Is Bin Laden is Spiritual Hero??!!? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4997

Users

12

Frequent Posters

lil miz thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Aparna_BD



Hi . but what has all this got to do with Osama Bin Laden being considered a spirtual leader by some ?
And Al- Qaeda is not a set up when Osama regularly releases videos of his organisation giving "kill the American .....jihad.....etc etc" speaches .

oh srry i got abit carried away lolzz...😆and btw about u saying that,

 still does not change my opinion about what i think, conversation over!

Edited by lil miz - 18 years ago
Aparna_BD thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: lil miz

and btw about u saying that,

 still does not change my opinion about what i think, conversation over!



Sorry I thought this was a debate mansion where we debate .😆
-Believe- thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago

Read something about Bin Laden:-article from infoplease.com

Bin Laden was born in Saudi Arabia around 1957 to a father of Yemeni origins and a Syrian mother. His father, Mohammed bin Laden, founded a construction company and with royal patronage became a billionaire. The company's connections won it such important commissions as rebuilding mosques in the holy cities of Mecca and Medina.

Mohammed bin Laden took numerous wives and fathered about 50 children. Osama was either the 17th son, or the 25th son, depending on various reports. Regardless, in a society where status within a family is highly important, bin Laden would have been of relatively low rank.

Bin Laden studied management and economics at King Abdul Aziz University in Jedda, Saudi Arabia, coming under the influence of religious teachers who introduced him to the wider world of Islamic politics.


USSR Invades Afghanistan
RELATED LINKS
Suspected al-Qaeda Terrorist Acts

Remembering September 11

Al-Qaeda

The Taliban

Afghan War

Afghanistan

Saudi Arabia

Sudan

Cold War

Islam Primer 
 


The 1979 Soviet invasion of Afghanistan galvanized bin Laden. He supported the Afghan resistance, which became a jihad, or holy war. Ironically, the U.S. became a major supporter of the Afghan resistance, or mujahideen, working with Saudi Arabia and Pakistan to set up Islamic schools in Pakistan for Afghan refugees. These schools later evolved into virtual training centers for Islamic radicals.

By the mid-1980s, bin Laden had moved to Afghanistan, where he established an organization, Maktab al-Khidimat (MAK), to recruit Islamic soldiers from around the world who later form the basis of an international network. The MAK maintained recruiting offices in Detroit and Brooklyn in the 1980s.

The Taliban, the former rulers of Afghanistan, arose from the religious schools set up during the mujahideen's war against the Soviet invasion. After the Soviet army withdrew in 1989, fighting erupted among mujahideen factions. In response to the chaos, the fundamentalist Taliban was formed and within two years it captured most of the country. The Taliban gave bin Laden sanctuary in 1996.


An International Network
RELATED LINKS
Most Wanted Terrorists

FBI's Ten Most Wanted

Chechnya Time Line

Russian History Time Line

Russia

Terrorism

Terrorism Around the World 
 


After the Soviet withdrawal in 1989, bin Laden returned to Saudi Arabia and worked in his family's construction business. He founded an organization to help veterans of the Afghan war, many of whom went on to fight in Bosnia, Chechnya, Somalia, and the Philippines. Scholars have suggested these loosely connected bands of seasoned soldiers, ready to fight for Islamic causes, form the basis of bin Laden's current support.

In 1990, in response to the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, the Saudi government allowed American troops to be stationed in Saudi Arabia. Bin Laden was incensed that non-believers (American soldiers) were stationed in the birthplace of Islam. He also charged the Saudi regime with deviating from true Islam.

Bin Laden was expelled from Saudi Arabia in 1991 because of his anti-government activities. He eventually wound up in Sudan, where he worked with Egyptian radical groups in exile.


Anti-U.S. Attacks


In 1992 bin Laden claimed responsibility for attempting to bomb U.S. soldiers in Yemen and for attacking U.S. troops in Somalia the following year. In 1994 pressure from the U.S. and Saudi Arabia prompted Sudan to expel bin Laden, and he returned to Afghanistan.

