Battle of hydespass

luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

A blog dedicated to Alexander the Great. Posts may be occasionally interrupted by moments of silent awe. Because one blog isn't enough: thesecondachilles.com

Plutarch - Life of Alexander - 60

The Hydaspes (Jhelum) River today

In May 326 B.C., Alexander arrived at the bank of the Hydaspes River*. On the other side, stood King Porus' army. History seemed to be repeating itself for it was at the same time of year in 334 that Alexander had ridden up to the bank of the Granicus River just as the Persian army waited for him on the other side.

Two things, however, were certainly not the same. Firstly, the Hydaspes was a much larger river than the Granicus. It would require boats to cross. Secondly, Porus' army was larger - literally, for it included elephants.

Porus' men kept a close watch on the river. Alexander would have known that if he tried to cross the river opposite them, the Indian soldiers would have all the time they needed to pick his men off.

So, Alexander adapted his tactics accordingly. At the Granicus he had used main force against the Persians. At the Hydaspes, he employed cunning.

Firstly, he got the Indians used to his presence by the simple expedient of making a lot of noise. Then, one night, Alexander lead a part of his infantry and the best of his cavalry' up river and crossed it to an island.

A storm over Unna in Germany

A 'violent storm' broke out and several Macedonians were killed after being struck by lightning. The rain fell so heavily that the Hydaspes was put into high flood. Despite this, Alexander still managed to reach the opposite bank.

Plutarch says that it is

... on this occasion that Alexander is said to have exclaimed, 'O you Athenians, will you ever believe what risks I am running just to earn your praise?'

which frankly does not sound like the kind of thing Alexander would say. I certainly can't think of any other occasion when he made a similar comment.

* The modern day Jhelum River

A Matter of Sources
If I have read Plutarch correctly, his account of Alexander's arrival at the Hydaspes and his subsequent actions comes from Alexander's own letters, while his account of the crossing to the island is derived from Onesicritus. I don't know if I have picked the right point where Plutarch moves from Alexander to Onesicritus but it is clear when he shifts back to the king again, for he says that

... according to Alexander's own account, the Macedonians left their rafts [at the island] and waded across the breach* in full armour, up to their chests in water.

Once he had reached the far side, Alexander rode for two miles to meet Porus' army. Along the way,

... [h]e was attacked by a thousand of the enemy's cavalry and sixty of their chariots.

This detachment was swatted aside. Upon hearing of the Macedonians' approach, Porus set out to meet his enemy. Mindful, though, that the rest of Alexander's army still stood on the opposite side of the river, he left enough men behind to stop their crossing and attacking him in the rear.

* The flood water had created a channel between the island and opposite bank

The Battle of the Hydaspes River
Plutarch jumps straight into the midst of the battle. Here is how it unfolded.

  1. Alexander attacked Porus' left wing
  2. On the king's orders, Coenus attacked Porus' right wing
  3. Porus' army on both flanks was routed
  4. The Indian soldiers on the left and right fell back - against the elephants and their comrades in the centre
  5. This must have caused confusion and at least some disorder, but Porus' men now rallied and put up 'stubborn' resistance
  6. A long battle ensued
  7. The Macedonians won

Plutarch gives Alexander's letters as his source for the battle.

King Porus
At first glance, there would not seem to be much to connect Porus to Eazy E, the late rap star who was a member of the seminal rap group NWA. However, while Porus was as tall - 'about six and a half feet' according to Plutarch - as Eazy E was small - according to the lyrics for Gangsta, Gangsta - both had something in common - they were built like tanks. Of Porus, Plutarch says

... his size and huge physique made him appear as suitably mounted upon an elephant as an ordinary man looks on a horse.

Unfortunately for Porus, though, he proved rather more easy to hit than Eazy E. As the battle progressed, the king was struck by numerous spears. But just as Eazy E could rely on Ice Cube for help while they were 'cold running [sic] shit', Porus had his elephant which, realising that his master was weakening, knelt down to prevent him from falling off, and pulled the spears out of his body with his trunk.

