Broken girl on the floor - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

5.2k

Users

24

Likes

178

Frequent Posters

SummerRain7 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: pamk06


What a beautifully written post 👏and I so completely agree with you on most part but a different take on some other parts. 😊

I know the CV's have blotched up. They messed up on so many story lines. Just this morning, I was thinking that if they would have shown some encounters between Nandini and Kunal where they were just spending time with each other as friends (before the rain dance of course) when Mauli had to suddenly go for emergencies, it might have helped the audience relate more. They just moved from one phase to other, not giving viewers time to connect with Nandini, or Kunal-Nandini as a whole. Maybe it was the backlash that they were getting due to which they had to move the story at a fast pace.

I also agree that we are romantic fools at heart where we lap up everything that Indian TV shows us. Its our fantasy-land in a way. Also, after watching ITV for so long, we all can determine the tracks and things that could happen. So when the story is sold as a love story, we generally want to see all the happy lovey-dovey things that happens and only that. We ignore the murders, the remarriages, the betrayal, the H throwing h out of the house multiple times and even if there is abuse, we do not talk about it. All we want are the hugs, kisses, shirtless leads and lots of eye locks because that is what was promoted and that is what we signed up for.

So this show was promoted as EMA and the heart of this story is EMA and how it destroys agreed but, the backbone of this story is the abuse whether we wish it or no. A girl who wouldn't even think of breaking her marriage and was suffering in silence for so long, is suddenly having an affair with a married man and that too with her friend's husband. They say there is always a silver lining at the end of a tunnel and sometime you latch on to that small ray of hope for survival . May be, in that darkness that her heart was filled up with, Kunal become her silver lining and she latched on to him as a drowning person latches onto a small piece of wood. He became a savior and thus ,the abuse is main factor which connects these two. She because he is her only hope and she looks at him as a protector and he because he wants to protect and has that savior instinct. Each and every step of their story from the beginning even before they knew each other was that she falls down and he picks her up.

If Nandini would not have been abused, she would not have dreamed of breaking her marriage, she would have always been dedicated to Rajdeep whether he loves her or not. And if Nandini was not abused, Kunal's love for Mauli would never have been overshadowed with his need to protect, save and in turn, love Nandini. So, yes people can ignore the abuse and focus on EMA but they cannot avoid it because abuse is the inherent part of this story. Without the abuse, there would have been no EMA and there will be no Kunal and Nandini.

I do understand and agree that when we are so used to seeing everything so explicitly on screen, its difficult for audience to connect with the layers that this story has especially when the CV's have kept us in the dark or not given the reasoning's behind certain actions. Its a failure on their part or may be they are getting cut in the editing.

But, anyways, my post today was only for the @bold. If you cannot sympathize, you should not even belittle something that is so grave.

PS: Yes, his anger was hot, I was waiting for some more action from him but well even the silent anger was treat to the eye. 😆




Thank you !! I understand the intent of your post completely and agree with it. I was also just trying to understand and explain, what it could be ,the are making people indifferent to Nandini's suffering. Because there have been moments when I had to remind myself of the abuse that she suffered or is suffering, which in effect means I'm not quite feeling it for her.
Blue - Yeah!! There used to be a time, when I used to get so high on some ridiculous scenes. I still do 😃at times, but I find myself getting bored of it and when I think about it from a logical point of view, I feel like hiding my face and running.


Green - This was the difference in perception. I could clearly see his savior/protecter instinct coming into play. But I still looked at Nandini's abuse as a plot point and right from the beginning I saw it that way. And yesterday's episode is again making me feel that way. (BTW, Dhrashti was brilliant yesterday. God, she gave me chills the first few mins) But I really wish they hadn't consummated their relationship in this manner. If I had to put it crudely, Kunal actually took advantage of the vulnerability of an abuse victim. They should have kept that for later, when they both are in a happy state of mind. Because everytime there can't be a horrible incident or the threat of a horrible incident to bring them closer. It was quite evident from the last couple of episodes, that they do have strong sexual interest in each other. That should have just played out naturally, which is what happens in reality too. Anyways, what's done is done.


Pink - These two really need to start talking!! I understand that silent communication is the USP of their relationship, but give us self-talks at least. I have given up hope on Kunal's side of the story. It looks like Mauli is the white elephant in the room that they do not want to talk about and that is worrying.

Red - I don't find Shakthi hot.That could be the reason why I sometimes judge him harshly.😃

BeautyForAshes thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: pamk06

I

why are we not seeing the broken girl on the floor?

i have the same questions 👏👏👏

Why are we so focused on the cheating factor? Yes, cheating is wrong but don't you think the abuse that they are showing also requires the same amount of attention.

