Amey/Karunya might loose just analysis - Page 4

Originally posted by: mans

Maera I know it was really sad...now panna also voted out on v-day I mean voting out itself is bad and if it happens on Bday or Valentine day u feel terrible

Tru Mans.. it's feels terrible if u get votd out on sum special occasion!

Originally posted by: harshmm

Absolutely yar. You are most welcome. A shayar like you( I remember the ek shyam tumhare naam thread still) is a great addition to the club. we are so happy to have you on the club.

I think judges comments are very reasonable for Finals. After all they are their to give feed back to public based on performance. I think public should learn some judgements from these judges. Sonu, Anu and Farah never said anything unreasonable about their overall performance. Its the public, who doesn't care what these contestants are doing, they are just voting in the least deserving contestants for no reason.

If I be the judge, according to the performance, the Rank is Karunya, Amey, Meenal and Antara but from the past few weeks trend, it looks like it will be Antara, Karunya, Meenal and Amey. Its a scary thought even to remotely think that because of wrong public voting, we can loose THE BEST SINGERSA like Karunya. I think he is OVERALL BRILLIAN. HE CAN SING AND PERFORM DIFFERENT TYPES OF SONGS WITH SAME EASE AND COMFORT. Antara has a very decent voice, but I don't see her an an IDOL. I didn't see her rocking performance even once. I think she is getting more of a sympathy votes than deserving votes. What was the need for her to mention in the show that her parents were not there because of financial reasons. People feel sympathise for her and vote thats why she was not in bottom three even once, if I am not mistaken.

Its not fair with Karunya and Amey who are definitely better than her.

I think only time will tell what Bhartiya Janata has in store for them.

Originally posted by: NKSUDHIR

I think judges comments are very reasonable for Finals. After all they are their to give feed back to public based on performance. I think public should learn some judgements from these judges. Sonu, Anu and Farah never said anything unreasonable about their overall performance. Its the public, who doesn't care what these contestants are doing, they are just voting in the least deserving contestants for no reason.

If I be the judge, according to the performance, the Rank is Karunya, Amey, Meenal and Antara but from the past few weeks trend, it looks like it will be Antara, Karunya, Meenal and Amey. Its a scary thought even to remotely think that because of wrong public voting, we can loose THE BEST SINGERSA like Karunya. I think he is OVERALL BRILLIAN. HE CAN SING AND PERFORM DIFFERENT TYPES OF SONGS WITH SAME EASE AND COMFORT. Antara has a very decent voice, but I don't see her an an IDOL. I didn't see her rocking performance even once. I think she is getting more of a sympathy votes than deserving votes. What was the need for her to mention in the show that her parents were not there because of financial reasons. People feel sympathise for her and vote thats why she was not in bottom three even once, if I am not mistaken.

Its not fair with Karunya and Amey who are definitely better than her.

I think only time will tell what Bhartiya Janata has in store for them.

Originally posted by: sadia087

i think ur all r rite usually the ones u don expect turn out to b winner....in fact bfore even readin this i was thinkin hus the ones um least expectin coz most likey they will turn up..... ....nd they were antara n anuj!!!!....i do want anatara there in top 5 mayb even 3 tho i like meenal better but as idols i see amey n karunya either wud do....hope that happens n not the other way around.....n soo true hemachandra was outstandin....his nahi samne tu was AMAZING FABULOUS to say the least....n so sad that he had to leave dat very day but 😛 that he got offered by subhash ghai on that very day or else his ouster wud hav been much more sad....at least it ended on a positive note....but i felt he shud hav won n wen i watch srgmp i jus think that he shud hav been there singin.....n rahul....awww poor guy....i also felt bad hes so talented he must hav felt disheartened even tho he shudnt coz hes gr8......oh well returnin to our idol scene....i hope this trend changes that the unexpected wins.....u don need sooo much of mystery n suspense n shock!.....jus want the deservin candidate to win....amey n karunya!!!!!

Originally posted by: NKSUDHIR

A agree with you mans, some times judges are contradict their own statements, but I don't think Antara is better that Karunya. May be, she has better voice than Amey, but Karu and Amey are experiences and versatile singers. I still want to see Karu as my next Indian Idol. We will listen to Antara's singing in movies and we will like it too, there is no doubt about that. But her stage performance is OK. Yes, Public is with her more than Karu, Amey amd Meenal.