Ishaan is seriously CREEPY.. *VB Note* Pg 11

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

krait

@krait

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: minu_8
Count me also in the disappointed ones.
That scene in OBS is seriously cuuute.
I dont understand bengali even one word. But whatever i could make out of the words that sound like hindi.. i dont think lolita said anything about how she was fed up of everyone talking about scooter so she got it back.. there was none of that irritation on her face like suhana which i loved. i didnt like the reason suhana gave for not getting it back... and right now i am not ready to believe that its subconscious and suhana is not ready to admit why she did etc etc. and if lolita also did really give the same reason and i didnt understand even then, i think llita's gesture seemed more heartfelt than Suhana's. and lolita also asks ishaan if he is happy so sweetly.. and their ankhon ke isharein were soooo cute.. and the way lolita agreed. I agree ragini is a fantastic actress but i think i personally like lolita's character more... during this whole car/scooter episode i feel lolita showed more genuine emotions than suhana... SGP really screwed up the whole thing :( OBS is such a treat to watch even if one doesnt understand bengali.. I LOVE ishaan/lolita chemistry..
I hope i didnt offend Suhana fans.

i doubt you went through whole thread before posting...

i think there is a misunderstanding... here nobody is saying lolita's character or the actress who played lolita is not good....ragini and lolita(i dont know her name) cannot be compared... both are playing the same character but in their own way.... so both are good....

like you even we all are disappointed that sgp messed up the scooter scene....

i agree lolita showed more genuine emotions than suhana during the scooter scene but i dont blame ragini for that....sgp creatives are to be blamed for this....may be in obs they wanted to show that lolita is slowly falling for ishaan so she was shown reacting more emotionally when ishaan says he sold his scooter....but in sgp they played the whole scooter track differently....may be they are thinking bcoz sgp airs on national tv, the audience dont understand emotionse and they like things that are OTT ...

Edited by krait - 14 years ago

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 14 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: minu_8
Count me also in the disappointed ones.
That scene in OBS is seriously cuuute.
I dont understand bengali even one word. But whatever i could make out of the words that sound like hindi.. i dont think lolita said anything about how she was fed up of everyone talking about scooter so she got it back.. there was none of that irritation on her face like suhana which i loved. i didnt like the reason suhana gave for getting it back... and right now i am not ready to believe that its subconscious and suhana is not ready to admit why she did etc etc. and if lolita also did really give the same reason and i didnt understand even then, i think llita's gesture seemed more heartfelt than Suhana's. and lolita also asks ishaan if he is happy so sweetly.. and their ankhon ke isharein were soooo cute.. and the way lolita agreed. I agree ragini is a fantastic actress but i think i personally like lolita's character more and i like the way OBS actress has done it... during this whole car/scooter episode i feel lolita showed more genuine emotions than suhana... SGP really screwed up the whole thing :( OBS is such a treat to watch even if one doesnt understand bengali.. I LOVE ishaan/lolita chemistry..
I hope i didnt offend Suhana fans.

This is an interesting viewpoint.....personally I didn't find anything wrong with Suhana's reactions....they were totally in keeping with her characterization at this point.....Ishaan's character is the one that is being messed up compared to the one in OBS.....we all have our own preferences....I prefer Suhana to Lolita....Lolita is sweet as well but I can easily picture Ragini doing that scene just as well if not better than the OBS actress....no offense to fans of the actress....this is just my viewpoint.

Like Krait has said above, it is the SGP creatives that messed up majorly in this scooter scene by showing Ishaan in such an OTT manner and missing out an opportunity to show a sweet and poignant Ishaan-Suhana scene and developing their equation further.

Edited by nureat01 - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

LadyMcbeth

@LadyMcbeth

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

#53

Originally posted by: nureat01
LOL now I wouldn't generalize also, LadyM....I do think Jay has done quite well many times....we shouldn't take that away from him....for e.g. I liked his acting in the jail scene when Suhana sleeps on his shoulder, going further back....the scene post the muh dikhaai, the scene when Suhana finally says to him that she won't leave the house....the guy has held his own and acted well.....so we can't say in general that Ishaan is only a wimpy loser who makes out with his scooter and talks to the teddy bear....those moments are the ones I dread no doubt but they aren't ALL that is there to him....I just wish the creatives realized that and stopped showing Ishaan as such an OTT mental-looking ghonchu