👏 you have beautifully written

Why are we not seeing that woman who tries to stand up everyday but is pushed down to lower levels by her ex-husband. Is it because she is cheating, she does not deserve our thought? Is her crime really that grave that she deserves those heinous acts that her ex-husband is doing against her?

wow wow👏 ... really out of words here ...you absolutely spoke my mind with those lines⭐️... they think she deserves worse and see what they exactly want to see ..

I had goosebumps yesterday watching the physical assault and was horrified today by seeing the mental assault he did on her but instead we are still stuck on Kunal love explanation.

that's because few people keep comparing the pain of each characters and argue that their favorite characters in the show seems to have suffered the most pain... as far as i have seen all the three has their own problems...and pain... we still do not know kunal's backstory... his father ... and the broken relationship between his mom and dida...( again when i say this ppl i'm there will be people who'd jump on me to say that it doesn't give him the license to cheat... yes i agree... but let us please look beyond EMA as the show itself is about EMA... right?!...

I think Mauli deserves full sympathy/support for what Kunal and Nandini are doing but Nandini, in fact no women, even if she is a pros*****e deserves what Nandini faced yesterday and today and for this abuse that she is facing, she deserves full sympathy.


exactly ... i too feel bad for mauli...i like her character as well...never once disagreed with all the good things she has done...but people are so partial that they are blinded to nandini's sufferings... even after so many episodes of silsils ...the only chant after every episode is about cheater/cheating story... i wish there were posts that come up with something beyond it ..for the characters in general...

overall you said it beautifully👏⭐️... Pam i'm a huge fan of your posts... i happen to read one of yours when logged in after years... this was a lucky next😳as i avoid the degrading posts that keeps talking about NOTHING in general😆...need to appreciate such patience with which ppl come up with all new posts to hate them all over once again...

pamk06 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: SummerRain7

Thank you !! I understand the intent of your post completely and agree with it. I was also just trying to understand and explain, what it could be ,the are making people indifferent to Nandini's suffering. Because there have been moments when I had to remind myself of the abuse that she suffered or is suffering, which in effect means I'm not quite feeling it for her.

Blue - Yeah!! There used to be a time, when I used to get so high on some ridiculous scenes. I still do 😃at times, but I find myself getting bored of it and when I think about it from a logical point of view, I feel like hiding my face and running.

I,also,do watch those shows to kind of unwind after a long day but I stop as soon as its start getting repetitive. No thinking , just watching from pure entertainment perspective. 😛

Green - This was the difference in perception. I could clearly see his savior/protecter instinct coming into play. But I still looked at Nandini's abuse as a plot point and right from the beginning I saw it that way. And yesterday's episode is again making me feel that way. (BTW, Dhrashti was brilliant yesterday. God, she gave me chills the first few mins) But I really wish they hadn't consummated their relationship in this manner. If I had to put it crudely, Kunal actually took advantage of the vulnerability of an abuse victim. They should have kept that for later, when they both are in a happy state of mind. Because everytime there can't be a horrible incident or the threat of a horrible incident to bring them closer. It was quite evident from the last couple of episodes, that they do have strong sexual interest in each other. That should have just played out naturally, which is what happens in reality too. Anyways, what's done is done.

Yes, Dhrishti was amazing. That was some brilliant acting which is very commendable. Also, i do wish they had not consummated their relationship. It was seriously not needed and especially not at that moment. As you say, she was not in her right state of mind so it was Kunal's responsibility to stop. Also, it did not even come across as if he was too shaken up or something and was not in the right state of mind. He seemed to be pretty normal so the scene just did not feel justified. They should have used some other scenario or just shown it as silent companionship or a hug. It would have been more in line with their relationship. Anyways, as you said, whats done is done.


Pink - These two really need to start talking!! I understand that silent communication is the USP of their relationship, but give us self-talks at least. I have given up hope on Kunal's side of the story. It looks like Mauli is the white elephant in the room that they do not want to talk about and that is worrying.

Yes, they need to start talking or atleast some self talk on what they think about Mauli, their feelings, their relationship, at this point anything would do. Like yesterday the whole show, did not have one significant dialogue. Hopefully today.

Red - I don't find Shakthi hot.That could be the reason why I sometimes judge him harshly.😃

I do not find him hot either but I do think he is a very good actor. I am a sucker for those angry, possessive, jealous scenes/heroes where they lose control and the real emotions come out which leaves the "h" all baffled and me with a small smile on my face. 😛 so I did wish that they would have shown his anger more. 😉

My comments in Blue.😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".