In 1998 bin Laden called for all Americans and Jews, including children, to be killed. He has since been accused of increasing his terrorist activities, such as the 1998 bombings at the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. The date, Aug. 7, was the anniversary of the deployment of U.S. troops to Saudi Arabia.

U.S. cruise missile attacks against targets in the Sudan and Afghanistan in Aug. 1998 are not believed to have seriously hampered bin Laden's network. Bin Laden continues to call for the destruction of the U.S., Israel, and the Saudi monarchy, stating that with these obstacles removed, Islam's three holiest sites, Mecca, Medina, and Jerusalem, would then be liberated.


International Terrorist Network


Yet, even as he is reviled in the West, bin Laden is a hero in parts of the Islamic world, according to intelligence reports. His organization is called al-Qaeda, "the Base," and has approximately 3,000 followers, which he funds with his estimated $250 million fortune. Experts have said that bin Laden could represent a new trend in terrorism—privatization. Until his emergence, most large-scale terrorist organizations are believed to have been connected to governments. With his money and disciplined followers, however, bin Laden is believed to have the ability to launch even more devastating terrorist attacks. He has not denied that he is seeking nuclear or chemical weapons, saying that it is a religious duty to defend Islam.

Bin Laden has been disowned by most of his family, including a brother, Sheik Bakr Mohammed bin Laden, who has established scholarship funds at Harvard Law School, and the Harvard School of Design. In 1991 his Saudi citizenship was revoked.


Wanted: Dead or Alive


After the Sept. 11 attacks, the U.S. issued an ultimatum to Taliban-ruled Afghanistan to turn over bin Laden—this was just the last of several such demands made by the U.S. and the UN after bin Laden was implicated in the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings in East Africa (the U.S. also responded then by launching retaliatory missile attacks on Sudan and an al-Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan). Binding their fate to bin Laden's, the Taliban became the target of air strikes by the U.S. and Britain beginning in October 2002 that swiftly toppled the regime within two months. But Bin Laden, the object of the military campaign in Afghanistan, remained at large. He was believed to have fled to the mountainous region of Tora Bora, but the heavy U.S. bombing campaign that followed failed to vanquish him.

Since the attacks, Bin Laden has released several video tapes broadcast on Qatar's Al Jazeera network, the first of which praised the Sept. 11 hijackers, but stopped just short of claiming responsibility for them. In subsequent tapes, he threatened that more attacks against "the infidel" will occur and warned that "America will not live in peace." Bin Laden's whereabouts remain elusive, but he is thought to be somewhere in Afghanistan or Pakistan. The FBI has placed a $25 million bounty upon his head.

😳

anjali.nair thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Believe

Is Osma is a terrorist or Spiritual Hero??

i didn't care to read after this first line. because in my opinion a guy who hides in a cave after training many innocent youth to kill millions of innocent hardworking people can only be a terrorist irrespective of any religion. he openly claimed that he was behind 9/11 so what more proof we need to brand him a terrorist? who in their right mind would even consider such a sicko, a spiritual hero?

Majority thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: bluepink


i didn't care to read after this first line. because in my opinion a guy who hides in a cave after training manyinnocent youth to kill millions of innocent hardworking people can only be a terrorist irrespective of any religion. he openly claimed that he was behind 9/11 so what more proof we need to brand him a terrorist? who in their right mind would even consider such a sicko, aspiritual hero?



I fully agree with you Bluepink.

How can one, even in one's worst moments of insanity, consider perpetrators of genocide even remotely heroic is just beyond my grasp.

If one of your own were killed or maimed by the actions of these people, perhaps you would sing a different tune.

Believe and Sania_Hitler, I am not at all sorry to say that your sense of heroism does not do you proud in any way. Rather the complete opposite.
-Believe- thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Jatayu



I fully agree with you Bluepink.

