Was it an ufair desicion? - Page 5

Originally posted by: phadukaran

IF YOU go just by dance style, and concept and all, BOYS should off won hands down. boys always did something different. even if they have done Western it involved something different, all the time. While girls did Indian, and whatever challenge must be, it always had Bollywood integrated in it and it looked good cuz we have always seen it.

if you go with grace, finishing and all, girls were good,

Here is My thought!!

Girls deserved to win, Many times it seemed that girls were not given scores..... Bhaktiyaar indeed was a good dancer but i agree with the decision of the judges being monotonous and being different is different.... Girls gave their best short be it Karishma,Mouni,Narayani or All the girls at the end... Atleast in Finale they sent made sure almost all performed unlike the opposition team, plus there was no need to play and bet so many points which boys did, taking risk and having confidence is different and having overconfidence is different... In face of round there were places where Bhaktiyaar slipped , But Ashita gave him a good competition and she deserved to win, they shdnt have taken such a big risk, i agree with what Mouni said once at the stage u never knw if anything goes wrong .Moreever,in a competition someone wins and someone looses every one shd have a sportsmanship... Amey poor soul pity him he as a child did a gr8 work and the only one who performed... Girls deserved the victory guys lost in face off round with their risk and girls were leading all the way.... Three cheers to the girls aka Meethi Churis!!They deserved every bit of their win:)

Luv,

Shagun

Originally posted by: sonali.19281

just going by today bthe decision made in the face off and tashan round just didint make sense..oj even if i agree ashita stood a chance there is no way karishma was better..my heart went out to bakhtiyar..besides malaika looked to be analysing his psyche more than his dance today😳..both decisions taken together just did it..i think the tanshan atleast should have gon to the bouys..but in ideal terms both the rou nds were better performed by the guy

Originally posted by: pyaridilwalino1

dancing wise both the boys and girls have presented VARIETY! Western is not a variety of dance....boys have done break dance, popping and locking, and many different CONCEPTS! While girls have explored many forms of Indian cultural dances. They have also given their shot at different concepts. Bollywood is not a dance, but a concept... instead all songs were used from Bollywood movies! So the debate on variety doesn't seem to stand a chance, in my view. The tashan round should have been in the favor of the boys for sure...but everything else was FAIR! Gaurav Chopra said--"Jo badal garajte hai.woh baraste nahin!" and that's what the guys proved today. ALL that complaining and sulking when they didn't win a round brought them out to be referred to as SORE LOSERS! If they had a problem with decisions before voice them and make a point. Boys had a problem with Chaitu given a remark before he even performed...they never questioned the judges decision directly. In the beginning Bakhtiyaar is NOTED--and continuously noted to be a brilliant dancer...that doesn't mean just because he is a "brilliant dancer" he needs to win all the time. Boys need to grow up and learn to face a challenge. Decision was completely FAIR and if something was unfair was the treatment that the boys as a WHOLE gave to the whole cast and crew of Zara Nach Ke Dikha! Shweta

Originally posted by: flute

i fully agree with u.
that stupid fat lady as a judge was really a headach to boys team...😡

Originally posted by: santoshkdl

I hate the judges..... I think they're stupid.... non-intelligent people..... it's clear tht Bakhtiyar was better than Karishma............... maybe there might be a little debate on ashita.... But no way, bakhtiyar was far better than Karishma in all due respect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111

I think some of the decisions towards the boys were really unfair! Bhaktiyar should of won some of them... they were very biased!

Originally posted by: kalhonahogames

i don't know about the over all but Ashita and Bhatiyar face off round was not fair 4 sure.

Originally posted by: bushraw

The judgemnt was wrong to start the show with come on if u were to take a pole i bet u bakti would over karishma anyday he was way better and deserved to win. Im a girl and i thought that was sooooo unfair and i bet its all that stupid Malika's falt.

Originally posted by: imroze123

THE DECISION WAS VERY MUCH UNFAIR ...BOYS GAVE THEIR 200 % but MALAIKA IS VERY STUPID AND UNFAIR. AND CHUNKEY REALLY NEEDS TO CHANGE HIS SEX...HE IS A DHABBA on MALE CLAN .