What was the point? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

2.6k

Users

14

Likes

160

Frequent Posters

sushma_01 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21
Sheemu di, I totally agree with you! The whole build up that they gave us looked as if we were about to get a totally wonderful track. I wanted to see Suhana's love for Ishaan, the deep bonding that they would have, Suhana realizing the importance of a family slowly just like they showed in OBS.
But here, we had to wait for two weeks to get the report, and all of a sudden they wrap up the whole operation and post operative care in like 15 mins flat???!!! 😡😡 Even if they had to do that they could have shown some meaningful scene b/w Ishaan n Suhana before the surgery. The last scene on Tuesday could have been better if there was some emotion b/w them, but instead lending support to his wife Ishaan went on to say some crap about God's market share like a total dork!!

Also, I was suprised that Ishaan had not met the doctor till the last moment. He was asking the doc 'Suhana ko koi takleef nahi hoga na??' I mean, did he not meet the doctor and discuss the whole procedure before hand? Any normal person would do that atleast the day before surgery. CVs are ruining Ishaan's character completely!
radpat25 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#22

I know it was ended hurridly...that too in one episode ...its really was dissappointing...especially to those who have been thru such a situation in real life...but we all knew it didnt we...and we know the reason behind all this too...TRP...this is how the cookie crumbles in indian tv industry ...sadly...no place for emotions and sensibility...if we all get so irritated...i can imagine the frustration of the makers...they handled the most sensitive things sooo wonderfully...gave us some wonderful emotional tracks like RB-Deepak,panna tracks...they had to end this BT track in such a manner...It started on a very good note...with some really wonderful scenes...and like shounak said...who knows,they must have shot for future episodes of the cancer track too...but if one fine day SP comes and says its not working...change it...what to do...work day and night and try to make it as logical as possible...within the limited available time and with the available actors...and yesterday they genuinely tried to make it believable...though ishaan asking the doctor abt the surgery minutes before the surgery was indigestible...i agree..anyway...this track was totally messed up...so the more we try to find logic in all this the more we will be dissappointed...wats the point...its over for them and for us too.

@sheemadi...i agree..they could have shown this speed to get the reports...which tested our patience...khatam hi karna tha BT track, toh aur jaldi ho jaata...but instead we had to see all those fillers...forced comedy...Comedy scenes dalne ki farmaish bhi SP ki hi hogi...i am sure...to make the show lighthearted 🤢...but all this just made a mockery of an emotional track..that too related to a disease.
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23
@chandraditya. Yes dear I am tired. Today I am feeling to tired to be bothered by it. I don't want to think about what could've been done as its makes me sad
589799 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
@Sheemu Di. I kind of agree with you. But I am tired of being tired. When Netri said that there was a scene where Suhana felt that her mother was there with her during the operation and SGP didn't show it. I got annoyed. It could be a beautiful scene. As a compensation I am going to write that scene in my FF soon. I really want to write that.

@Aneesha If you see my post, then can you just check the comment I made on my short story which I posted. I have a question for you. Here's the link:

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=1634148&PID=41906213&#41906213

Thanks. 😊
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
Yes Sheema di, that really was one of the best Ishaan and Lolita momens. It really showed how deeply she cared for him. We have yet to see that from Suhana
meenakshi_16 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
@mjtruelegend i think u should not hope or expect something to happen...or else u'll jst go on expecting n the show will end one day but ur wish wont be fulfilled

i was not a obs viewer...did'nt knew anything about obs...i read the scenes that were missed out in sgp and even i feel "kash yeh hota"...
i even tried to watch those scenes in youtube of obs...but still not satisfied becoz i want ragini to be there.
now i have stoped hoping anything
Edited by meenakshi_16 - 14 years ago
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
@sushma and aneesha. Thankyou both for your inputs. Of course I agree with the things you have said. What is done, can not be changed but I am not expecting them to make amends with any of the missed parts. Just take each day as it comes.
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#28
@ Farikina. You are right dear, they really have made a total mockery of an incredibly sensitive issue. Never mind!
mjtruelegend thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#29
@radpat25. Thankyou for your reply. Yes I cam understand the frustration of the makers but I still don't understand why a BRAIN SURGERY was wrapped up in less than 30 minutes. This is why it didn't make the full impact. Yes we've had some wonderful moments. Shame there were only a few and far between. Overall its a disaster. They should have just done exactly what OBS did rather than making changes.
madhu_d thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
@sheemu dont say like that yaar.. " M" hurted Why??? i tell you.

  • ishaan character is the most inconsistent in SGP
  • Suhana can b made to look like a patient with an creative hairstyle (curly)
  • New definition of sachha pyaar.
  • There is no place & time for comedy...Timing is not needed.
  • BT is no more dangerous it can b cured in no time...provided you have a family like kashyap's and there is no need for patient to stay calm..they can shout at the top of their voice, dance, play...etc.etc.
  • SGP is no more a lighthearted romantic comedy..its an comedy drama
  • Expectations always remain as expectations.
  • And the most important a hurried start should have and hurried end.
is these not enough ????

kya bolu yaar i was totally disappointed with this track...no words to say...the centre point of this track was to show the real love and affection of suhaana towards ishaan which was forgotten altogether and there left no point in showing this track…

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".