debate in IBN 7 channel on srgmp

There was one hr programme in ibn7 channel debating about reality show with topic 'besur and sur' and how channels are looting and paly with the sentiment of the public and earn money on sms and voting. The participants in the discussion were khayyaam M.D , a reporter of ibn7 and sony tv in charge of indian idol , annu malik MD and Ismail darbarji. The question put up by ID to media is "though All over india voting was pouring for raja .and while slogan of raja in all the channels, were so loud, how raja got a difference of 25 lakhs. less . He further added that in his view Amanat was the best of all and consistently sang well and nobody found any mistake in his singing from . the beginning ,so amanat was best singer than two, as far as voting is concerned raja got more vote than anybody else. He will challenge on this point. Then how aneek suddenly got 25 lakhs more vote. zee tv has no right to play with sentiment of public who spend so much to their contestant. Zee tv brought Amanat from pakistan then why sms and voting was not allowed from pakistan and spoiled his chance of winning while zee tv has earned lot of money on amanat's name . khayyam ji , ibn 7 reporter and ismailji on one side and sony channel was giving his justification of voting and annu malik was neutral in discussion..Sandeep was the host of the show. ID was teling that he was 100% sure and confident that zee tv has made some adjustment to make aneek winner.

In another channel zee tv ashish asked when debojit won why ID did not have any objection.

In my view debojit winning was justified bcos the three contestants of top 4 made a walk over on debojit getting top1 out of four that made assam , east india to vote for debojit with an vengence of insulting their contestant [ assam] in final after they did walkover and hemachandra though he sang well he did not get much vote bcos he too joined in the walkover drama.

NOW THE PUBLIC BECAME AWARE OF THIS CHEATING, ANYBODY CAN FOOL ANYTIME BUT NOT ALWAYS.

PUBLIC WILL BECOME MORE CAREFUL IN FUTURE.

It is an eye-opener . How these channels exploit people emotionally . Hope people will think before spending their money on such shows.

****

Debo a crap singer won becasue of voting manipulation. It was ID who must have asked zee to make him the winner of 2005 challenge.

I will say this now if it wasn't for the walk out nonsense of which ID took advantage then vinit would have been the winner and he was much deserving. Nonetheless he is singing more for his mentor then debo becasue ID doesn't care about Debo at all. He just wanted him to win that is it.

Also why aneek won is because when aneek first came to show ID made fun of him and treated him like crap.

Moderator's Note: Post edited.. Commenting on personal life of the music directors and making personal attack is against the rules of the forum.. The member is being warned for the same and asked not to make such comments in the future

Is there any video online of this discussion?

Originally posted by: a406a4

All of that = unsubstantiated bollocks.

Zee has nothing to gain or lose by declaring Aneek the winner. ID is renowned for hypocrisy, throughout the competition, he told Aneek that may he become the winner, and now he's contradicting himself?!.

who knows zee has anything to gain or lose by declaring aneek a winner. It is zee who send aneek in short cut after he won srgmp bengal .ID wished to poonam ,raja, aneek ,sumedha, and amanat and once to mussrat also when they extraordianrily sing well. . ID is not hypocrisy but some time harsh when some injustice is done to anybody.

he praised a lottttt raja & aneek in show while degraded amanat more with faults & donno why he is acting like this now😕...he was aware amanat was third & didnt get that much votes like raja or aneek from beginning of thsi show too... Raja/Amanat got first place many times while amanat become first only in one episode...

I guess he is doing this just to stay in limelight so that he get some attention as he dont have any works after this show till SRGMP 2008 happens... 😕 donno whether he will be in 2008 too if he is doing liek this...

Dont he know he himself took AMANAT from Dubai & not from Pak...He were calling like Dubai kki Mahabali till patriotic episode too & its him made amanat into pakistan region...why now complaining...

also its 13 lakh difference rt? not 25 lakhs...

if he says debo win is justified as others walkout then why cant he can think like when Pak were in bottom 3 Amanat also mentioned abt Indian public too becoz of this bias voting...But still he didnt out & stayed so longgg....I didnt see him praising HEMA much in 2005 times too & now telling like since hema joined in walkout he also got out...

Can I watch this video somewhere online?

Originally posted by: musickimasti

ID is a foolish guy who ditched his previous wife for a new one. No one can trust him.

Debo a crap singer won becasue of voting manipulation. It was ID who must have asked zee to make him the winner of 2005 challenge.

I will say this now if it wasn't for the walk out nonsense of which ID took advantage then vinit would have been the winner and he was much deserving. Nonetheless he is singing more for his mentor then debo becasue ID doesn't care about Debo at all. He just wanted him to win that is it.

Also why aneek won is because when aneek first came to show ID made fun of him and treated him like crap.

Please dont drag his family matter in this forum and our discussion shd be restricted only to srgmp and nothing beyond that.

Your last para = ID was right in objecting aneek when he entered in the short cut and he did not make fun of him but objected on entry. then he was convinced. He said the same point in media also if australia is winning three tines in a row , will any country allow them to enter direct in semifinal. definetely not. ID just said that again aneek has to cross all the audition and then enter to public voting. Zee brought aneek that means some special influence they showed on him. [treatment shd be uniform orelse other contestant will get doubts why he is special to enter directly without audition.]

Considering that this is again a similar discussion on ID's comments on news channel, this topic is being closed.. It was clearly mentioned by the Dev Team that no more discussion on this topic will be allowed..

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=760381&T PN=21

Topic Closed