Aamir Hafeez 'Mera Rang De Basanti Chola'

hi guys, just wanna know what did everyone think of Amirs Mera Rang De Basanti chola song?

and please do not compare it to Rohanpreets Rang De Basanti Chola song.

It was an easy song maybe thats why Amir got an A but really dont you think it was atleast worth like A+ ....?

share your views xXx

Aamir's performance was rlllyyy good and he should have got a A+ as it was a very hard song to sing and he put lots of effort in it.

😊

ALSO he was looking 'v. handsome' as sonu nigam said lollzzzz 😛 😛

Originally posted by: m_khan90

Definetly I will give an A+. As Sonuji said it was a difficult song sung by three playback sigers. I usually not fond of patriotic songs that much but I have listened to Amir's rendition several times. I dont know what happened to the judges no matter how good he sangs but they never gave A+ lately. They take out so minute mistakes of Amir which was not so important. In jiya Dhadk jaye sonu's comment was like shocking. He totally did not like it and he said there is no soul in it. I hate judges mentality first chadho and then at the time of winning girado for obvious reasons.

You have a point. i didnt reallt think of it first but its not fair the way Sonu said its an easy song then said that 3 singers sang it. in my point of view Amir should have been credited more for singing a 3 men song alone. how could it be easy singing it alone when originally 2-3 singers sang it? it should have been A+.... The judges are not grading him fair and i think it will cost him the competition

Originally posted by: m_khan90

Sonu did say it is a difficult song and since three ppl sang it there is no chance of taking a breath and Amir has done a good job. Sonu did said that but he gave an A only.

Sonu also realise that his comment effect the Amir's getting a B div. He mention that in the program. Now I have to see what he is going to do in futue episodes.

in that episode sonu said its an easy song with only 1 difficult part. i think maybe thats why he just gave him A

Originally posted by: m_khan90

Sonu said that in listening it seems/feel that it is an easy song. That means it is NOT an easy song.

ok ..... i think i misunderstood it, thanks for clearing that up 4 me

well now i just done understand why he didnt get an A+ then. defo not fair

i think he should have gotten an A+

Whats wrong with Sonu Nigam ji??He used to like aamir.
I think Zee network spoke with sonu and said that it is the last stage and it is time for aamir to go!I would really be disappointed.

Originally posted by: Zidane-nedved

Whats wrong with Sonu Nigam ji??He used to like aamir.
I think Zee network spoke with sonu and said that it is the last stage and it is time for aamir to go!I would really be disappointed.

but why do they want Aamir to go? I really hope that this isn't true...but I agree that he should have gotten an A+.

If the judges are not "hyped" by his performance then the people will think (he did not impressed sonu or suresh so he do not deserve my vote)

Originally posted by: Zidane-nedved

If the judges are not "hyped" by his performance then the people will think (he did not impressed sonu or suresh so he do not deserve my vote)

true the judges thoughts on the champ affect the general public voting system

sonu does like amir alot but just dont know..... maybe he wants amir 2 improve more and give outstanding performances

but cuz of this if Amir is eliminated then that will be unfair