these are all my opinions and thoughts!!! - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

2.2k

Users

11

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

preetie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: anaad

I totally agree with you, it does make sense, just because Pakistani singers come to India doesn't mean that they are desperate. The music industry is a fast growing industry and to be successful you have to answer to the demand of your costumers, in the case of Atif, he is mainly popular with the younger generation and I also listen to his song myself on a regularly basis while my parents hate his songs. And the fact that Pakistani singers are invited means that there is demand for other than the Indian music. The Indian music industry is mainly focused on Bollywood songs while other kind of music is not fully promoted,...at least that's my impression of it, I don't actually know how popular other music forms are in India,...I am personally more inclined towards the band and sufi music than Bollywood music. The other thing is that the Pakistani singers are already very well established overseas,...and I guess, it is safer and easier to invest in them then to start from scratch and having the risk that a new band may not work out as expected, resulting in a financial loss,...Money is the only thing that counts!

It is the same with any other field, people are invited to the West to work, not because they lack people with expertise or aren't capable do their work properly by themself, but because they want to have diversity on the work floor so that they can compete with the ever changing industry. They invite people from different backgrounds, different culture, with different mind-set etc. so that they eventually can make use of their capability consequently leading to a very acceptable profit.

By the way Akon also came to india to sing for SRK movie. May be Indian music directors like to experiment. Atif is not main stream. Few songs like flavor of the month.
preetie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: cape



i think akon gave india an honor to come and gave them a chance to sing in one of their movies i dont think akon need any popularity or fame,hes already been sooo popular in this whole world...he dont need bollywood,but bollywood needs him...(it is my point of view,do not take it seriously anyone here)

whoa...hold your horses my friend. Hollywood want to work with bollywood including Tom Cruise. Akon is no exception. Bollywood is multi billion dollar industry. Akon didn't do favor he is tapping in to new massess of admirers.
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
Atif defo has different hatke voice but he surely is besura...pardon my honesty..I have seen and heard him live...This days technology can do wonders...If I tried I would probably sound great too but I am not going there 😆
And pls DO NOT put AA and RFAK in the same sentence..
RFAK is a whole different level of singer compared to AA..
Both countries have had great legends and singers in past...Not speaking of present 😛
Blame the MDs of India who go get these artists for their movie songs...Possibly for alot less money than they would end up paying someone from India...Chori karne wale MDs will only look for a cheap way out na 😉 India me singers ki koi kami nahi...WHole India has talent oozing out of every corner of the country ...
Again I ain't fa Sanu, Kunal fan as I dont care for their voices...But there are many other singers in India who could do waaay better than AA...Globalization and business sense brings this type of collaborations..I do get young girl's obsession with him though...SOnu used and still has same effect on many 😃
Again As Rebel mentioned Channel-show gives scripts for all of them to say what they are saying...No matter what A legend and an elderly singer with such a tenure should NOT be disrespected be it for TRP or NOT..😳
With that said I think this show should concentrate on displaying singing talent than India-Pak next war..Peace out!!
Edited by Dabulls23 - 12 years ago
-shabz- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: s123vi

arre its only abt music n talent. film industry needs it coz of constant demand. evry creative field needs 2 keep experimntin in order 2 survive n evolve into smthng bettr.!
well i just wanna add that indians r not only gvin chance 2 pakistanis bt also othr foreign singers.infact it has bcm a trend now due 2 more english lyrics.
forgot AKON??

nahi nahi...akon needs india desperately😆
-shabz- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: preetie

i am canadian as well living in singapore...like i said if a canadian gets a chance in hollywood, he/she will run for it...for pakistan its bollywood.

cape thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: preetie

whoa...hold your horses my friend. Hollywood want to work with bollywood including Tom Cruise. Akon is no exception. Bollywood is multi billion dollar industry. Akon didn't do favor he is tapping in to new massess of admirers.



ok well that was my point of view what i felt as i said above,and beside i dont care who goes to india and sing it was just a general thought about akon,...iam talking about the behavior what i felt after watching 2 or 3 episodes of that singing programe...and i disagree what asha said and trying to clear out ke not onlyy our singers want to go to india but bollywood need them too...
Edited by cape - 12 years ago
cape thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Atif defo has different hatke voice but he surely is besura...pardon my honesty..I have seen and heard him live...This days technology can do wonders...If I tried I would probably sound great too but I am not going there 😆

And pls DO NOT put AA and RFAK in the same sentence..
RFAK is a whole different level of singer compared to AA..
Both countries have had great legends and singers in past...Not speaking of present 😛
Blame the MDs of India who go get these artists for their movie songs...Possibly for alot less money than they would end up paying someone from India...Chori karne wale MDs will only look for a cheap way out na 😉 India me singers ki koi kami nahi...WHole India has talent oozing out of every corner of the country ...
Again I ain't fa Sanu, Kunal fan as I dont care for their voices...But there are many other singers in India who could do waaay better than AA...Globalization and business sense brings this type of collaborations..I do get young girl's obsession with him though...SOnu used and still has same effect on many 😃
Again As Rebel mentioned Channel-show gives scripts for all of them to say what they are saying...No matter what A legend and an elderly singer with such a tenure should NOT be disrespected be it for TRP or NOT..😳
With that said I think this show should concentrate on displaying singing talent than India-Pak next war..Peace out!!



