Was Mani right in bringing Ruhi to the hospital?

vdna thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
How many think Mani was right in bringing Ruhi to the hospital without consent from Raman or Ishita...??
I didn't like that part ..He's a nice and concerned friend of Ishita ...but he should have asked Raman before bringing Ruhi in ...I'm sure if it was going to benefit Ishita Raman would have been OK with it ...and would have taken Ruhi in himself or would have thought of something else! ...
Mani should stop talking liberties with Ishita and Raman and invading their family privacy ..Ishita is a mature adult - a so called doctor herself for crying out loud! and it shouldn't take a child's plea to make her realize how important it is for to eat! ..
That was a pretty ridiculous - sensationalized drama ...just to sideline Raman ...Mani does not have rights over others kids' and if Raman as a parent has decided that it was in his child's best interests to stay home and not worry herself then his decision ought to be respected...
Ishita could have been told what the consequences would have been if she didn't eat ..and how Ruhi will suffer if she was ill for a long time ...they could have shown Mani talk to her about Ruhi instead of over extending his liberties and bringing Ruhi over without Raman's knowledge...
And he has such concern for a friend after so long ..and doesn't really seem concerned to check on his son and see how he's doing without him?

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

5.3k

Users

33

Likes

186

Frequent Posters

--Megha-- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Ishita Thanked him for getting Ruhi to the hospital so he was right.
Reina1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Ishita was unconscious and Raman was out of his own mind with worry, so he couldn't think properly. I am sure she was with the Bhalla's and Iyers who are equally her family. If they allowed her to go with Mani, I would regard as the same as her parents deciding.
Tanyaarora11 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Well! I honestly loved the episode. But two things did turn out to be glaring and one of them was this.
See, on one level I understand that you're feeling that he is invading the privacy and acting on his own. Maybe not Raman but they should have shown a scene where in he took permission from any elderly member to take Ruhi along. mani deciding all that himself was slightly inappropriate as far as boundaries go. Though, I feel CVs intended to show that he's meddling too much because what followed afterwards completely resonates our worries. Raman spelled it out, he did not like that bit and he bashed him left right centre. So yes, it was inappropriate but that was the whole point, because had he not crossed the line and went overboard taking a decision which honestly he had no right over then we would have left bereft of the awesome Mani- Raman face off!
momb24 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Mani should have asked raman,however it was good for ishita that ruhi came.
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Mani has thus far been shown to be so good that the cvs probably took it for granted that the audience, ie us, will realise that its a given that mani would have first taken balla senior, amma etc consent before bringing ruhi to the hospital.
Otherwise the cvs are implying that we the audience will naturally assume that, ...vandu discovers ruhi missing from the flat, has called the police and a delhi wide search is taking place for the raman kumar balla ceo of the year's missing, presumed kidnapped daughter😆

Besides which, if mani hadn't brought ruhi..how would we have seen the "eureka" moment ..."oh yeah!! ruhi can make ishita eat" look on raman's face??😆 Very quickly followed by the look that said..."oh sh*t"!! why didn't I think of that!!"😆
Mages thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
mani did the right thing by bringing ruhi to the hospital...otherwise ishu's health would have been worsen...neither she was listening to raman nor mani...she was being very stubborn...and we all know ruhi is ishu's strength and weakness...sometimes what husband...friend can't do...the daughter does it like a magic...ruhi is ishu's lifeline...mani did the right thing

secondly...ruhi was with Iyers...I am sure mani have asked permission from the Iyers to bring ruhi to the hospital...they might edited out the scene as usual...ruhi is Iyers grandaughter...while Iyers knows mani since childhood...they trust him

Edited by Mages - 11 years ago
sanaasr thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
he had no business being in the hospital, let alone bring ruhi to the hospital!
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
^^
You are right Mani had no right to be at the hospital, but if he hadn't been there then, ishita would be dead (oops! I forgot, she's the female lead...she'd be in a coma) because puttar didn't know the answers to the Dr's questions and the Dr's couldn't give her the correct treatment. Also then appa instead of mani would have had to drive home to fetch ishita's medical file and had a crash coz he was in such an emotional state, run over adi or maybe the kid of the suraj half of poplu and bhoplu brothers.

Then the poplu and bhoplu brothers would have taken appa to court but appa would not have been able to defend himself coz he got injured in the car crash. Puttar would not be able to help either...sadly...😭 coz...

Puttar would be in jail for assult and grevious bodily harm to union members. Pathak has disappeared so who would get puttar released??😕 See...mani is needed here too...maybe pathak too is hiding where mani's kids are hiding. Now coz only mani knows where his kids are, and his kids know where pathak is, mani is needed, otherwise bechara puttar in jail without a get out of jail card...alll coz mani wasn't at the hospital...😭

BUHHHTTT thank karvachauth, Mani was at the hospital, and he handled all the people and situations with maturity, kindness and consideration, including puttar...what was it he said to puttar...you stay with ishita...😳 So yeah...good job mani even though he had no right, was at the hospital!
Edited by Panthera - 11 years ago
BIaddict thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Ruhi coming to the hospital and making her Ishima eat= right
Mani deciding to bring Ruhi to the hospital without Raman's permission = wrong

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".