Raja Sen lists his Best Actresses of 2012 - Page 11

Am okay with him being bias towards bebo.. that just shows that she's such a good actress that this guy is in love with her as an actress.  But  If he's so bias he would if included kat in this list since he likes her too.  Edited by beboholic - 11 years ago

wow 😳

Sridevi should be #1 on every list for English Vinglish.

Originally posted by: abby_girl30

I don't think it was fair to include Kareena twice...her heroine spot could have been given to PC for Barfi...he seems a little biased towards Bebo 😆

Kareena was OTT in Heroine but for a few scenes...crying, shouting and getting hyper does not automatically mean good acting...she was amazing in Talaash...calm and powerful... Lol...so Raja Sen is not BIASED because this is his list...his opinion...but if another critic puts Kat in the list...that critic will lose his credibility...that won't be his opinion and his list then??😆😆

Isn't it Best Actress list? Not best role list.So Kareena should be mentioned once with all her works this year listed together not separately.  Edited by DejaVu. - 11 years ago

I have to disagree with that PC was better than IIena.. I thought they were both equally good.. just because PC tried a challenging role doesn't make her better than IIena. I think IIena deserves to be up there.. take out Parineeta, Diana, and bebo should have on spot and PC should be included. But than this is Raja Sen's list.. not ours so we can't tell him his list is wrong it's his opinion.. it's not like even on this forum we agree on who was the top performers.. so why should Raja Sen have a list that satisfies everyone. Tomm a list will come out that leaves Kareena or Rani out... does thar mean that list is wrong? No. It's his or hers opinion of who they liked as performers. Edited by beboholic - 11 years ago

Originally posted by: blue-ice

</div>

Kareena was OTT in Heroine but for a few scenes...crying, shouting and getting hyper does not automatically mean good acting...she was amazing in Talaash...calm and powerful...

<div>

Lol...so Raja Sen is not BIASED because this is his list...his opinion...but if another critic puts Kat in the list...that critic will lose his credibility...that won't be his opinion and his list then??😆😆

You don't get it.
I'm not defending Raja Sen's list. I'm arguing the use of the word.
So lets get this straight.

You can accuse this list of NOT being credible - Fair
But the word biased does not make sense unless its for some reason other than acting.

If Katrina was on the list I would say its not credible, and that he's stupid. His opinion is retarded BUT unless he was screwing Katrina Kaif and only included her for those reasons, I would NOT call it bias.

Originally posted by: pathaka

disagree there.

Both had gr8 roles and performances but i wouldnt say sridevi's performance was hyped more coz shes a yesteryear actress. I feel sri had the edge because it was a far more nuanced performance...there were lots of little subtle gestures, expressions, the way she changed her body language to convey under confidence and confidence etc which add so much to the character and the performance... IMO none of the other actresses could have pulled that off. 

Originally posted by: desigal90

BUT unless he was screwing Katrina Kaif and only included her for those reasons, I would NOT call it bias.

What? How does that make sense?😕 Here is the dictionary definition of 'bias':
Edited by perfectlystill - 11 years ago

Originally posted by: beboholic

I have to disagree with that PC was better than IIena.. I thought they were both equally good.. just because PC tried a challenging role doesn't make her better than IIena. I think IIena deserves to be up there.. take out Parineeta, Diana, and bebo should have on spot and PC should be included. But than this is Raja Sen's list.. not ours so we can't tell him his list is wrong it's his opinion.. it's not like even on this forum we agree on who was the top performers.. so why should Raja Sen have a list that satisfies everyone. Tomm a list will come out that leaves Kareena or Rani out... does thar mean that list is wrong? No. It's his or hers opinion of who they liked as performers.