Why alia couldn’t match deepika, katrinas peak?

shareShare facebook twitter
Posted: 5 months ago


Lack of good looks or aura?

She was able to get all the best opportunities by why did she fail to make it as big? 
Seems like for actresses, acting will always be secondary..you need the glamour quotient to be a true superstar.

Posted: 5 months ago

She doesn't grab your attention like Kat or Deepika would, the IT factor.

Posted: 5 months ago

Alia failed because she just doesn't stand out, either in looks, acting, or screen presence. Her acting is bearable and not exceptional. Looks wise, she is average and screen presence is also average. She can't capture the imagination like Deepika could/does.


Having said that, Alia is better than Katrina. 


Katrina - 0 in acting + 9 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 7 in acting + 9 in looks+ 10 in screen presence

Alia - 7 in acting + 4 in looks+ 6 in screen presence


These are just my rankings based on my personal opinion.

Posted: 5 months ago

there is something about Kat &DP that grabs your attention. Call it looks, call it glamour, I dk. But there is something about them. 


&this is from a non-fan. 

Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by mintyblue


Alia failed because she just doesn't stand out, either in looks, acting, or screen presence. Her acting is bearable and not exceptional. Looks wise, she is average and screen presence is also average. She can't capture the imagination like Deepika could/does.


Having said that, Alia is better than Katrina. 


Katrina - 0 in acting + 9 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 7 in acting + 9 in looks+ 10 in screen presence

Alia - 7 in acting + 4 in looks+ 6 in screen presence


These are just my rankings based on my personal opinion.


Agree with you! Plus KJo babysitting Alia and gift wrapping her all the handpicked roles might have a small effect as well.


For me, 

Katrina - 1.5 (0 in hindi and 2 in acting) in acting + 7 in looks+ 7 in screen presence

Deepika - 6 in acting + 9 in looks+ 9 in screen presence

Alia - 6 in acting + 3 in looks+ 5 in screen presence

Posted: 5 months ago

'X' factor *pun intended* smiley17

Posted: 5 months ago

Because she looks like a pre-pubescent boy. 

Posted: 5 months ago

Originally posted by Sharpener


Because she looks like a pre-pubescent boy. 

So true smiley37

Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Salman Khan 's peak or SRK 's peak.Who had more stardom???

pencil Shikhar3   stackexchange 33   eye 1910

Shikhar3 33 1910 5 months ago Maroonporsche
Deepika Should refer Alia as Alia Ma'am.

pencil Twinklingmoon   stackexchange 8   eye 992

Twinklingmoon 8 992 1 months ago Twinklingmoon
I couldnt stand Naina

pencil InspectorShirke   stackexchange 8   eye 1335

InspectorShirke 8 1335 2 months ago Shailesh_Rathi
Why salman bhai why????????

pencil ght_shona_4evr   stackexchange 42   eye 5029

ght_shona_4evr 42 5029 4 months ago TMKOC_MY
Which Singer Peak You Have Enjoyed More?

pencil Arsalan_khan   stackexchange 6   eye 283

Arsalan_khan 6 283 28 days ago --Ariana--

Topic Info

9 Participants 8 Replies 567Views

Topic started by vsbarry

Last replied by Veni-Vidi-Vici

FORUM QUICK JUMP

up-open TOP