Why didn't they show Anandi's rape?

woman11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Today's scene of sexual assault was not only disturbing but immensely violent as well for the standards of Indian television. However, what keeps me wondering is that why did the CVs not show Anandi being raped? In a situation like this in reality, the kidnapped girl would have been raped. The scene too was very similar to an archetypal rape scene---there were prolonged shots of struggle, close up shots of the feet of both the abuser and the abused ( a very common symbol for rape) and a post-molestation break down scene of Anandi which again resonates with other post rape scenes. Yet the audience was shown that Anandi was stopped just short of being raped, she is molested. Now I can think of two possible reasons why they didn't show Anandi's rape:

1. The CVs were sensitive and decided showing a rape scene would be too much violence for the Indian TV screen. So not showing the rape scene actually brings out the sensitive side of the CVs to not make the story too bleak and dark

2. The rape of the main female protagonist would have been unacceptable for the general Indian audience. The rape of Anandi would have tarnished her "purity" and would have made her less acceptable among the viewers. So Anandi experiences a near-rape but not a complete rape and thus she still keeps her ""purity" intact. A raped Anandi, like a lot other raped women in our society, would have been seen as someone "impure" and not worthy of playing the main protagonist.

I personally think it is the second reason. Though I feel greatly relieved that Anandi was not raped, when I come to think of how her rape would have probably diminished her acceptability, it makes me shudder to think about the general mentality of the larger audience about rape.

What do you guys think?



Edited by woman11 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

11.9k

Users

14

Likes

102

Frequent Posters

Blukitten thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Oh God !! I am glad she was not raped she has been through enough problems.I dont want anymore negativity.The scene was kind of disturbing specially her crying scence it was heartwrenching
I thought Jagya would appear out of nowhere like typical filmy hero, beat those goons black n blue and save Anandi.
Thank God he's not her savior he'll probably just escort her out of the jungle.I guess Sharavan's identity is still a secret for Anandi so he might go back as an innocent person and cause further trouble.
Edited by niharika_n - 13 years ago
khusi_* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Yeah right, Cvs know these r sensitive issues. They cant show anandi being raped coz it would take the story in another way completely.

And yes viewers cant accept it easily. More than acceptability of viewers, it would be very much tragic which is they cant show in case of a lead character. Though it is a reality but they cant show it. The way the didn't show kid anandi(13 year) getting pregnant at the tender age which a big and harsh reality in case of a child bride! Viewers would have not accepted it at all.

There r some issues they cant show in TV. Whether it is violent or not.

But I am very surprised the way anandi's molest scenes were shot. I cant explain how I felt at that time, specially in the ad break. But one thing it is relatively bold compare to asha's molestation scenes. The close up shots and anandi's crying were heart wrenching!!😭

Personally I never felt very much restless about j to come and rescue anandi ASAP. I never felt much but yesterday I was on the edge of my seat like..jagiya...just come'.fast..otherwise it would be very late. So cvs r creating the situations to create impact in viewers mind that j is a hero, if he wouldn't come, anandi will be dead!!

And honestly I really really felt at that time. Though I still cant connect to J's redeem track and still dislike him like hell but I have to appreciate him😳...though i dont want to!!.

he is not like the filmy hero in this case but anandi needs a support and j will help her...but thats itself a very big thing...!!baas anandi sahi salamat pahunch jaye haveli...cvs know viewers mind very well and their plan is successful!...Grrr...😡

Edited by khusi_* - 13 years ago
leo4ever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
they want to show she had eloped of her own wish, they want her to be all ok, so that she has no proof that she was kidnapped and if raped, they know she will use medical report to prove as she is considered the smart one in the village. so that is why heth singh warned no one to touch her. and as for sexual voilence i think it was done pretty decently enuff, there have been worse situations. Also i was impressed with the way she reacted, she actually managed to kick and hit, love it when they show anandi willing to stand up for herself and how she instead of moaning runs away the next day, am glad she is showing presence of mind and not the victim approach
bips thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
I'll agree with you ... it has to be the second reason ... having the "heroine" as a rape survivor takes a lot of courage and very few, hardly any serial ever goes there ...

