Harry Potter or Twilight? - Page 2

Originally posted by: eclipse_101

If I had to choose, I'd shoot myself to death.😛

These two books are different and uncomparable..two different books altogether...both the best in their places!

But I feel that this post is biased especially when someone creates this post in the Harry potter forum only..unless you created this post in the Twilight forum as well.

There are many epople who haven't read HP and have read Twilight but not HP...feelings may vary...

Originally posted by: godisone

I've always been a die-hard Harry/Ginny and Lily/James fan!😆😆😆 And of course, we must not forget Ron/Hermione!!!😛😛😛 I thought the epilogue to Harry Potter was soooooooooooo sweet and cute😳😳😳, a GREAT ending to the perfect series! Out of Harry and Ginny's kids, I really can't make up my mind who I like! They're all so cute! But I think I like Lily the best. She seems like a mixture between her mother Ginny and her grand-mother Lily (Evans) Potter!😊 After that, James Sirius and Albus Severus are equal, because James reminds me of Fred Weasley (who was unnecessarily killed😭😭😭) and his grandfather James Potter while Albus Severus reminds of Harry (when he was younger) and Albus Dumbledore, one of my favorite characters (who died but whose death did sadly make sense😭😭😭)!

I think Twilight's a good series too, but like many people said, Harry Potter will always have a special place in my heart, always, because there was something so enticing and endearing about the whole series, and even yet, I cannot get tired of reading it. For me, Twilight's one of those books that is good but I can't read more than once. (Sorry Twilightians!😳)

Originally posted by: twinklystar_hp

i started reading HP when i was 12 that was like in 2000 8 years ago..and at that time only the 4 books were out...as soon as i read the first book i remember i was aharry ginny shipper...i knew if int he end harry has to be with sum1 it wud be ginny..cuz i just felt their coupel was right..y else wud she be brought in from the very first book itself that even for just a few seconds..*-) so yeah i've ALWAYS been a harry ginny fan never harry hermy and i was very sad when harry fell for cho in 3rd😭 but all's well that ends well😃

as for my fav character...it has to be...the charatcre whom u just mentioned....killign whom rowling made me cry SOOO MUCH...FRED WEASLEY!! from the twins i LOVED FRED..😭😭😭i still can't believe she killed fred...i luv ALL Weasleys buttt if sh ehad to kill sum1 Y FRED😭 she actually was gonna kill mr weasley in 5th but she then redempted him and decided to kill 3 more major charatcres in 7th...one of which was fred....Y FRED Y FRED Y FRED😭😭that's one aspect of the last book i still havent come to terms with i just cant accept that fred died😭i sitll remember him happily chatting abt how many detah eaters he will bring down...i still remember his excited & determined expression showing harry tht he wasnt alone😭fredddddd😭

I never would be able to accept fred weasley died infact he will ALWAYS bealive for me..i have made my own alt. ending in which fred is aliveeee and happy and yeah him and george's weasley wheezes is world's most famous shop...😊

HP is a legend...will always be remembered...

btw yeah i saw and commented on this topic of urs intwilight forum too..i think even there majortiy wud choose hp when it cums to a comparison...wht do u say???😉

oh and yeah lemme take this moment to also say that: EDWARD CULLEN U ROCK MY HEART😳

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

Fred or some other important character had to die, or else how would Harry get the strength to walk into the forest and step into his own death, as DD has planned?? Harry remembers Fred's and Lupin's dead body and then he realizes that it's time he goes to the forst and end his life so that any other wont suffer for him. If some unimportant character wud have died then i am sure Harry might not have felt that going to the forst and meeting his own end is that important.....PLUS some characters had to die to make it more realistic and more tragic so that people will remember it forever..!!

Originally posted by: godisone

Yes, I agree with you, or else the war with Voldemort wouldn't have seemed like a war at all, if the Light Side hadn't any deaths or casualties at all. Even in Rilla of Ingleside (By L.M. Montgomery), when Rilla's brother Walter died in the battle of Courcelette, it was very sad😭, but it made the book more remembered and more realistic. Likewise, I agree that so many people dying in the DH book made it more realistic and better written, but that doesn't erase the sadness does it? I can't help it....I'll always "mourn" the deaths of Fred and Dobby the most.

I think Remus's death was sad too, but my sister and I always felt that his death was more of a relief to him that anything, because he was reunited with his friends in heaven. Plus, He was having difficulty living in this world as a warewolf. Now that both he and Tonks are dead, they can live happily ever after i guess😆😉That's why we weren't as sad at his death, but Tonks should have lived, because she was young and poor Teddy knew no parents.😭 If Tonks had lived it wud have been more tragic for Tonks to take care of a child all alone, and she would definitely miss Luypin like mad. Now both are reunited. Plus, J.K.R wanted to show Harry as a God Father, thus Teddy's parents had to die.😉