samcek thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Although I have been a member of IF for a few years, I do not post often. Usually only when I really like something or have a strong opinion on something. Or to post OS'.
I am a bit confused as to the direction of this show...

Some characters (Soumya, Dadi, Rags) are fine. I hate them as i'm meant to - the CV's portray them well enough (or to the best of the actresses abilities). They are villains and they play their roles well enough-ish. The point is I understand what I am meant to be feeling when I see them onscreen.

Pratima, Lata, Pankaj - again I don't agree with their choices but I understand (to a degree) what these characters are meant to be portraying. Parents who made choices for their kids thinking they knew what was best. I guess this is supposed to emphasise the whole "mother knows best" thing. Again, I don't agree, but I understand where they stand in this drama.

Menka - I'm unsure here... People say she isn't bad she is stupid, but stupidity isn't an excuse for doing bad things. Menka creates trouble which amuses us, but that doesn't make her good or even neutral. Perhaps if the CV's showed her doing some good along with her trouble making I would understand her a bit better... As it is I think she should be punished along with her Jiji.

Anuj, Saurabh - Whats there to say here... Apparently Yuvraj trusts his cousin and mother but not his own brothers... These two could be replaced with plants most of the time and it wouldn't really impact me too much. Perhaps its because I watch a lot of UK/USA shows, but do the CV's know that shows can be layered? i.e. you can have more than one story line and these can entwine? Why not use these two for another storyline? It would detract from what we're currently seeing. Which brings me to...

Yuvraj, Suhani - Try as I might, I struggle to connect to these two. Sometimes I can, then they do something completely out of character and I think "maybe they have twins wondering around and the CV's are filming both sets." Suhani's moping is understandable, she's heartbroken. For some reason she's decided to punish herself by staying in BH. Her behaviour is by no means excusable, but, in the land of Indian TV, it makes some sense (abandon all logic ye who enter here).
Yuvraj however... This isn't a hero. Everything i want to say, has been said by better writers (Clarity in particular hits the nail on the head), and even for Indian TV this is shocking. Putting his Dadi and Ma first is normal on StarPlus, but we've now decided that redeeming a villain comes before wives? Really? This is actually what people are happy to see?

Once I watched this show and was quite enraptured by it. I looked forward to watching it and wrote a few OS' because it spoke to me, it was different. Im enjoying the show now to watch Rags and Soumya... Im not interested in the love story.

Im sure this is where a disclaimer goes... Where I am supposed to apologise for offence caused but I won't. Im not apologising for my opinions, they are mine to express. I do, however, respect those who have different opinions to my own, and look forward to you expressing them.




Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

997

Users

4

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

wayback thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Amazing post this is the reason that is stopping me to watch the show... I mean I don't understand this show now... It's sometimes more confusing than maths problems...lol...
I don't understand Suhani now... Sometimes I think she is strong, bold women but other time think no she isn't...she is Mahaan person. Who think more about his family than herself. I know nothing is wrong in doing so... But still...
She brought Soumya home and said that she should not suffer any kind of harassment and physical abuse.. But she too is suffering from emotional harassment and abuse but still she wants to stay in BH.. And perform the duty of a maid...
I always thought that BH is so big and if the family is so rich.. Then why only one official servant that is Ramesh..
Which is confusing to me..
And Yuvraj Birla the most confusing person in the whole show. I think I won't be able to understand him ever.. His feelings are the biggest mystery ever...

I think may be because the story leave many loop hole open... It has become confusing more and more now days...
clarity thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Sam, you said it all.

YuvAni have gone from being well-written to being the worst written characters on the show. They really have no sustained personalities, because the CVs change their personalities as and when it suits them. šŸ˜•

I would say that the secondary characters are much better written than their leads. As you said, we know what and how to feel when it comes to the others, but YuvAni just turn everything topsy turvy.

Both Suhani and Yuvraj are so weak right now. Truth be told, I had been dealing with a weak Yuvraj, but I couldn't stand a weak Suhani, because she's supposed to be the protagonist of the show. 😳 It's unbearable.
I too don't want YuvAni together now, 'cause I feel there is too much bad history between them. I think YuvAni being a couple is an affront to Suhani's self-esteem. How can she be with a man who has STILL not acknowledged the fact that he could possibly love her? The CVs have ruined what could have been a great couple.

These CVs do not care about characters and their consistency as long as they can peddle the bullshit they call a story line. This show is a lost cause. They will do whatever it takes to get TRPs, so I have no hope from them anymore. It's better to look for greener pastures. šŸ˜‰

As for Menka, yes, just because she's funny, it doesn't excuse the fact that she does bad things.
dunceHat thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
samcek,
well-expressed! I started on IF exactly 2 months ago...and my first post
was about "give SU some personality"
My very First post here:
made various posts with analysis, requests for logic, request to stop acute sodaragmen-poison in time, and turn the zero into a hero etc. etc. etc and more etc.!
None of that made a bit of difference to what has now become of SSEL😊 CVs just decided to abuse the initially trapped audience as return gift for all the love they showed...
but cheer up you may in luck tonight and YU n Snakey will drink and eat lots of mango prepared by inhouse maidSU! CVs have great plans lined upšŸ˜†šŸ˜† what joy!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".