swasthi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
So what is the message that is relayed through this track?


... karma vs dharma
... good over evil
or ... the sinking of the titanic Saathiya


From the start till the arrival of Radha we relished in the unfolding of the romance of Ahem and Gopi and wondered about her past. This particular story line is what really appealed to the wider audience.

Since then the show has been nothing short of sibling rivalry and verminous revenge that multiplied infinitesimally spirally and metamorphosing into lessons on moral relativism.

Why take the audience down this path?

Why develop the lead character from a naive and innocent girl to a justice driven person?

What does the future hold for Gopi?

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

2.3k

Users

6

Likes

10

Frequent Posters

ani_gr thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Hey Swasti.. Nice to see you after such a long time... 🤗.. How are you ?
The end of Radha has been shown as evil be destroyed and the truth winning... What I feel is that Kokila/Gopi gave Radha enough time and also enough gyan not to do what she wanted to do... So at the end when she does not listen to any of the pleads, Gopi had to kill her..
As you see in Gita, Krishna Bhagwan also has said the same thing.. people who take everything from an evil person is sinner even compared to the one who does it... so I think they finally tried showing us that evil dies..
As for Gopi, she did not mind going to jail, but she destroyed the evil..
Not sure of how Gopi's cgaracter is going to unfold after the leap..😃
kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: swasthi

So what is the message that is relayed through this track?



... karma vs dharma
... good over evil
or ... the sinking of the titanic Saathiya


From the start till the arrival of Radha we relished in the unfolding of the romance of Ahem and Gopi and wondered about her past. This particular story line is what really appealed to the wider audience.

Since then the show has been nothing short of sibling rivalry and verminous revenge that multiplied infinitesimally spirally and metamorphosing into lessons on moral relativism.

Why take the audience down this path?

Why develop the lead character from a naive and innocent girl to a justice driven person?

What does the future hold for Gopi?



Kokila herself wanted Gopi to fight for the justice & stand for what is right. She had tried to make Gopi open her mouth against what is wrong & was getting pissed off when she was keeping quiet.

If she had to go to the extent of dirtying her hands, it was better that she was in her original self.



swasthi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: ani_gr

Hey Swasti.. Nice to see you after such a long time... 🤗.. How are you ?

The end of Radha has been shown as evil be destroyed and the truth winning... What I feel is that Kokila/Gopi gave Radha enough time and also enough gyan not to do what she wanted to do... So at the end when she does not listen to any of the pleads, Gopi had to kill her..
As you see in Gita, Krishna Bhagwan also has said the same thing.. people who take everything from an evil person is sinner even compared to the one who does it... so I think they finally tried showing us that evil dies..
As for Gopi, she did not mind going to jail, but she destroyed the evil..
Not sure of how Gopi's cgaracter is going to unfold after the leap..😃


Hey there Gayatri 🤗


kavitha_r thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
If it is about karma & dharma then the foremost karma & dharma is about taking care of her own family first. The rest of the things follow later.

Gopi had promised Ahem that she will never leave him but did not keep up her word. What was the point in killing Radha after Kokila had caught Rashi?

What was the need for her to take the law to her hands? There were many ways to kill Radha but the CV's chose that Radha should die in Gopi's hands. It seems that the CV's do not understand the karma-dharma concept.
Xarina thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Swasthi good to see your post. In all honesty I don't even think that the writers know what the future holds for Gopi or ahem, come to that. It is whatever their pea brains come up with. Won't be holding my breath I'm afraid.
touch_of_pink thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Hi Swasthi.
I'm new to the forum. But I was an avid reader of your Ahem and Love posts, they were very beautifully written and always brought up points that I had never thought of about a particular scene.

My answers to your questions:

Why take the audience down this path?

To achieve high TRPs.

In fact yesterday I realised that the record for the highest rated episode so far is for Devon Ke Dev Mahadev where Maa Kali kills a particular demon (apologies, I don't remember exactly which one). I'm not sure, maybe DABH had beaten the record at one point, but the DKDM episode reached 8.2 TVR. Bearing this in mind, noticing that these episodes were going to be telecast in Mahashivratri week and realising that they needed to reach a high dramatic point before the leap, I think this is why they went with this sequence.

If you were asking why the show started focusing on Radha and her so-called 'revenge', then I blame that on TRPs as well. TRPs have remained constantly high, SNS is in top 3 shows, therefore the writers assume viewers love Radha and also do not feel creatively challenged to show something different. So they have been going along with this 'Radha saga' as I like to call it.

Why develop the lead character from a naive and innocent girl to a justice driven person?

Because that is the destiny of every Star Plus bahu. 😆

But here I would also like to say that although Gopi was naive and innocent before, she always had her own way of showing the difference between right and wrong. She was a person who had quiet strength and immense patience. Remember that time when Kinjal had asked Ahem and Kokila for a huge sum of money (or something along those line) and Gopi had employed a clever tactic to show Kinjal the error of her ways?

I'm trying to say that it's okay if she became driven for justice. But I wanted her to strive for it in her own way, the Gopi way, with Kanhaji as her guide, her smartness, quiet strength and patience that she possessed. Stabbing someone to death with a trishul...I can't come to terms with that. They should have used Maa Durga or Maa Kali defeating evil as a reference point, as in every woman has an inner strength that comes out to defeat evil in real life. And this does not necessary have to be shown as literally killing someone, especially in a show like SNS where things had never gone this extreme in the past.

What does the future hold for Gopi?

At this point, Gopi's future seems very predictable to me. I actually made a post about this:



I apologize for my cynicism. But I've been watching these shows for so long that I've started to notice a pattern and have picked up on the usual tricks of the trade. 😆

I also apologize for the long essay. 😳
MADHYAMAVATHI thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
As for the CV's prolonging the Radha track for maintaining the high TRP's, SNS had always maintained high TRP's even before the Radha saga. In fact I feel the TRP's would have been much higher had the saga been ended much earlier. Many loyal fans were also getting irritated by the prolonging of this track.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".