Aneek is better than Raja - Page 12

I think it is the other way round. The female guests on the show fall in love with Aneek's voice. Deepika Padukone was simply dancing to Aneek's tunes and supported only him till the end of the show......

Originally posted by: laxmi129

Aneek is better than Raja, true atleast in one aspect. He knows how to propose to all the female guests on the show.

When Sumi sang "Boleh Chudiyan" Aneek instead of dancing seemed to be galloping as he lost his composure, still he sang very well....It really was fun watching that episode.... Only the sweetness of Sumi can match the sweetness of Aneek's voice😆

I am a huge fan of Aneek.
But if I wanna giv a REALLY unbiased opinion...I think Amanat should win. I want Aneek to win, but honestly...Raja's drawback is versatility and scale, Aneek's drawback is a li'l immature voice (though it normally doesn't matter)...Amanat has no such weakness.
Amanat should win, to be fair. But wait a couple more years, and Aneek will be one of the LEADING playback singers!!
But I STILL want Aneek to win. It may seem biased, but seriously, Aneek's immature voice hardly ever creates a problem!
ROCK ON ANEEK!!!!
(I want the results to be: 1.Aneek 2.Amanat 3.Raja)

PS:BTW, it doesn't matter even if it's 1.Amanat 2.Aneek 3.Raja

Originally posted by: mumbai80

Raja is the man, no two ways about it. He is the most original of the two. Singers like Aneek are dime a dozen in the streets of India....who may sing well but do not touch your soul like Raja does every single time...it's who touches you deep inside,not someone who sings technically correctly...singing is an art which should stir your emotions and Aneek just doesn't have it!!!
So Raja is the one......END of Discussion...so there you have it!!!!!

my thoughts exactly...well said👏

All three have their best performances. So the question is firstly who has more "best performances" and whose "best performance" was really out of this world. This is hard to answer without compiling the relevant data. Even then to judge on the quality of the performance is subjective in some way, due to personal taste. But generally speaking (and based on memory) I think Raja would be ahead in number of best performances , but in deciding the most mind-blowing performance, all 3 are closely tied.

I'm again watching the repeat telecast of the ghazal and semi-classical round. This challenging round makes it evident that Amanat, Aneek and Poonam are far more superior to Raja in their singing.

Originally posted by: PSWARUP

I AGREE

Originally posted by: bina40

Aneek proved that he is better than Raja because he sang the song which was just recorded.Not even heard by the public and Raja sang the song which was very popular. Even VS has much faith on Aneek that he gave such sweet song to Aneek.

I agree Aneek is a better singer than Raja but Raja has a better voice and Amanat is better than both of them in singing and voice too.

Originally posted by: shah4268

I agree Aneek is a better singer than Raja but Raja has a better voice and Amanat is better than both of them in singing and voice too.

Raja has a better voice? disagree on that. Raja's voice always cracks at high notes. When he was singling before Shahruk Khan his voice cracked as usual and I don't think king khan was impressed. He is a sufiana singer and there is nothing special about his voice per se. But I do not deny that in his genre he sings exceptionally well (example : Allah Ki Bande, Vande Mataram etc.)

Amanat again sings exceptionally well ghazal and classical raga based songs only. Whenever he tried to venture out of his mold he did not quite succeed, a case in point is his 'pyare bindu'.

Much negative have been said by Aneek's detractors on his voice. But voice is one of his strong points other than his perfect control on high and low notes, sur taal etc.His voice has a smooth honeyed texture to it which is very soothing to hear. You can listen to his songs again and again without getting least bored which is mainly because of his voice.

If we want a perfect voice then Aneek is the answer. From here the purity can be diluted with various elements to derive at other voice types. 😆