Eazy E

Aftermath
Once the battle was over, Alexander approached Porus. How do you wish to be treated? he asked him. "As a king. Porus replied

... and when Alexander went on to ask whether he had anything more to say, the reply came, 'Those words, "as a king, include everything.'

So, Alexander gave him everything - his kingdom plus another province for good measure.

Plutarch concludes the chapter with a satrapal appointment. 'Philip, one of the companions' was given a satrapy, 'three times the size' of Porus' domain, to rule.

There can be no question that Alexander treated Porus with great respect in given him back his kingdom but it's hard to avoid the conclusion that Philip's appointment was designed to keep an eye on him and keep him in check.



Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.3k

Users

3

Likes

8

Frequent Posters

luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

CROSSING THE RIVER

In order to keep Porus unaware of his crossing, Alexander left Craterus in camp with a sufficient force and orders not to cross himself until later. One story tells of Alexander leaving a soldier dressed as the king to further confuse Porus. Alexander took with him part of the Companion cavalry, the mounted archers, and several infantry units under Hephaestion, Perdiccos and Demitrios. The crossing was to be in three waves. In order to safely cross the river Alexander made rafts from tents and used the thirty galleys and boats from his crossing of the Indus River. In total he crossed with an estimated 15,000 cavalry and 11,000 infantry. Unfortunately, the crossing did not go as smoothly as he had hoped. Alexander was surprised that instead of reaching the opposite shore he landed on a large island in the middle of the river. From the island to the other side, his men would have to wade across. Of course, there is some disagreement on whether or not Alexander knew of the island - it could have been a mistake or it may have been on purpose. Many do not believe the existence of a large island would have been something Alexander could have missed.

After reaching the shore at dawn, Alexander regrouped his army into battle formation and prepared for his meeting with Porus. The Companion cavalry was stationed in front of the infantry (not all of the infantry had crossed as they would join Alexander later) while the mounted archers served as a defensive screen against the elephants ahead of the cavalry because Alexander was reluctant to have his cavalry advance without protection. Scouts for Porus had already seen the Macedonian's crossing and informed the Indian king of Alexander's arrival. Porus prepared to retaliate.

BATTLE

In a futile attempt to delay Alexander, Porus sent his son with 3,000 cavalry and 120 chariots. This attempt spelled disaster for Porus. Alexander killed the son and destroyed the cavalry and chariots; the few survivors fled back to Porus. Arrian, who most believe has the most accurate account of the battle, addressed this confrontation:

...and the Indians, seeing Alexander there in person and his massed cavalry coming at them in successive charges, squadron by squadron, broke and fled ... Porus' son being among the killed; their chariots and horses were captured as they attempted to get away...

Without waiting for the additional infantry to cross, Alexander advanced the six miles towards the Indian camp where he would wait for the remainder of his infantry to arrive. "Alexander had no intention of making the fresh enemy troops a present of his own breathless and exhausted men, so he paused before advancing to the attack. (Arrian). Since most contemporary sources are lost, there is considerable disagreement from later historians over the facts of the battle. However, there is agreement on how Porus prepared to meet the Macedonian army, placing his best weapon, the elephants, on his front line ahead of his infantry. The Indian cavalry was situated on the right and left flanks screened by the six-man chariots. In the middle was Porus astride his elephant.

Alexander the Great in Combat

As with his other battles in Greece and Persia, Alexander relied on many of the same techniques that had proven successful. Most sources agree that Alexander, stationed on the right, used the Companion cavalry to attack Porus' flanks while his horse archers pelted the elephants with arrows. Coenus, whose initial location is uncertain, attacked Porus' right flank while Alexander assaulted his left. In a defensive maneuver Porus sent his cavalry from the right to circle back and help his left against Alexander. Next, Porus, who awaited help from his ally King Abisares of Kashmir, sent his elephants against the Macedonian phalanx. Slowly, the infantry pulled back but without breaking ranks as the horse-archers attacked with a barrage of arrows. Unfortunately for the Indian army, the elephants panicked and revolted, actually causing more harm to Porus' own men than to Alexander. Arrian wrote:

In time the elephants tired and their charges grew feebler, and with nothing worse than trumpeting. Taking his chance, Alexander surrounded the lot of them elephants, horsemen, and all and then signaled his infantry to lock shields and move up in a solid mass. Most of the Indian cavalry was cut down in the ensuing action; their infantry, too, hard pressed by the Macedonians, suffered terrible losses.