... You are right, in a kidnapping its almost next to impossible that the woman would come out of it without being raped ... Having shown the actual rape, the story would have taken a completely different turn... and required the kind of bravery and sensitivity that CVs don't have...

Now of course it will all be about Anandi having to prove to every tom,dick and harry of the village that she is still pure ... No one will ever turn around and say that even if she had been assaulted, how was it her fault ??? ... Why punish and humiliate the victim ?

Now i'm sure that they are going to show people talking crap about her, people not coming to her classes any more, she not being allowed to teach in school etc etc etc ...

Despite everything, i am glad that they did not show an actual rape ... There is way too much violence against women on TV ... It somehow surprises me that we as women watch all these shows where women are slapped, assaulted, abused, humiliated at every turn ... too much of violence ... i'm glad they didn't show it ... but what they did show was also too graphic ... there was no need for it
anshansh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
this was a wreckning scene to hype curosity but indeed pratyusha has emersae in her acting day by day i was happy she wasn't and still she escaped her own not saved by jagya that she is a brave girl really it was her inner strenght she is back good but too much pain for anandi too very 😳
intruderfast thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

yaa i believe audiences would have stopped watching

she is the main lead and if she is shown getting raped , ho gaya satyanaash show kaa
in shows like kyunki though they have shown popular character like nandini getting raped but she was accepted by her lover karan(but yeah tulsi was the lead there)
but even in kyunki shows the scenes were not as disturbing as yesterdays molestation one🤢
gosh this serial will hit a record in molestation
pehle maasa then gehna (i heard she was actually raped by her bubby basant), phooli ,gulli .
now anandi , even sugna was in a way taken adv of by pratap
sirf sumitra hain jo bach gayi
why do i get the horrible feeling that gauri might be the next one
and with her they might show the actual thing cos she is not the lead and she is not liked
intruderfast thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
wow wish that kind of power every girl has,then no man would ever dare take adv of women
now abt cvs , i dont trust these twisted minds
they have an extreme fondness for molestation and eve teasing type of scenes🤢 har do teen mahine mein aise scnes aate hain
woman11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Agree with all of you. The scene was extremely violent and immensely disturbing and yet the CVs tried to keep it to the point of molestation as if to show no 'real' damage was done. Though there is hardly any difference for the victim between getting molested and getting raped------for both are equally devastating physical and psychological experiences of violence----there seems to be a difference in the cultural connotation of rape and molestation, which is again related to the misconstrued notion of female purity. So apparently, the female remains "pure" as long as the process is not complete.Thanks Anmol for pointing out Nandini's rape scene in Kyunki, I was not aware of any raped female leads in Indian TV before. But I seriously wish they don't show any more rape/molestation/assault scenes in BV. Asha's and Anandi's were almost back to back, as if the CVs are not getting enough of such scenes🤢.



khusi_* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
the character Nandini from kyunki was raped by her husband who was a completely black character. but i think scenes were not shown...like K soaps...BG music and camera works did the job unlike BV where actually Anandi's molest scenes were shown clearly.
Nandini's rape was a marital rape like gehena...but the effect on her was shown was very very distrubing...she went into a speechless shocking depression state...!!...those incident create a lots of chaos at that time i remember clearly...that y the need..y to show..etc...etc!!
In gehena's case also scenes were not clearly shown like anandi's case...but the scratches on her body and her body language was very very veryyy disturbing...not once..it was twice!!!...i felt like killing Ds and basant...but 2nd time gehena's rebellious nature was shown which i applauded!!!!
these says bv hits the record🤢
infact compare to gulli/asha's case to anandi case...anandi's scenes were veryyy disturbing🤢
and it is the truth...that rape and molest cases r nearly same...and impact was also nearly same...but in viewers mind raped is unaccepted of female lead...matter of purity!!...
Edited by khusi_* - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".