Was PTSD was in mind of writer while writing Nandini - Page 3

Originally posted by: TheMockingBird

Maya never brought trps for beyhadh although it was sony show but many shows like badhe aache have brought trps for sony also and kbc also. and here i m talking about trp janta .I use to love maya but my mom and aunties use to hate her and they used to despise her.So you see our indian audience still not ready for grey characters.They only understand black and white .Gabbar was pure negetive and his dialogues was epic so character became famous.

Originally posted by: Banjaaran25

many sony tv fictional shows hardly gets trps anyways😆.

if the character is meant to be hated and it is hated.. then it's a success. for both the character and the actor.

however if the character (case in point being Nandini) is not meant to be hated but to be seen as this bechari victim who just loved.. and yet is being despised .. then it is a failure.

Gabbar is epic. end of. i will challenge you to duel till death if someone says otherwise. *gee. kidding.*not just dialogues his entire aura was epic.

that's why i said not entire junta MB.. but i have seen people giving a chance to greys. i know i did. so did many others in IF (trp givers.).

I will wait and watch what they hv store for nandini only then i will decide whether character is meant to be hated or not.For what now i believe writer never had in mind to justify EMA.It's poor screenplay,inconsistent writing and execution which had lead to the confusion.I hv watched writer previous shows and they happen to my favorite like Astitav she never justified EMA.Secondly,when the show started writer tweeted mauli is her dream character so in her mind mauli was always important character in story telling.Thirdly ,they rushed kunal and nandini falling track at jet speed as if they were in hurry to reach the main part of story that is EMA ,its revelation and consequences.If they hv wanted to justify EMA they would hv shown negetive mauli or problems in mauli and kunal relationships or they hv taken their proper time to show emotional bonding bw kunal and nandini so that audience connect to them but no they were not worried about that they rushed the story to reach main part.Some are saying it's due to the backlash they hv given mauli so much importance but my pov is little different if mauli was not abn important character they would hv gone for new face but they went for aditi who obviously is good actress.Backlash to they are recieving from even from start of show if they would hv wanted they would hv changed the story there and then so i will wait to give my judgement on nandini before jumping on any conclusion

Originally posted by: FruitToasty

Abhinav just liked the comment, he didn't write it

@Banjaran i also felt good interacting with you .I respect your pov although we can agree to disagree at some points but still it's good to interact with sensible ppl here who can discuss characters and actors without name calling.Looking foward to interact with you more.

@TheMockingBird
Like I have been saying all along, people give too much credit to the writers/creatives! The creatives aren't capable of all that thinking and developing the story around that! Even if they attempt on doing that, it would only take them a couple of weeks before they go their usual shitty route and these writers/creatives are no different! PTSD ka suna bhi nahin hoga inhon ne! If that's what they had planned then they would've taken the story forward accordingly! Irrespective of what the optimists might think, they aren't gonna show anything nice, their only purpose is to somehow glorify the illicit affair and shove KUNAN down the viewers' throats just like any other cliche love story in those Indian soaps! Why don't they understand that this isn't just like any story! The two despicable people except for some (those who salivate after watching the disgusting romance) will never receive any sympathy or support from the larger audience! Ok fine feelings aren't right or wrong but when you act upon your feelings, at that point you'll be either right or wrong, there's no neutrality after that!

Originally posted by: anmirza

@TheMockingBird
Like I have been saying all along, people give too much credit to the writers/creatives! The creatives aren't capable of all that thinking and developing the story around that! Even if they attempt on doing that, it would only take them a couple of weeks before they go their usual shitty route and these writers/creatives are no different! PTSD ka suna bhi nahin hoga inhon ne! If that's what they had planned then they would've taken the story forward accordingly! Irrespective of what the optimists might think, they aren't gonna show anything nice, their only purpose is to somehow glorify the illicit affair and shove KUNAN down the viewers' throats just like any other cliche love story in those Indian soaps! Why don't they understand that this isn't just like any story! The two despicable people except for some (those who salivate after watching the disgusting romance) will never receive any sympathy or support from the larger audience! Ok fine feelings aren't right or wrong but when you act upon your feelings, at that point you'll be either right or wrong, there's no neutrality after that!

During onitial days i also thought they are glorifying EMA as they were using divine connection,BGM and all .I made several posts on it in this forum about that.But my views changed when i saw the pace which the story was moving.CVS never tried to show emotional bonding between kunal and Nandini .If they wanted to justify kunan they would hv spent time in showing emotional bonding of kunal and nandini so that audience will be able to connect .Instead they rushed that track and jumped on EMA track and soon after that jumped on revelation track .This mean their real story theme was something else but not glorification of EMA.What i think they wanted to show consequences of EMA .Writer herself said much before that mauli is her dream character this is even before EMA has started in show .This means she have always wanted to show mauli pov and it was important character for her for story telling.It's just that poor execution,screenplay and some inconsistent writing caused confusion.Baki i will wait and watch to futher give my pov i will jump on conclusions like before.

Originally posted by: TheMockingBird

During onitial days i also thought they are glorifying EMA as they were using divine connection,BGM and all .I made several posts on it in this forum about that.But my views changed when i saw the pace which the story was moving.CVS never tried to show emotional bonding between kunal and Nandini .If they wanted to justify kunan they would hv spent time in showing emotional bonding of kunal and nandini so that audience will be able to connect .Instead they rushed that track and jumped on EMA track and soon after that jumped on revelation track .This mean their real story theme was something else but not glorification of EMA.What i think they wanted to show consequences of EMA .Writer herself said much before that mauli is her dream character this is even before EMA has started in show .This means she have always wanted to show mauli pov and it was important character for her for story telling.It's just that poor execution,screenplay and some inconsistent writing caused confusion.Baki i will wait and watch to futher give my pov i will jump on conclusions like before.

Originally posted by: rajh

time kahan hai??low trps are making channel unhappy..and show is on radar..so cvs trying to save show by showing consequences of EMA from wifes point of view..which trp audience might like..so cvs rushed the story and finished ema romance track and now showing consequences of EMA..

CvS were in rush from beginning only .Bepannah is also one show which are not getting trps and that show too has big names but still colors doing promotion of that show like anything.This show was not properly promotes even it got its first promo just 11 or 12 days before the show .Still this show is doing consistent as it trps are bw 1.3 to 1.6.So i don't think show is any kind of radar for now becoz they know it is controversial subject and wil not be liked by audience so easily. neither i read any news about it from any reliable source.Even if show is at radar wife angle also can't save show becoz the show is shifting to 11pm slot and much improvement can't be expected at this slot

Originally posted by: TheMockingBird

CvS were in rush from beginning only .Bepannah is also one show which are not getting trps and that show too has big names but still colors doing promotion of that show like anything.This show was not properly promotes even it got its first promo just 11 or 12 days before the show .Still this show is doing consistent as it trps are bw 1.3 to 1.6.So i don't think show is any kind of radar for now becoz they know it is controversial subject and wil not be liked by audience so easily. neither i read any news about it from any reliable source.Even if show is at radar wife angle also can't save show becoz the show is shifting to 11pm slot and much improvement can't be expected at this slot

Originally posted by: rajh

thats the point --

colors is unhappy with all three serials--as a punishment they shifted them to late night slot --@ 11 pm this show not going to get good trp --and big budget of this show dose not allow PH to run this show longer time..i

I don't think it's punishment and all it's just that they wanted prime slot for Big Boss as this show is big show for colors.