Meanwhile, Coenus circled around Porus' rear and attacked his left flank from behind. Porus' army fled straight into the waiting Craterus who had already crossed the river - 12,000 Indians and 80 elephants died to only 1,000 Macedonians.

PORUS CAPTURED & AFTERMATH

Throughout the battle King Porus remained on his elephant, despite suffering severe wounds, shocked to see his army flee but still reluctant to admit defeat and surrender. Alexander approached the proud, defeated king and asked him how he wanted to be treated - to which Porus responded that he wanted to be treated as a king. Alexander respected this and told Porus he would remain king, owing allegiance to Alexander. Plutarch wrote:

When Porus was taken prisoner, and Alexander asked him how he expected to be used, he answered, "As a king.' For that expression, he said, when the same question was put to him a second time, comprehended everything. And Alexander, accordingly, not only suffered him to govern his own kingdom as satrap under himself, but gave him also the additional territory of various independent tribes whom he subdued...

From Hydaspes Alexander continued on towards the Indian Ocean. Sadly, this final march would be without his beloved Bucephalus. The great horse who he had been with him since his youth had died - reportedly either from old age (he was over thirty) or battle wounds. Alexander would build a city in his honor, Bucephalia. Unfortunately, Alexander's march to the ocean would not go without challenge. His army finally won their own battle with the king, convincing him to return home. About this decision Plutarch wrote, "Alexander at first was so grieved and enraged at his men's reluctancy that he shut himself up in his tent and threw himself upon the ground...but at last the reasonable persuasions of his friends and the cries and lamentations of his soldiers...prevailed with him to think of returning. Alexander would return to Babylon where he would die in 323 BCE. Following his death, his vast empire would be the scene of a series of Successor Wars for the next three decades

Fruitcustard_9 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
I dont agree that king poras's army flee from d battle grounds, its wrongly written here, infact some of facts says after loosing many king poras army still wanted 2 fight but king poras refused. Some articles states even chanakya asked king puru not 2 fight alexander
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Seee that means the show will definitely complete its 260 episode run because its already 150 this week. And abhi anusuya ko chudayenge...army collect karenge and udhar alex soachega ki porus mar gaya. it will take around 10 more episodes...i am sure final war will include him standing at jhelum river and all of this stuff...it will be powerpacked...i have high hopes from siddharth sir, aakhir its his dream show.
luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: EtherealRati

Seee that means the show will definitely complete its 260 episode run because its already 150 this week. And abhi anusuya ko chudayenge...army collect karenge and udhar alex soachega ki porus mar gaya. it will take around 10 more episodes...i am sure final war will include him standing at jhelum river and all of this stuff...it will be powerpacked...i have high hopes from siddharth sir, aakhir its his dream show.


Haan love stories bhi to hain 😆 20-25 episodes uske bhi rakho
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Exactly puru laachi and roxane alexander...aur anu mil gayi toh anu bamni...sab chalegaaa 😆
luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
Shivdutt bhi lega hafta marne ke liye
EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: luckySnow

Shivdutt bhi lega hafta marne ke liye

Haan puru sabko maar kar...talwar de hi dega finally anusuya ke haath mein to kill shivdutt...i will never ger that she is a warrior...why in the world she doesnt attacks him herself...ab toh woh bhi jaanti hain ki porus alex se nipat raha hain...shivdutt ko toh woh nipta sakti hain.
Fruitcustard_9 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Cvs ko shivdutt se bahut pyar hai , i feel maybe shivdutt will run 2 alex & in end alex gift shivdutt 2 puru as token of frndship
luckySnow thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
President of India getting trolled poor man

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".