Was Sadhna's fear not valid? - Page 2

i think in such circumstances it is very difficult to maintain firm attitude(control0 ...here I would appreciate Sadi....

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

I think my topic is more on Sadhna's not changed nature whereas the oher one is directly pointing that Sadhna has changed....

My point was basically that since there was already a topic discussing Sadhna's reaction, another topic seemed unneccesary, however I don't have a problem with you creating another topic. I feel like the other is saying more that Sadhna's reaction was unlike her character that has been portrayed so far simply because sadhna has never been known to yell at anyone. I don't think sadhna did anything wrong, her reaction is completely justified under the circumstances. It was a very natural reaction. Many people freak out in emergency situattions. I know I do.

Originally posted by: Bini311

Bani, if you are hinting that I took the shade of Creatives to blame Sadi, than let me tell you I don't have to hide under anything to point out my opinion. Having seen Bidaai, for the last two years, and knowing the characters very well, the way Sadi snapped at Ragi was unexpected, shocking and surprising...and we have seen enough drama in these show before...enough stressful episodes....but never seen such reaction...so perhaps it is not Sadi's reaction..it is not her character.....and now suddenly.........so I was upset with Creatives for tampering with the basic characteristics of the person...

Ofcourse when panic, people can react in different ways, some can snap at others or some can loose their voice.......but knowing Sadhana, I would have thought she would have gone with the later.

i understand why sadhna slapped ranvir

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

Sadhna is not God... that she cannot falter. Yeh, in majority of the cases, it is shown that she is the most stable character with proper judgement sense. One reaction can never spoil a character and that too at such a moment. That's what I am saying.

Well said. Sadhana had a very rough childhood. She was always under pressure to prove herself. Her main concern had always been to make sure that there are no complications in Ragini's marriage due to her presence. Now that Ragini is well settled and having a blissful married life, Sadhana can finally think about her own life. With positive changes in Alekh, she can see her dreams coming true. She had 2 concerns in yesteday's episode :
1. Alekh and Ranveer's life was in danger.
2. Alekh's condition taking a U-turn.

Basically her hope/dream of having a good life shattered and she panicked for the very first time. She is still the same old Sadhana who loves and cares for everyone.

Both Sadhana and Vasu should have shut the phone off instead of nagging at him so that he could have gone back to Alekh and his driving.

Its a common reaction for you,for me or for anyone else but not for the character of Sadhana we saw till now-Possible RIFT

I agree, raginis behavior was weak and uncalled for..im very disappointed