It was Shakthi's DECISION... not CV's - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.5k

Users

20

Likes

87

Frequent Posters

ccubedtab thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: rreya


Personally i would have wanted a new kriya rather than all these stupid twists but i agree that it would closed the option of bringing shakti back in the future...so if thats the reason CVs chose to end Kriya's character then its fine...

Having said that, i think even if they had showed kriya telling the exact truth to rey, they could have shown him accepting it slowly and moving on...coz in reality not all breakups end on a bitter note...a lot of breakups happen due to practical reasons/ parents/ family etc etc...and that does not mean that it wasn't true love or the people involved are losers...In my opinion such a breakup would have been more realistic as, in reality not many people are saints(like kriya) who would make such big sacrifices that nobody knows of and leave with so much hatred for herself...
And the possibility of kriya(shakti) coming back was open in this option as well... So i think this would have been a better ending to her character as not only would it have been more realistic but fans would have also been happy that at least the beautiful couple that they loved watching ended with respect for each other and not hatred...




In real life its true... But this is not real... Just kidding...

Do you think that the fans will accept Rey in a gloomy mood???

And the hatred in Rey will help him to forget Kriya faster... and that's an advantage for Rey.
..



ccubedtab thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: marauder


My first question isn't D3 supposed to be a youth show ? Isn't break up a part of our life while growing up. My point is Kriya need not had to be a saint and a proper break up of her and Rey would have been better. For e.g Some other girl was paired opposite Sid in DMG but then she left the show ( but mind you the break up was a positive one there ) and then the character of Ridhimma was brought opposite to him. And despite unmatched popularity of Armaan and Ridhimma pairing those two managed to strike the right chord as Sidma with the viewers and were able to create their own fan base. So sometimes a positive intent is needed . And a youth show should be kept that way only and should not be turned to some Saas Bahu opera where lead is always sacrificing for the sake of others.




I'm sorry as D3 was/will be my first and last Indian tele-serial in ma whole life i guess... (not sure about future, but some how it will be the same... )

Didn't watch it from start, saw some random promos and then started watching D3...

And I'm really sorry that I don't have any information about any other serials...

You might have a point there, but what I have to say is it was Shakthi's decision to leave and no need to blame CV's for that... Yes, they have another option also, but in ma opinion this was the best available choice they had.

If it was in the other way,

1. They have to show more scenes of Shakthi (we don't know how much notice period she had given after her decision)

2. Rey will be gloomy and will be alone for a couple of weeks atleast..

3. The introduction of new pair for Rey will be a difficult one to handle with...

4. Weaklings and Rey will try there level best to stop her but will FAIL for sure (as Shakthi will leave for sure), so it is more negative energy...

5. If it is a well planned and informed breakup, it would be difficult to re-introduce Kria at a later stage of the show... (her mom have to change her mind, blah blah blah)

So in ma POV, what they have done is the best suited for the situation...

Please do let me know...

Thanks and cheers...



ccubedtab thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: mjht4everr

i totally agree with you

shakti left the show so what can the cv's do leave rey all alone n gloomy like devdas
ok the ending was abrupt but would rey forget kriya once he learns about the truth?
i would prefer rey happy instead of sad
n ppl hating taani seriously she has not even entered the show and ppl r commenting rudely abt her
let us give her a chance, mayb even she can create some good chemistry with rey if not the best
kriyansh were awesome but let us give niansh a chance as well, the new gal is kinda cute n sweet
n i love d3 as a whole not for a particular couple, so definately wont stop watching it.



You have a good point... 😉
marauder thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#44

@rreya Hey you wrote everything which i felt apart from the fact that i would like a completelely new character than replacing Shakti. But any ways all the thing you said is right.

@ccubedtab
look all the problem you mentioned have came or are going to come in one way or other but what approch Cv's had used is an escapism. Instead of making the character face the harsh realities of life they have made them escape . Its not right. You mention about negative energy which will come when guys would attempt to stop Kriya and eventuall fail but wouldn't that have been better . The weakling team which fought so hard for their right is shown going down without any fight . How come this spreads a positive energy ???

Edited by marauder - 13 years ago
rreya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: marauder


@rreya Hey you wrote everything which i felt apart from the fact that i would like a completelely new character than replacing Shakti. But any ways all the thing you said is right.

@ccubedtab
look all the problem you mentioned have came or are going to come in one way or other but what approch Cv's had used is an escapism. Instead of making the character face the harsh realities of life they have made them escape . Its not right. You mention about negative energy which will come when guys would attempt to stop Kriya and eventuall fail but wouldn't that have been better . The weakling team which fought so hard for their right is shown going down without any fight . How come this spreads a positive energy ???



@marauder- Glad that you agree! well I can understand your point as well... its not easy to see someone else as Kriya...but i guess i watched the show more for the story & character than for her (Although i love Shakti!)

"but what approch Cv's had used is an escapism. Instead of making the character face the harsh realities of life they have made them escape . Its not right." - So true!!!
Infinities thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#46
You have a point , I do agree , but what was the need to end KriYaansh ? They could have REPLACED Kria"S character !!! They could have brought a new Kria !! They , in a way chopped off her character !! D3 was a story of her dreams , her goals , her apirations and her love story !! KriYaansh was NO PUPPY LOVE that she ended it on such a bad note !! end hii karna tha toh Happy ending kar sakte the !!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".