i don't think Aamir deserved power packed - Page 2

soorryy guys but my opinion is that ammir is the best among all ... rohanpreet n anamika both come sec for me, tammnay is good tooo but vasandura sorry she never impressed me .. i m goin to agree with CHARTBUSTER some time her voice really irritates me tooo....
sorry again no offense to neone..it is just my opinion... 😊

Originally posted by: Pradarshak

Bhaskarji aapne meri dil ki baat kaha hai. If anyone deserved the powerpacked performance it should have been Rohanpreet for Sureshji special episode. He has gifted "mithas" in his voice and it was a very balanced performance for that song.

Today Sonu pointed the right thing about Anamika that she is an excellent singer only when it comes to commercial songs.

Amir did exceptionally good at places, but overall he did not get the feel of the song. (May be I too biased with the original song) May be he is too young to get the feel of this song(Gulzar saab Zindabad! Illya Rajaji Zindabad! Suresh Wadkarji Zindabad!)

I am never very much impressed by Tanmay's performance.

I was disappointed with Vasundhara, may be the thought of elimination affected her singing.

i feel the same about the song aye zindagi.....simply adore it.

I felt the same way as Bhaskar and Rohanpreet was the best .Even in the republicday parade he was very good.Tanmay also never touches my heart too.I never liked Vasundhara.Anamika is good but compared to other girls in another show she fades out and mentally I am always comparing her with them.sonu is hyping Amir and Vasundhara.This is my opinion only.

I love the song ye zindagi ..Illyaraja is a genius and Gulzar is another.

I think Amir deserved it today !!!!

I thort they were all good, but Anamika wasn't as gr8 as she usually is. I think Rohan did gr8, even Vasu did very well. N while Tanmay's was peppy, it doesn't mean it was easy to sing. He did gr8!!!!!! 😃 😃 😃

Originally posted by: minimouse2007

in today's episode i don't think Aamir deserved the power packed performance award.he did some golmaal with lyrics but no one pointed out..somehow i feel sonu is a little biased towards him...he never says negative to him...well he did point somethings but....

Still i feel tanmay's performance was more power packed...

Amir darely deserved it... He gave the best performance among all without any doubt. Vishalji commented perfectly for everyone's performance. And he admired amir the most. Even he pointed out Tanmay's mistake. And i think He was the best ever judge in any reality show....Judges are not biased towards Amir as they give him "A" for the comments buhat accha, excellent....and they give rohanpreet "A" for the comments aaj gaana dheela tha. And they give vasundhra "A" for the comments sur bikhra bikhra tha, kacha kacha laga gana....Then how can you say that???

If I am right in reading the 2nd Feb update it duz not say anything about AAMIR getting the power packed performance so I havent a clue what u are talking about?? It says Vasundhra gets it..?????

Originally posted by: redbia

Amir darely deserved it... He gave the best performance among all without any doubt. Vishalji commented perfectly for everyone's performance. And he admired amir the most. Even he pointed out Tanmay's mistake. And i think He was the best ever judge in any reality show....Judges are not biased towards Amir as they give him "A" for the comments buhat accha, excellent....and they give rohanpreet "A" for the comments aaj gaana dheela tha. And they give vasundhra "A" for the comments sur bikhra bikhra tha, kacha kacha laga gana....Then how can you say that???

i completely agree. They need to give grades according to what their comments are. I'm so sick of hear mixed comments with the same grade. They need a reality check cuz their grades basically mean nothing. Everyone gets the same thing and when the audience votes someone out the judges blame them for not voting for the right person.

If they care so much about the rite person then they should give out proper grades that rank each kid based on how they sang. Not just give everyone A's cuz that means they are all equal and we can kick out who ever we want. Or they could stop complaining.

Originally posted by: bBSs

If I am right in reading the 2nd Feb update it duz not say anything about AAMIR getting the power packed performance so I havent a clue what u are talking about?? It says Vasundhra gets it..?????

yea i think they may be talking about a different day...this Sat it was Vasundra who got the power packed performance.

The point coming to Sonu being biased towards aamir I do not believe for a second. As Sonu duz critisize aamir most of the time in the past few episodes so I do not know what you are trying to imply.?????? As some ppl will agree with me also on this matter.