again iam gonna say the same thing my friend ke atif definetly has something thats y youth is crazy for him...no matter he sings besura or technology can do wonders still y music directors only choose his voice to put on that technology system????y not others???iam not saying hes a great singer aur sur ka pakka singer iam just saying ke not only atif but BW also need atif...and putting RFAK and AA in one sentence doesnt mean they have the same voice quality iam just justifying my point by saying ke EITHER its RFAK,SAA, or AA indian music directors/filmmakers need them no matter what...atleast thats what i have seen since last 3 to 4 years...i disagree ke atif would charge less than other singers in india after having soo much popularity from the songs he has sang in past do u really think MDs and filmmakers would pay him less???every country has its own talent i think but still atif would be choosen over others i wonder y na😳 ...agar MD kisi new singer ko choose karta aur pehli nazar woh singer gata tu i think aus ko bhi bahut bahut less pay karna parta...because i think new talent or the person who sing the first time for any movie would get sooo little money for his first performance so MDs ye cheap way bhi out karsakhte hai right😳 but still they only want atif...
Edited by cape - 12 years ago
preetie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: cape



ok well that was my point of view what i felt as i said above,and beside i dont care who goes to india and sing it was just a general thought about akon,...iam talking about the behavior what i felt after watching 2 or 3 episodes of that singing programe...and i disagree what asha said and trying to clear out ke not onlyy our singers want to go to india but bollywood need them too...

I think your question to yourself should who needs who more. Bollywood is open to anyone in this world including dancers from europe. They take people in including Kyle plus other hollywood actress. Now europeans may start arguing with Indians on this matter. how many countries do we indians have to listen to. You need to understand it is not need, it is just to add flavor to what bollywood is all about. If pakistani singers refuse, bollywood wont get hurt as they will find someone else. If bollywood refuse...that is set back to anyone who is trying to get into bollywood. Even brazilian women are trying their luck in bollywood. Now does bollywood need brazilian women...at the end of the day it is the place to be after hollywood. People are making big bucks as bollywood market is huge. I am amazed how much Salman, Akshay is asking per movie and if converted to dollars in is in millions. It is not limited to India or pakistan. Need of pakistani singers is bit far fetched idea. I think you need to understand bollywood is like little city or country of its own and people all over the world want to be part of it.
cape thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: preetie

I think your question to yourself should who needs who more. Bollywood is open to anyone in this world including dancers from europe. They take people in including Kyle plus other hollywood actress. Now europeans may start arguing with Indians on this matter. how many countries do we indians have to listen to. You need to understand it is not need, it is just to add flavor to what bollywood is all about. If pakistani singers refuse, bollywood wont get hurt as they will find someone else. If bollywood refuse...that is set back to anyone who is trying to get into bollywood. Even brazilian women are trying their luck in bollywood. Now does bollywood need brazilian women...at the end of the day it is the place to be after hollywood. People are making big bucks as bollywood market is huge. I am amazed how much Salman, Akshay is asking per movie and if converted to dollars in is in millions. It is not limited to India or pakistan. Need of pakistani singers is bit far fetched idea. I think you need to understand bollywood is like little city or country of its own and people all over the world want to be part of it.



first i think u need to understand what iam saying,i dont need to question myself about hollywood since everyone wanna go thereand work for them pakistan india canada china everyone...and atif was already so popular but i can understand he got more popular or popularity after been in bollywood for like 3 to 4 years now...bollywood gave him so much i agree..BUT bollywood also need his voice just as u said to add more flavors to their film industry...and for hollywood who comes who goes i dont know and dont care,iam talking about my pakistani singers specially atif,bollywood give chances I AGREE but on the other hand its not they feel pity for someone or atif came to them and beg for a song no they went to him first so it means ke both need favors from each other...its not only atif who got a favor from ur MDs...
Edited by cape - 12 years ago
preetie thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: cape



first i think u need to understand what iam saying,i dont need to question myself about hollywood since everyone wanna go thereand work for them pakistan india canada china everyone...and atif was already so popular but i can understand he got more popular or popularity after been in bollywood for like 3 to 4 years now...bollywood gave him so much i agree..BUT bollywood also need his voice just as u said to add more flavors to their film industry...and for hollywood who comes who goes i dont know and dont care,iam talking about my pakistani singers specially atif,bollywood give chances I AGREE but on the other hand its not they feel pity for someone or atif came to them and beg for a song no they went to him first so it means ke both need favors from each other...its not only atif who got a favor from ur MDs...

You are talking from both sides of your mouth. You are just not clear. One hand Akon honored India than something else. Did Atif begged???? we don't know. Most likely no body begs. Did he wanted to sing in bollywood...Damn right I am sure he was jumping with joy once opportunity came along. At the end of day, you need stop bollywood need this and need that. Bollywood has plenty of choices. Artist needs Bollywood regardless where they are from. Is he recking his reputation on the show? Yep he is. Do I want to listen to him. I can do without his voice as there are is plenty of choice of music that comes out of bollywood every year. You guys are talking as if he is only singer singing in Bollywood. There is saying one eyed king for country of blind and it fits perfectly for Atif. He sang couple of songs and you guys are all over it. He really hasn't contributed much in comparison that has been done by others.
It is interesting we hear this more from you guys than anyone else.
Edited by preetie - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".