How can one, even in one's worst moments of insanity, consider perpetrators of genocide even remotely heroic is just beyond my grasp.

If one of your own were killed or maimed by the actions of these people, perhaps you would sing a different tune.

Believe and Sania_Hitler, I am not at all sorry to say that your sense of heroism does not do you proud in any way. Rather the complete opposite.

I just love him cos of his valiant power, i not agree to killing innocent people and other that type of activity, bt am against US forgin policy if you read more about bin laden,then you can find US Govt. make him a hero, to fight againt Russia at cold war time. 25 year in india we search veerappan in small forest....😉 so think what about Laden!!!!

Majority thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Believe


I just love him cos of his valiant power, i not agree to killing innocent people and otherthat type of activity, bt am against US forgin policy if you read more about bin laden,then you can findUSGovt. make him a hero, to fight againt Russia at cold war time. 25 year in india we search veerappan in small forest....😉so think what about Laden!!!!



What you are saying is completely different. You are speaking of politics now.

And why only US? Our very own Indira Gandhi propped up Jarnail Singh Bhrindanwale who later turned against her.

Politics aside, any person can be a power centre. Al Capone was one in Chicago. Kim Jong Il is one in South Korea as was Saddam Hussain in Iraq. None of these people have anything heroic about their deeds. They are criminals.

Also, please don't say that it's all a propaganda of the West/US. It isn't. Saddam's gassing of the Kurds has nothing to do with US. The same goes for Auscwitz and violence in Chicago by Capone.

Please do not glorify people who commit crimes against humanity.
-Believe- thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Jatayu



What you are saying is completely different. You are speaking of politics now.

And why only US? Our very own Indira Gandhi propped up Jarnail Singh Bhrindanwale who later turned against her.

Politics aside, any person can be a power centre. Al Capone was one in Chicago. Kim Jong Il is one in South Korea as was Saddam Hussain in Iraq. None of these people have anything heroic about their deeds. They are criminals.

Also, please don't say that it's all a propaganda of the West/US. It isn't. Saddam's gassing of the Kurds has nothing to do with US. The same goes for Auscwitz and violence in Chicago by Capone.

Please do not glorify people who commit crimes against humanity.

If we talking about Bin laden without politics we cant say anything, and am not glorifing his doings. 😳

Majority thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Believe


If we talking about Bin laden without politics we cant say anything, and am not glorifing his doings. 😳



A man is what he is because of what he does.

Consider for a moment. Why are Einstein, Mother Theresa, Rabindranath and Nelson Mandela (to name but a few) famous? It is not because of WHO they are but because of what they've DONE.

It is not possible think Einstein without Relativity and so on ....

So when you say you admire a man, what you REALLY admire are his deeds.

I must also thank you and appreciate your tone in this discussion. I look forward to having more of such with you.
-Believe- thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Jatayu



A man is what he is because of what he does.

Consider for a moment. Why are Einstein, Mother Theresa, Rabindranath and Nelson Mandela (to name but a few) famous? It is not because of WHO they are but because of what they've DONE.

It is not possible think Einstein without Relativity and so on ....

So when you say you admire a man, what you REALLY admire are his deeds.

I must also thank you and appreciate your tone in this discussion. I look forward to having more of such with you.

Ok i agree Einstein, Mother Theresa, Rabindranath and Nelson Mandela famous of their deeds...but if you look the world history, every bad guy have +ve side also for eg: Yasser Arafat is the quintessential terrorist in his time later people start love him as a hero. Some people say that Bin Laden is an evil man. For various reasons, I don't agree. I believe the evidence shows that evil does not really exist - only distorted goodness Although I believe that Bin Laden should be captured and imprisoned,common sense tells us that there are people who do love him - even if it is only his mother. i think God loves Bin Laden unconditionally otherwise he die long b4...😳