Asma getting better or Mentors misleading us ?

yeah i like asma she is improving u can see that when she just entered the saregamapa and she ARABIC SONG THAT TIME THAT WAS NOT GOOD AND YESTERDAY WHEN SHE SANG THE SAME ARABIC SONG FOR SALMAN THAT WAS SOOOOOOOOOO GOOD

Definitely the mentors are misleading us, not only in judging Asma but also other contestants as well......Long ago I posted about the mentors simply giving history...history....history for average singing......I don't understand their judging.......and their comments are very boring...."your singing is good", "super, fantastic, midblowing, history", "you've improved a lot"....these are the common comments which will not interest the audience......in previous saregamapas I always look forward to hear the comments/critics from the mentors but now I find the advertisements are more interesting than their comments!

Originally posted by: Summer3

I think most of us enjoy the Asma drama on stage as it is really fun. In the Salma Episode she really was the star in making us laugh.

But about her singing is she really improving or are the Mentors misleading us, by giving her "History" every week?

Honestly I do enjoy her songs because her songs are carefully selected to suit her voice.

PLease do not say that you hate her again.

Any one can say that she has improved. First of all hindi language is new to her forget about sur and taal. Asma worked hard and now she can sing songs of lataji also (didi tera dewar). She use to only sing song which as arabic music but now she is singing all kind of songs.

hmm someone mentioned good enough to stay on top 5..so currently who do you think is weaker than asma and deserves to go?

i think the only mentor that gives proper comment is shankar ji...he tells you where you went wrong and how it could be better etc etc.. himesh comments are repetitive and boring..he says the same thing over and over again...he has more side fringe than any girl ive seen.

xoxo

First of all, I don't think anyone can or should hate Asma. She's a cute girl who brings a smile to everyone's face. Now, as we all know she is the weakest singer on the show right now. And yes she is improving, but that doesn't mean that she has reached a level where she can give tough competition to the other singers. Judges are giving her history to give her (and the show) some credibility.

Remember ...

Mauli Dave of C-07?

Suhit of II3?

Amit Tandon of JJWS?

All these singers improved tremendously from their original position. But there improvement wasn't as successful because most of the other singers were already at that level and beyond even before they entered the show. THAT is the true problem.

And although her jokes may annoy some, or her presence might be a bit frustrating because other better singers are exiting the show, I still don't think that anyone should hate her.

Originally posted by: hira**

i find her presence injustice to eliminated good and desrving singers like Arshad,Shujaat,Sara,Naina and Mitika.