Copy Cat vs Versatile. - Page 2

Originally posted by: Vsakhi

oh man, ppl seem to be parroting the same thing over and over and over.. 😕😡 just finished posting this elsewhere and i see the same thing in this thread.. so merely copy pasting..

to al those ppl who claim aneek copies sonu nigam... could it be that you feel that way simply cos aneek's tonal quality is similar to sonu's?! jaane kya chahe mann, dil se, ya ali, tauba main pyar karke, in dinon, bulla ki jaana and the few hr songs that he sang.. pray, where did you find him copying sonu in them? and in the sonu songs that he sang, well, his voice is similar to sonu's and his expressions would match the original if he's a singer worth his salt, so naturally it would sound similar to sonu's singing.. but would it be classified as copying?

to copy someone's style of singing is different from having a similar voice tone. to me shabbir kumar is a copy of md. rafi cos he copied rafi's singing, but sonu nigam is not even though initially ppl found his voice similar to rafi's. in the same vein, aneek sings as aneek and does not copy sonu nigam. he might sound like sonu, but he does not copy sonu.

if aneek copies sonu, then mussarat copies nfak big time, raja copies kailash kher/sukhwinder singh, poonam copies jaspinder narula, mauli copied sunidhi.. so there! 😛

If you saying it so makes you happy - then sure 😊

For the rest, Raja rocks!

Sakhi,

Can you please also enlighten as to who amanat and sumedha copy! I just want to say one thing. there is a difference between inspiration and copying. aneek is just duplicating. No two voices are the same. aneek needs to show that he can bring something special to the sonu songs he sings. not just copy them. YOu have yourself accepted in your previous posts that he sounds just like sonu.

Can mussarat sing NFAK songs in different style?

i think amanat has sung every type of songs go to youtube type his name and u will find there he sang fast and slow songs he did not just sing one style of songs. Most of the time aneek only sings Sonu nagam songs.

lol! amanat not versatile?? like jadoogar said, go LISSEN to the epis n not just SEE them!! amanat is prolli THE MOST VERSATILE singer on srgmp who can sing any type of sing to the core of perfection with ease!
n fyi rahat fateh ali khan is awesome, i love him but he HASNT EVER sang like NFAK or even come close to him as much as mussarat has.
aneek; hez ok but instead of singing from the heart with his own flavor n touch, he sings, like his mentor HR said, with the fear of losing, with the fear of raja amanat n others!

aneek is a big big copycat he copies SONU 👏

i agree with u! but i dont thnk aneek shud win cuz he is already a winner from srgmp bengali, n he jus came in srgmp half way through! i thnk any other contestant shud win cuz they're da ones dat tried rly hard 2 reach where they r now n aneek just came in and didnt even go through all da hard ships dat others had 2

Amanat -
copy cat - no - 1
versatile - yes - 1
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 3/3

copies none; fairly versatile with fast(bijuriya),peppy (jine mera dil lutiya), slow, classical, romantic songs...
comforst zone being classical....


Aneek -
copy cat - yes - 0.5
versatile - yes - 1
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 2.5/3

copies Sonu a lil, versatile with fast, slow, romantic, emotional, semi-classical songs - comforst zone being sonu songs....

Musarrat -
copy cat - yes - 0
versatile - no - 0
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 1/3

copies nfak; not versatile - but best in his comfort zone

Poonam -
copy cat - yes - 0.5
versatile - partially - 0.5
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 2/3

copies jaspinder narula, not so versatile - but good in whatever she sings - best in her comfort zone ie Jaspinder songs

Raja -
copy cat - yes - 0
versatile - partially - 0.5
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 1.5/3

copies sukhvendar singh/kailash kher; best in his comfort zone ; not bad in other genres too meaning not bad at versatility...

Sumedha -
copy cat - no - 1
versatile - yes - 1
comfort zone - best - 1

score: 3/3

copies no one; and fairly versatile; good in her comfort zone ie the sensuous songs

with this report for me Amanat n Sumedha top the charts followed by Aneek, Poonam, Raja n Musarrat 😃

It is one thing to support your favorite. but doesnt meanyou need to put down other contestants. Aneek may have sung different singers's songs, but they all sound like Sonu singing albeit not as great as Sonu.
But please dont say that Amanat is not versatile. If any he is the most versatile singer followed by Sumedha and Poonam. Amanat/s voice is so original, doesnt copy anyone. PLease LISTEN to the songs not SEE.

Aneek is not copy cat he HR cat 😉