|firefliesHaven|MaNan AT#36|'I Am No Toy, You Are No Messiah' - Page 109

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

58k

Users

50

Likes

1.7k

Frequent Posters

charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: 13thwish

Harshad's back story.. I want to hear this too.. until then, I'm just not able to get a hold on his character.. of course his actions are inexcusable but I really need to understand the 'why' behind it all..

In my idle moments, I had this crazy theory regarding the band of brothers.. what if when they were kids, something bad happened/ was done to Harshad or someone really close to him by Dhruv during one of his attacks.. then to protect his buddy, Baba takes the blame on himself.. This would explain Harshad's focused hatred of Baba, and also give some reasoning for Baba's I like to be the villain and make Dhruv the 'hero' complex too..
I dunno.. call it my crazy imagination gone wild😆😆



The thing is Alya is super close with Manik and fab5 since 7th std, the girl is good , so I don't know if she would ahve hung around this crowd if they did something bad even accidentally to Harshad...all the accusations point towards Harshad's wrong and he has never denied them. Makes me feel he did something totally nonredeemable for Manik , who then backlisted him, which Harshad felt was unfair . Then with Alya leaving him too, he just felt lonely, and held on to the grudge for Manik as the one who stole it all from him.

But Manik's Harshad is a bad guy chant is very consistent and definite.

I always thought Manik's Parent complex for Dhruv comes from him doing something that night when the whole mess with Dhruv started- he sort of felt responsible , because it's too random how a 7 year old was around all of that.


Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake


I just hope they dont drag this Cabir drama too long.Ayaz is probably tired from juggling two shows but I am selfish I want Cabir back in Ky2, back to Fab5 and Nandini😭


Adhi, he will be in some MTV Reebok how too -- that shooting is over na?

Arre, exactly. They be just making Ayaz roam around in graveyards and hospital corridors, wooing a girl by his intelligence and humor or shouting for spirits and dead people at night -- it is a wanker hospital with bloody mary and zombies running around --😵
With so many characters with a story line going no where and everyone attracted to everyone -- it be going no where.Ayaz be giving more time to KY2.
Cat. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: OneThatGotAway

Dhruv questioned Manik ... yeh sab kya ho raha hai ?!

Why you little @^#^!/@^#^#&&#!^@//!


Ughhh gala na daba doon main iskaaa


Yaaarrr the ansoun pochnaaa scene ... i am dying to use it as my sigfy


The tune .. Nandu ke mote mote aansoun ..Baba's lil sarr hilake mana karna usko ronay se .. itne pyaar se aansoun poch dena ... and then Nandu holding onto his hands for a few milli seconds before removin em apne face se ...


And my fav bit was how .. Nandu was crying phoot phoot ke .. and she wasn't bothering to hide it and act all cool. I have always loved how honest Nandu has always been abt her feelings .. and that little bit was like Look what you did you idjit :( bachi hasti bhi khul ke and roti bhi ... uss mein confidence hai, apne ideals pe naaz hai .. parr BHARAM nahin hai .. hota toh she wouldn't have cried iss tarha openlu Manik ke samnse jab ke he knows he is the reason shes crying. Oh how I love Nanduuu


Nandu be so beautiful, I dont know how Manik can watch her crying, poor baby
Rafzzz🤗
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
@CC- Just STFU Harshad and his bird away. They are the gloom of this show.
@Rafs - Nandu is Boss, bas. She is like see my hurt, feel my pain and watch me cry, this is all thanks to you but you so ain't going to get it all in your thick skull .


charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
That Q-label thing isn't random, I think i should stop thinking about that possibility. 😆
Medha.S thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: zohasad2.0


I know.🤣..and btw sab log sun lo...I meant heaRt.


Arre we understand you Zoha bae ... but seriously, i bet half of the people who stalk the AT and wanna join are just so scared of the violence and aggression and people being asked to get out constantly that they be making their own groups and chats to discuss the tyranny going on MaNan AT ..


medha16 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: AnomanderRake


Maybe Navya's pregnancy will come out and Harshad will skip town and Navya will go back to her hometown for sometime. Ugh I was feeling bad for Navya right until even after she slept with Harshad even though she annoyed me but now, no way, she has sold her soul to the devil and my poor Baba ka beautiful haath they are eyeing😡😡😡


Navya is not naive and nw I dont even pity her.
She can be extremely sly when she wants to be...look at how she tricked mukti n alya so convincingly...and today, she had d presence of mind to look disheveled...she can go to any lengths for her harshadji and that's unhealthy...she has no qualms of hurting cabir or manik.
I just can't sympathize anymore...she n harshad are way out of that space now.
zohasad2.0 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: Medha.S


Arre we understand you Zoha bae ... but seriously, i bet half of the people who stalk the AT and wanna join are just so scared of the violence and aggression and people being asked to get out constantly that they be making their own groups and chats to discuss the tyranny going on MaNan AT ..



exactly...sometimes when I stalk silently I realize we are crazy.We talk anything BINDASS in a flow...not caring one bit and every newcomer comes up saying they were scared to enter coz we are always busy way too much amongst ourselves.😆
Edited by zohasad2.0 - 10 years ago
diva82 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: OneThatGotAway

Dhruv questioned Manik ... yeh sab kya ho raha hai ?!

Why you little @^#^!/@^#^#&&#!^@//!


Ughhh gala na daba doon main iskaaa


Yaaarrr the ansoun pochnaaa scene ... i am dying to use it as my sigfy


The tune .. Nandu ke mote mote aansoun ..Baba's lil sarr hilake mana karna usko ronay se .. itne pyaar se aansoun poch dena ... and then Nandu holding onto his hands for a few milli seconds before removin em apne face se ...


And my fav bit was how .. Nandu was crying phoot phoot ke .. and she wasn't bothering to hide it and act all cool. I have always loved how honest Nandu has always been abt her feelings .. and that little bit was like Look what you did you idjit :( bachi hasti bhi khul ke and roti bhi ... uss mein confidence hai, apne ideals pe naaz hai .. parr BHARAM nahin hai .. hota toh she wouldn't have cried iss tarha openlu Manik ke samnse jab ke he knows he is the reason shes crying. Oh how I love Nanduuu



It shows as well how much she does trust him, she is not sacred at all showing her vulnerable side and even lets him wipes her eyes but it wasn't enough for her, she needs more than that, too much has broken inside of her, she has been in pain. For the first time, Manik looked at the damage he has done.
I loved how he was so possessive about her in front of Dhruv, he just yanked her out of his arms, he didn't care for Dhruv's feelings anymore, the only thing mattered was Nandini.


I can't wait for your siggie. rafz 😳
Edited by diva82 - 10 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: medha16



Navya is not naive and nw I dont even pity her.
She can be extremely sly when she wants to be...look at how she tricked mukti n alya so convincingly...and today, she had d presence of mind to look disheveled...she can go to any lengths for her harshadji and that's unhealthy...she has no qualms of hurting cabir or manik.
I just can't sympathize anymore...she n harshad are way out of that space now.


This!!

If her naivety had some consistency , i could still understand her but she revels in Harshad's diabolical side , there is sort of reverence which is what puts me off.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".