Today's Episode... - Page 3

Originally posted by: tongue_twister

Himesh ji has never pulled down any contestant. I think,you do not watch properly. But, Atif always tries to find out mistakes and then when he cannot find out anything he says" it could have been better,you were flat blah,blah,blah." He gave a standing ovation to Sara yesterday and the lady got only 10. That shows how much he knows about music.

Ofcourse I do watch it properly.And in my pov-Both captains are biased and irritatingEveryone's POV can't be same.Thats ok😊

Originally posted by: tongue_twister

The episode was simply superb. Diljaan and Yashraj were just too,too good. Never knew they could set the stage on fire the way they did, Both showed their true potential. Atif,as always tried his level best to pull down the Indians but,his trick did not work out.

Pakistani singers did not do full justice to the the criteria given . They did very simple alap and sargams. Nabeel just did not do anything extra. I was surprised to see him get 20. I would have given him a 0. He did nothing in comparison to Dilajaan and Yashraj.

Even Mulazim, compared to Diljaan and Yash, did hardly anything. His sargams were basic and very very little.

Originally posted by: lotus1963

Even Mulazim, compared to Diljaan and Yash, did hardly anything. His sargams were basic and very very little.

I agree with Varsha. Didnt understand the 30 marks or the standing ovation!!

Originally posted by: Anondo.R

Yeah i thought Contestants along with the captains select songs. But Atif's question confused me! 😕

if i m not wrong,yestrday evry1 on set scolded budhha 4 choosin a song which he cud not sing proprly. evn in maa episode, himesh told 2 jury that budhha was keen 2 sing d same song, sung by aameer so he allowed him. it means songs r selectd by captains only accordin 2 d themes.
as far as aatif's displeasure concrnd, it was coz of his own misundrstandin of d theme. still i doubt it coz himesh was vry much right whn he askd sara that thn hwcm she prformd accordin 2 d theme if they were not guided properly.
aatif was embarassed n wantd 2 hide it by blamin sk team 4 it though pak team mentor mr. rustam clearly acceptd his fault in undrstandin d theme criteria.

Originally posted by: s123vi

if i m not wrong,yestrday evry1 on set scolded budhha 4 choosin a song which he cud not sing proprly. evn in maa episode, himesh told 2 jury that budhha was keen 2 sing d same song, sung by aameer so he allowed him. it means songs r selectd by captains only accordin 2 d themes.
as far as aatif's displeasure concrnd, it was coz of his own misundrstandin of d theme. still i doubt it coz himesh was vry much right whn he askd sara that thn hwcm she prformd accordin 2 d theme if they were not guided properly.
aatif was embarassed n wantd 2 hide it by blamin sk team 4 it though pak team mentor clearly acceptd his fault in undrstandin d theme criteria.

Check my previous reply. I said maybe in last episode SK team selected songs for them. @Red If you felt so its your personal opinion. I said what i felt 😊

Originally posted by: Snigdhakhanam

ya I thought the same.I didn't get it properly.Are SK team choosing contestants songs from the begining or they chose only yesterday😕?

Not from the start. Only yesterday i think. I dont know maybe i'm wrong. but i felt so!

Originally posted by: tongue_twister

Himesh ji has never pulled down any contestant. I think,you do not watch properly. But, Atif always tries to find out mistakes and then when he cannot find out anything he says" it could have been better,you were flat blah,blah,blah." He gave a standing ovation to Sara yesterday and the lady got only 10. That shows how much he knows about music.

absolutely right!
ppl tkin aatif's side should watch his expressions durin indian performances. he nevr seems 2 enjoy thm whereas himesh behaves same whethr its indian or pakistani. himesh also tlks less negative thn aatif .
yestrday yashraj was d best n evry1 includin abidaji n sahir praised him while aatif said, u missd taal 2 tyms. WTH!!

@ anondo

its ok!
i also respect ur POV.😊

Originally posted by: tongue_twister

I fully agree with you. Sarega,regama,gamapa is the begginning sargams that you do when you start learning music,ideally from the very second day.And, Atif always does a standing ovation for his singers no matter what they do.😆

Anyway having said all that I immensely enjoyed the programme yesterday and thought the Indians were far far superior and better prepared the only jarring note and a huge one being Buddha's terrible terrible attempt. He deserved his zero for sure. But Nabeel did too. Sara did too and Mulazim certainly didnt deserve his 30 nor the standing ovation.