Better mentors and judges

I sort of long for the likes of Alka Yagnik and Abhijeet to be on this show.

At least, we would have had the correct marks given for good singing, and not for other reasons. These 2 judges are fair and make fair criticisms, they just would not have dished out 10's all the time.

no i think abhijeet was too harsh on sameer last saregamapa

Abhijeet is harsh but a better judge..I also wud hv loved if these two were there instead of Bappi da

i think vishal and shekhar are the best!!!
i dont want anyone replacing them 😃

Originally posted by: anshu03

If any girl sings well, Alka gets insecure and always tries to find out some mistake in her. The least said about abhijeet the better, he must first learn to respect other artists. He is sitting workless and thinks that he is something great.

As far as Vishal & Shekhar go, I will only respect them when they take their blindfold off for Mauli. They can only see her and hear her. Right from her Maiyya Maiyya, they are just stuck to he like chewing gum on hair. Words like Mauli You Rock and Mauli's back when actually she kills the song are surely not attributes of a good judge.
Out of all judges I have seen on all shows, the only won which was true to the job, gave positive criticism and was not onto any nautanki has been SONU NIGAM on Indian Idol.
Even when he is critical, he does not insult anyone and gives good tips and when he appreciates someone he does not go over the top.
Rest are all not good enough.

Well said. I have exactly the same opinion. 👏

Sonu Nigam is a great judge. I wish we had him here. He always gives the right feedback

also, id like to see shaan as a mentor on SRGMP. just for fun.

alka yagnik and abhijeet can be very biased at times. also i dislike their bickering and abhijeet cn be rude for no reason. i dont like his eccentricities

I like the judges, except bappida!! He really makes me angry!

I think of the current lot ,I will only keep VS & would like to replace the rest. Would be good to have Sonu, VS & Shankar Mahadevan