Was Mani right in bringing Ruhi to the hospital? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

5.3k

Users

33

Likes

186

Frequent Posters

Jelly-bean thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: anjs


very good point Divu...



Thanks 😳
anjs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: attubaby

Mani brought ruhi to hospital...ishita felt good nd broke her fast too...so d decision turned out to b correct...but he shd hv taken permission from d family, which I thnk he had..as ruhi was home nd other family members were also at home


but he went from the hospital, and raman was there in the hospital...so why keep him (the father) in the dark...why not ask him first...cause he is ideally the only person mani shud be asking, apart from ruhi's mother who was un concious
amrithas thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#53
Its was not Mani's place nor was he right in bringing a six year old kid to emotionally manipulate a fully grown woman a doctor at that to eat. If she was being stubborn n Raman being stern here which I felt was justified was not working, Mani the concerned friend could have gently reminded her of Ruhi worrying back at home. I dont think its pleasant onscreen nor offscreen to see someone acting oversmart n show a person how to deal with his own family. If only her had the grace to step back after being insolent enough to get ruhi to the hospital and let Raman take over with handling his wife n daughter, he could be redeemed in my eyes atleast. No but this self righteous person was sidelining the man in their life displaying how great he was at handling all this n had to cross all boundries by voicing it too. Totally n completely wrong he was.
582445 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#54
I didn't get the point .. it is very easily assumable that Mani has taken Ruhi with the permission of elder's of Ruhi's family .. I guess in India elders of family can the decision for a kid just like his/her parents .. certainly Mani has not kidnapped her .. then what's the issue?? when elsers have allowed Ruhi to go with Mani they know it is the right thing to do .. simple .. Mani wasn't wrong at all ..
kathzyna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#55
Mani was right bringing Ruhi to the hosp[ital just because she is young does't mean she needs to be lied to constantly .She has every right to see her mother even she thanked Mani uncle who treated her as an equal and didn't cushion her from reality it's going to build character in a child she doesn't have to hold emotions in too afraid to express it.
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#56
^^
Ek kahaavat hai...pait mai dard 😵 aur sirr peeting. Yahan bhi aisa hi kuch hai.😆

Hospital rules and possible differences across the world.🤓...did mani ask elder's permission or not🤔... is elders permission enough😕...did mani kidnap ruhi 😡😆...should mani have asked raman's permisson🤓...shld a child be allowed in hospital or not...was there a significant possiblity that ruhi could have suffered PTSD from visiting her mom who is now recovering in hospital😲...should anyone but medical staff be feeding patients or not🤡...ishita is a dr, should she know better and not insist on fasting...😡 Is ishita a hypocite coz when amma (who was in a coma) was in hospital she said no bringing ruhi but now its ok (ishita is awake and recovering)
Could all have been accomplished over the phone or not...is raman bhalla a ceo😎, is mani the shani❓...is he mani, the shani AND naagmani ☢️...sab pait kar dard.😆

** passes round hajmola to everyone to aid digestion**😳

I just chill coz...Bottomline folks is that everything was set up to create that amazing scene between ishita and ruhi👍🏼 That kid who plays ruhi is an amazing actress! CVs took "artistic licence" with a few hospital related facts. Mani was shown to be not perfect, just sensible...he didn't kidnap ruhi😆. He obviously asked elders...and RUHI WAS SOOO GRATEFUL!! She THANKED him. 😳

In all this raman ko mirchi lagi AFTERWARDS. Because his FIRST reaction was..."OH YEAH!!!! Why didn't I think of that!! Ruhi can accomplish with ishita that which noone else can!!!" THAT expresssion of raman's in the next instant was followed by..."Oh sh*t!!! why didn't I THINK OF IT!!"😆

Brilliant episode, good acting by all involved...beti feeding maa... Maa beti hugg😭

Yaaras take hajmola and save your heads. We all know that raman and none of us would give a damn about ANY of these supposed bloopers, inconsistancies, right or wrongs of ruhi being there, if mani looked like ...appa or bhalla senior or murli...or mr kakkad and wasn't such a good friend to ishu😆


Edited by Panthera - 11 years ago
AroraTanya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#57
How did hospital authority permit Mani to bring Ruhi in the first place? Children are not allowed in hospitals.What a ridiculous scene!
AroraTanya thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: Panthera

^^
Ek kahaavat hai...pait mai dard 😵 aur sirr peeting. Yahan bhi aisa hi kuch hai.😆

Hospital rules and possible differences across the world.🤓...did mani ask elder's permission or not🤔... is elders permission enough😕...did mani kidnap ruhi 😡😆...should mani have asked raman's permisson🤓...shld a child be allowed in hospital or not...was there a significant possiblity that ruhi could have suffered PTSD from visiting her mom who is now recovering in hospital😲...should anyone but medical staff be feeding patients or not🤡...ishita is a dr, should she know better and not insist on fasting...😡 Is ishita a hypocite coz when amma (who was in a coma) was in hospital she said no bringing ruhi but now its ok (ishita is awake and recovering)
Could all have been accomplished over the phone or not...is raman bhalla a ceo😎, is mani the shani❓...is he mani, the shani AND naagmani ☢️...sab pait kar dard.😆

** passes round hamjola to everyone to aid digestion**😳

I just chill coz...Bottomline folks is that everything was set up to create that amazing scene between ishita and ruhi👍🏼 That kid who plays ruhi is an amazing actress! CVs took "artistic licence" with a few hospital related facts. Mani was shown to be not perfect, just sensible...he didn't kidnap ruhi😆. He obviously asked elders...and RUHI WAS SOOO GRATEFUL!! She THANKED him. 😳

In all this raman ko mirchi lagi AFTERWARDS. Because his FIRST reaction was..."OH YEAH!!!! Why didn't I think of that!! Ruhi can accomplish with ishita that which noone else can!!!" THAT expresssion of raman's in the next instant was followed by..."Oh sh*t!!! why didn't I THINK OF IT!!"😆

Brilliant episode, good acting by all involved...beti feeding maa... Maa beti hugg😭

Yaaras take hamjola and save your heads. We all know that none of us would give a damn about ANY of these supposed bloopers, inconsistancies, right or wrongs of ruhi being there, if mani looked like ...appa or bhalla senior or murli...or mr kakkad and wasn't such a good friend to ishu😆



I've been a silent reader in this forum most of the times and read many of your comments. I must say you loathe Raman to the core.😆😆
Panthera thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#59
^^
NO!! No I don't!!😲 This is only indian show I watch. Raman has some really good qualities. Most of the indian serials main male characters are complete and utter jackasses. I start watching and end up stopping very soon in sheer disgust!🤢

I don't fangirl over actors or fictional characters...dunno how😭😆 and raman crosses that line between taunting/insults and teasing wayyy too often. And I LIKE the scenes where he is on the right side of that line. The ishra interactions are lovely to watch then!😳

I have issues with how ishita too is often portrayed...but we won't go there right now!😕😆

I don't excuse or justify behaviours or just ignore it when it comes esp to the main leads. Also I don't throw red herrings.(blame another characters behaviour to draw attention away from raman, or vice versa).
..Or do "sirr peeting when pait hurting." And if I see a lot of it going on with raman right now...then well its an elephant in the room so to speak😆...and I point it out...can't have great big fat elephant in the room and everyones knows its there but everyone pretends its not there!

We all know that raman and we won't care a DAMN about ANY of the points raised here if mani didn't exist or wasn't,...well...Mani!!😆. Its got nothing to do with my disliking or liking raman.
Edited by Panthera - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".