I am not happy with Vipul's win.
I am not saying he is not a good singer. But Indian Idol should represent someone who...IMO has had some kind of struggle to overcome and in the end proves to be some kind of inspiration to others.
What struggle has Vipul had? He was born with a silver spoon in his mouth and then he already has had the experience of participating in a reality show.
IMO his victory is not only unfair but its not inspiring AT ALL!
I would rather have someone like Amit win rather than Vipul, because he has IMPROVED a lot. Look at where he was in the beginning and look at him now. THAT is a story, THAT is an inspiration. Besides, even though Amit does need more grooming and work, the talent that he DOES have is somethign that you cannot learn. It is divine and untouchable. Amit in his own style is untouchable!!!
Or even Dev whose so talented despite a young age.
I realize Vipul may be a better singer in some genres than Amit or Dev but, there is more to being an Indian Idol than being a good singer. You have to have a STORY behind you. What is Vipul's story? The grandfather thing? I dont even believe that to be honest.
I have NEVER agreed on any of the Indian Idol winners except Sourabhee. I strongly suggest the Indian Idol team to NOT renew for another season. This show is a disgrace. I am not even going to watch the finale.
Edited by DIDfan89 - 11 years ago