FRANKENSTEIN. Criticism of Barun/PH.

Marybarton thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Moral of the story - don't bite off more than you can chew. This is not a bashing, hear me out. I can only speak in logic.

You guys, to your credit, built an incredible show/Frankenstein. But...can't slack when in the business of customer service. Viewers need to be pleased by the product at all times. That is what differentiates TV writing from book writing. You need approval/TRPs/etc.

It
doesn't mean you didn't work hard, but everyone has to be a part of this product (IPK) from start to finish. You can make great buttercream and ruin it at the very end with a drop of lemon as they say.

Barun was in his right to leave after the end of a contract, but when you break a leg of Frankenstein, it can't stand - as evidenced by this downfall. It would be good for him if he could put on his resume that he finished the show that makes him a name to recon with. What film producers want more than anything is dedication from start to finish, not dedication 90% of the time and leaving the rest high and dry just because the contract is over and you need a break. I am going to be harsh on Barun and I am sorry for it because he truly is a kind soul and a brilliant actor. SRK is SRK 100% of the time. He wakes up SRK and he goes to bed as SRK. He never clocks out, that's what makes a great Bollywood actor - insane amount of energy and a very giving family. Get on that bandwagon if you want to try your luck in films. SRK is a persona, the only way he retains the aura is through dedication. He has a personal life because he knows how to compartmentalize it. You could have make IPKKND speak for you by finishing it and then taking that break. Whatever the dissatisfaction, a true professional (like Sanaya), sees the end. I am sorry girls, but I cannot excuse the guy just because he's pretty.


The same thing would have happened if Sanaya decided to leave. This was not your typical show where any soap actor could be replaced. Sanaya and Barun, PH, SP, etc - you were creative enough to create more than that. Your unprecedented connection to the viewers had a price. It was the couple (Arhi) the viewers connected with, and ALWAYS had to be them and them alone.

With viewers, there is only one rule - you keep up the momentum, you keep the viewers. The audience is always right. If it falls short for whatever reason, it falls. The PH has a history of not being able to finish a project as well as it starts it because they can't juggle more than one show at a time. You can't compromise on the budget or commitment to one show just because there is another. PS the other one is looking quite good for now. Please don't repeat the cycle with that one. Again, show us the product well and we will buy. Don't tell us to just support you like you have these past few days.

Viewers are the customers, not the employers, so the burden of 200 families falls on the employers' shoulders. Hopefully the PH gainfully employs all those hurt by this cancellation. As a viewer, I can only wish you all well.


The brilliance of this couple will never be repeated again, that is what strikes me hard at the end of the day.


Mary
.



Edited by Marybarton - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

5.1k

Users

36

Likes

326

Frequent Posters

Forever19 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
actually the jodi outgrown than the show..this is exactly what happened..people watch the show for story,but ipk fans watched it for sarun..
Marybarton thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: arshiii12

actually the jodi outgrown than the show..this is exactly what happened..people watch the show for story,but ipk fans watched it for sarun..



Absolutely, it was always about the couple for the viewers. THEIR story, but the other way around.
Forever19 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Marybarton



Absolutely, it was always about the couple for the viewers. THEIR story, but the other way around.



well sizzling chemistry have negative effects too...ipk's fate proves it all..
Amanram thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Could not have said it better. Mirrors my feelings exactly. I have repeatedly sent e-mails / messages to PH and SP stating that they seems to be unaware that they created a phenomenon that they cannot handle anymore.
I just wish that this PH can learn from this IPKKND mess and not keep on their arrogant stand of 'Dekhna hein to Dekho'. they are brilliant at creating something unique and amazing but they seem to get lost along the way...
Edited by Amanram - 13 years ago
deepthis thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
If i have to be honest,IPK lost the story plot long time ago
and if people r still watching the show,then its only because of SaRun
and people saying otherwise,I dont know if they r watching the same show
And the latest 200 going around in the forum is really stupid
I mean cmon we hav not watched the show for those 200 people
Atleast i watched it for SaRun and if at the end of the day I dont get to see them I hav all the right to ask whatever i want.
So people cant seriously judge on what other people want

Girlabouttown thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
The brilliance of this couple will never be repeated again, that is what strikes me hard at the end of the day.

spot on👍🏼
Marybarton thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Amanram

could not have said it better. Mirros my feelings exactly. I just wish that this PH can learn from this episode and not keep on their arrogant stand of 'Dekhna hein to Dekho'. they are brilliant at creating something unique and amazing but they seem to get lost along the way...



I think the viewers of IPK were loud and clear on this one - NAHI DEKHNA.

So I hope they will be more considerate of the viewers in the future. As a writer, let me say, if I wrote a book, it would be according to my wish. If I wrote a TV show - according to the viewers' demand. Simplez.

Marybarton thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: deepthis

If i have to be honest,IPK lost the story plot long time ago

and if people r still watching the show,then its only because of SaRun
and people saying otherwise,I dont know if they r watching the same show
And the latest 200 going around in the forum is really stupid
I mean cmon we hav not watched the show for those 200 people
Atleast i watched it for SaRun and if at the end of the day I dont get to see them I hav all the right to ask whatever i want.
So people cant seriously judge on what other people want




Agreed. I feel for the 200 people who lost their jobs but we are not running their company here. We are buying the product they produce. That is why I think they would have had a stronger contract, like Ekta's 3 year one.

MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Your right Mary! This show was so good and the couple so sizzling that it became SO much bigger than PH, SP or even the actors ever thought it would be! ARSHI fever started to spread and people could not get ENOUGH of this couple!
The testimont is all the "Best Jodi" awards they have won! All the poll's they have won on every sight! These two are a FORCE of Nature! A Phenomenon! The PH and SP could not keep up with it! Finally when one of the actors wanted to move on, there was NO way to move forward! They thought they could, but the fans reacted VIOLANTLY to the idea of a new ASR or a NEW male lead that was NOT ASR!
ASR played by Barun had gained such cult status that they could not take the risk of bringing in another actor to play him! The alternative, which is killing his charachter was even MORE risky as SP started to see! Especially after SPL they saw the craze for ARSHI and SARUN and also ASR! They must have realized that splitting this Jodi was a HUGE mistake!
Therefore the final coup the grace! The ending of the show! If Sanaya left, the same would have happened, NO ONE would have accepted another Khushi and no one would have accepted the DEATH of Khushi and ASR having to meet someone else! The LOVE story of ARSHI was SO epic that the idea of one of them ending up with someone else, even out of necissity was an INSULT to the audience's sentiments!
Therefore, you are right! They created a moster and now it has gotten so big that the PH and SP have been crushed by it! I agree that ARSHI is a phenomenon that CANNOT be repeated! I will mourn the loss of my "Daily Dose"! But will take comfort if we see an end with them walking into the sunset together!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 1 years ago

Arnav and Khushi are back ...LOL It sounds incredible, yet they are doing one ad. Instagram Link

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".