from a non-fan. 

Originally posted by: mintyblue

Alia failed because she just doesn't stand out, either in looks, acting, or screen presence. Her acting is bearable and not exceptional. Looks wise, she is average and screen presence is also average. She can't capture the imagination like Deepika could/does.

Having said that, Alia is better than Katrina. 

Katrina - 0 in acting + 9 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 7 in acting + 9 in looks+ 10 in screen presence

Alia - 7 in acting + 4 in looks+ 6 in screen presence

These are just my rankings based on my personal opinion.

Agree with you! Plus KJo babysitting Alia and gift wrapping her all the handpicked roles might have a small effect as well.

For me, 

Katrina - 1.5 (0 in hindi and 2 in acting) in acting + 7 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 6 in acting + 9 in looks+ 9 in screen presence

Alia - 6 in acting + 3 in looks+ 5 in screen presence

'X' factor *pun intended* 😛

Because she looks like a pre-pubescent boy. 

Originally posted by: Sharpener

Because she looks like a pre-pubescent boy. 

So true 🤣

Ranbir Kapoor would interpret the word peak in a different way when it comes to these three gals 🤣