Yeah, I know you are right... I'm just in a grumpy mood today. It's just that they show such rare moments of Ishaan's maturity, and more moments of him bhondu-ness these days. Nahin toh ... initially I had truly defended Ishaan's character. Lekin aaj kaal it is very hard to see Ishaan/Suhana as a couple. The makers HAVE to show some more chemistry lead pair to make it look credible. And by chemistry I don't mean towel-dropping awkwardness or hawtness depicted SO many times in the S1 serials, but subtle undercurrents ... Unfortunately it is an art very few makers can manage to capture and show on TV. But given that they could do it in OBS and are struggling to do so in SGP is surprising. Like you said, it will be interesting to see Rajdeep (OBS Ishaan) and Ragini together ...

Quote

428419

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#54

LOL..Yeah...he was really creepy with the scooter scene..especially when he was asking Suhana to sid behind him for a ride..I found that part really OTT and forced😕😕

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 14 years ago

#55

@LadyM: I think SGP prefers focussing on Suhana's relationship with the rest of the family than developing the IS equation/chemistry in a more credible fashion sometimes.....and showing scenes like this scooter one further makes them seem less credible as a couple.

btw I'd asked you in the previous post also.....did they show that jail scene in OBS as well?? When Suhana sleeps on Ishaan's shoulder.....if yes, can someone post the video for it?

Quote

krait

@krait

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#56

Originally posted by: nureat01
@LadyM: I think SGP prefers focussing on Suhana's relationship with the rest of the family than developing the IS equation/chemistry in a more credible fashion sometimes.....and showing scenes like this scooter one further makes them seem less credible as a couple.

btw I'd asked you in the previous post also.....did they show that jail scene in OBS as well?? When Suhana sleeps on Ishaan's shoulder.....if yes, can someone post the video for it?

@bold: i hope you remember what Zama Habib had said in an article few weeks back....

sgp is love story between suhana and kashyap family....
i think they have taken this too seriously.... i dont expect much from them after scooter scene...

and i dont think there was any such jail scene in obs... but i m not sure...

Edited by krait - 14 years ago

Quote

428419

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#57

Originally posted by: krait

@bold: i hope you remember what Zama Habib had said in an article few weeks back....

sgp is love story between suhana and kashyap family....
i think they have taken this too seriously.... i dont expect much from them after scooter scene...

and i dont think there was any such jail scene in obs... but i m not sure...

Yup..there was one krait..as funny as SGP one...but cudnt find the video..I actually have to go thru so many written updates in OBS forum to see which date did they air the epi and then find it online😆Once I find it..will try to post it😊

EDIT

btw welcome to the forum krait...Have seen many of ur posts here recently..So we have another critical member on board👏Pls keep posting😳😃

Edited by shounak-rijul1 - 14 years ago

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 14 years ago

#58

Arey Shounak baba padhaare hain! Welcome ji, Welcome😆......so any "future hints" for us?😛😆

Originally posted by: krait

@bold: i hope you remember what Zama Habib had said in an article few weeks back....

sgp is love story between suhana and kashyap family....
i think they have taken this too seriously.... i dont expect much from them after scooter scene...

and i dont think there was any such jail scene in obs... but i m not sure...

Yeah I remember what the writer had said....but I find it amusing how they forget that Ishaan is also a part of that family and that he can't be lumped into the same "love story" as the rest of the family.....is there no difference b/w the relationship that Suhana shares with Ishaan and that with the rest of the family?? Isn't the husband-wife relationship supposed to have a different sort of "love"?😆

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 14 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: shounak-rijul1

Yup..there was one krait..as funny as SGP one...but cudnt find the video..I actually have to go thru so many written updates in OBS forum to see which date did they air the epi and then find it online😆Once I find it..will try to post it😊

Are they airing the tracks out of order from OBS?? Cuz I'd expect that if it's the same timeline, then the jail scene should have been in the end January epis of OBS if they've shown it, no?

Quote

LadyMcbeth

@LadyMcbeth

Sparkler

Posted: 14 years ago

#60

It wasn't quite the same. But here you go Anu:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/user/sumism1#p/u/1619/8JwXJ-LBZmI[/YOUTUBE]

From 6:12 onwards ...

Exactly Anu! The makers seem to have forgotten that Suhana's love for Ishaan can't just crop up one day when she sees him cozing up with his old girl friend. Their relationship has to evolve gradually... and cannot be lumped into Suhana's love for the family.

Edited by LadyMcbeth - 14 years ago