ornellamg, Amanat is not just ok.. He is awesome, breathtaking in his forte (clasicals & Ghazals) & he is very good in mainstream.. Aneek is at ease & awesome in mainstream.. but the overall effect is slightly diluted due to his voice being immature. To me Singing classical & Ghazals take more talent than commercial mainstream & hence I would place Amanat ahead of Aneek.. as far as this show goes.. Aneek does have an edge but a very marginal one at it!