neensm thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
if it was only love story then the title is totally wrong.
a man falls in love with kinnar and a normal story. Instead they should show how education will make a kinnar stand on their feet , but it is the other way Harman who is educated is hunting for work to earn livelihood.
on what grounds were they adopting a child when they themselves are unemployed.
creatives are merging everything to make some unbelievable story.

Rubina's dressing up showing all her curves is so much unlike kinnar.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.9k

Users

10

Likes

55

Frequent Posters

Pani.Puri thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Ohhh ... So you basically see a kinner's dressing style to judge them if they're a kinner or not just like how you feel Saumya's dressing style doesnt make her look like a kinner ?? If any kinner in real life has done some proud work for India , I suppose then also you will be looking for that TG's dressing style rather than their hardwork ??? I agree to your point about the adoption thing in regard to Harman Saumya but other things of yours need to be upgraded especially for judging a person by their dressing sense ... BTW I dont find anything wrong with Rubina's saaree .. Her saaree looks awesome to me and quite sexyyy .. And most importantly , your last sentence should be about Saumya and not Rubina bcz Rubina is purely a feminine personality whereas Saumya is a TG so you have done a mix and match and written it wrong that Rubina is kinner .. Plz correct your last sentence ... Its the character played by the actor who is TG and not the actor herself ...
alka2212 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Ohh Plzz it s u who needs to go and find another work instead of coming on unknown forums and speaking nonsense about actors and the show🤣
zubeada thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: alka2212

Ohh Plzz it s u who needs to go and find another work instead of coming on unknown forums and speaking nonsense about actors and the show🤣

🤣
zubeada thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
they will show everything
and this show is about kinnar&normal guy love story from the begining

no one stand on their feet without struggling
so wht they show now is the right path 😳
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
Firstly if u hv watched the show from start then u will realise that the title song Shakti played on 2 people .. first on Nimmi when she used to protect Soumya from kinners and later on Harman when he started protecting Soumya from the society ... So the basic concept of the show was how Harman becomes Soumya's rakshak , her shakti and soulmate despite knowing her identity and supports her against all odds ..and till now this concept is kept intact in the show as Harman still continues to b Soumya's shakti, rakshak and soulmate ..so basically it was always a love story between a man and a transwomen as show tried to depict how even transgenders hv the right to lead a normal life and love someone ...

Secondly I think u should go through different articles that r available on google to know more about intersex , kinners and transwomen and also their dressing style etc etc ..in case u r not aware , every year there is separate Miss world and Miss universe contests held for transgender community where they wear even swimsuits and trust me they r gorgeous looking people .. they hv a body of a woman only .. just that they dont hv the basic female reproductive organ .. Soumya in the show is appropriately dressed .. kinners r not aliens and do hv great figure with grt curves ..

Thirdly mayb u should edit your post and mention Soumya instead of Rubina there because Rubina is an actress and a female who is playing the role of a kinner .. plss dont confuse between the actor and character ..

Fourthly yes HaYa did a blunder by adopting a baby when they were unemployed themselves and thats why they paid the price for it too as their baby was snatched away from them because they could not arrange the money instantly .. So CVs did show the consequences of what happens when u r not financially independent .. HaYa learnt from their mistake and this is what today has motivated Harman to become financially independent .. isn't that grt storytelling ??

Last but not the least , show is still on air and Soumya's education track will come too just how Harman becoming financially independent is going on right now .. they cannot show everything at one go or else show will b over tomorrow itself .. so wait and watch 😳


Edited by jyoti06 - 8 years ago
H_H_ thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
Only point I agree upon, is the so-far ignored importance of Education. It's high time Indian TV give due focus to Education and its importance, especially for those deprived of it for whatever reasons. I do hope that in Shakti in the future, there would be a whole track purely and properly dedicated for focusing on Educating Saumya, and showcasing the impact of that on her personality and her life.

Other than that, I don't agree.

Firstly, for everybody, having someone/s in our lives, who love us deep, true & unconditional love (all sorts of love; motherly or fatherly, sisterly or brotherly, or romantic) is a tremendous source of shakti that provides motivation & support, and helps in building self-confidence.

As for ("Saumya" -not Rubina-) having curves, it's completely normal! Please do the effort of googling intersex ppl and all their sorts and varieties and different shapes.

In regards of her dressing style being different from other kinnars... what do you expect? She was Never raised in a kinnar community, from where would she gain the knowledge of their sense of style?! As an adult, she was kidnapped and forced to live with them for a short while, and every thing was completely alien and suffocating for her, she never felt comfortable with their clothing or with any aspect of their day-to-day lives! And why would she? She was raised as any normal Punjabi girl!
Or do u think like the stupid Singh Household? Sticking all kinnar community's qualities and mannerisms to Saumya, just coz she's born a kinnar?! As if kinnars are born with all those morals and traditions, and have not acquired these habits due to isolating them into those communities that go by those rules, traditions & habits?

If you want to criticize Saumya's sense of style, then compare it with normal middle class Gurdaspur girls of her age and with same social background she grew up within...!
1114082 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Accctually...her dressing showing alll curves is Completely unlike her being showing sooo very ultraaa innocent and dont know anything ...shooo maasum...waaah 👏
965319 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: neensm

if it was only love story then the title is totally wrong.

a man falls in love with kinnar and a normal story. Instead they should show how education will make a kinnar stand on their feet , but it is the other way Harman who is educated is hunting for work to earn livelihood.
on what grounds were they adopting a child when they themselves are unemployed.
creatives are merging everything to make some unbelievable story.

Rubina's dressing up showing all her curves is so much unlike kinnar.

Respect your opinion,but love and companionship and the support of a loved one is IMO far more important than education in helping someone realise their potential.
Saumya is crippled in may ways and her journey will take time and given how long lasting Indian tv serials can be ,I am sure we are talking years here😆
Edited by marcello - 8 years ago
Shonal8 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10
If one googles they will find at least three news articles, where males have married intersex women, 2 in India and 1 in Bangladesh. It is even more common in the west.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".