What is your opinion for this weeks show - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

5.9k

Users

47

Frequent Posters

SmarterDesiKid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#61
Harpreet = 10
Juanid + Raja = dun know [nephew kept making me take him outside to play, so couldn't see these two performances]
Amanat = 9 [didn't like putting his name in the song, rest = great]
Poonam = 9ish
Aneek = 9.5
Mussarat = [skipped this one too]
Sumedha = 10
Mauli = 9.5

avtab thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#62
Qawali Episode:

harpreet-10/10 (Amaizing. he improved a lot)
junaid-7/10 (He has good voice but there was no force in his singing. he seems 2 b very tired. he sd take some energetic drinks)
raja-9/10 ( I think he is 1 of the most potential good singer. His teridiwani is still his best performence)
mussarat-9.5/10 (Outstanding but still sur se hat gaya tha)
aneek-9.5/10 (I think his he can do better)
amanat-10/10 (Outstanding like always)
poonam-9/10 (she choosen a tough song of latajee. I think no1 can sing lata's song easily)
sumedha-7/10 ( I didn't like her song tat much. Force nehitha. she also sd take some energetic drinks)
mauli-6.5/10 (actually, woh HR ki tara nak lagake gana gatihey. n I think choice of song was wrong. she cd do more better)

OVERALL a good show. I don't understand bappida. y always cut marks)
booboo7 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#63
saturday's show was the first enjoyable episode for maaaany weeks 😊

harpreet ~ 9/10 great attempt..could've done with relaxing a little more, but solid

junaid ~ 7.5/10 i want the old junaid back tried very hard but energy was missing...i wish the mentors would offer more encouragement to him

mussarat ~ 10/10 outstanding..he's a pro

aneek ~ 9.5/10 very energetic..preferred hema's version as the low notes for aneek were a little shaky

amanat ~ 10/10 superb..he seemed to be enjoying himself and it showed in his singing. loved it.

raja ~ 9.5/10 fantastic, but slightly worried that he is straining his voice a bit. magical.

poonam ~ 7/10 really did not like this song did not suit her voice and it was shrill throughout.

sumedha ~ 10/10 such a sweet voice, and just brilliant. looked a million dollars too.

mauli ~ 7.5/10 not bad, but not on par with some of the others. still, it was nice to hear her try somet different.

😊
stiletto thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#64
Harpreet was undoubtedly the champ this week.

Mussarat was good too.

I thought Junaid looked adorable but didnt sing as well he can.

The only thing that was really disappointing this week were the mentors.
SmarterDesiKid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#65
😆 Of all the things I read, 99% had Mauli at worst for Saturday, when she wasn't all that bad 😆
HayeSiyaapa thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#66
I hought da show over all was realll goooodd.. cuz like da way everyone wasseated as da judges said made daatmosphere better ppl actually got into the mood
dazzling star thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#67
Enjoyed the Qwali show

I thought that amanat was the best- 9.5
Mussarat- rating 9
Harpreet-8
Aneek- 8.5
Poonam-8
sumedha-7
Raja-8
Junaid-7.5
Mauli- 5
I think the bottom three will still be Junaid, Amanat and Mussarat, because the votes are carried forward and poor Junaid will exit the show.
Koyal thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#68
O.K. so, the performances this W/E. All very good and even if I may say so myself, Mauli was O.K. too, didn't mind hearing her (while looking away) only when she hit the high notes, I had to look, because it turned into another person singing, so I thought another contestant was taking the stage 😃 highly exaggerated, sorry, there I go again.

I loved the ambience as ID rightly pointed out.

Now for the Parformance (Bappida ishtyle).

Musarrat: was so good and flawless. I like to hear NFAK, but for me he's a bit hoarse, but wow man, Musarrat was like ghee in sheera, makhmal. 10/10

Amanat: was clearly enjoying himself, playing to the gallery, superb performance. Loved the way he playfully threw the rose, then innocently said "it fell down". 10/10

Raja : another beautiful performance. This guy just raises the bar everytime he sings. No words to describe. 10/10

Aneek : His voice so suited this song, it felt like he was singing for the film. High notes, low notes, mindblowing. 10/10

Sumedha : What a divine voice!! she sings so effortlessly, it seemed like she was lip syncing the song. No crunching faces, just a serene look of concentration. Another beautiful performance, such a sheer joy to watch and listen. 10/10

Poonam : She is a treasure for India. Such powerful vocals, one tone, difficult songs choice. Fantabulous. 10/10

Junaid : Such a different voice. So much of love in his voice, he is suited for romantic songs. One can feel the song thru his voice. But I think the judges, specially Shekhar and Himesh are bent on sending him home. I feel they know who should go, and trying to get low votes for Junaid in a such way that the fans of Himesh and Shekar will vote him off listening to them discuss Junaid's singing. He looked upset, which is natural, when such a disturbing ilzam (accusation) has been put on them, who wouldn't be? What if one of us goes on a goodwill mission to China and the next day, there are large hordings in their newspapers that we have actually come to spy, would we just sit in the hotel room and sip green tea and eat dim sim? Silly goons, naturally he was upset and his inner turmoil showed on his face. 9/10

Harpreet : I like his singing, which is much higher than some others there, but somehow I cannot connect with it. I did't go wow yet, that is not to say I will not, I may, but I haven't yet. 8.5/10

Mauli: 7/10 believe me this score is very high in my record book. Poor Shubha Mudgal must be taking training lessons in oooohhhh and aaaaahhhhing, oomph lessons in her classical songs... new twist.

Does anyone think somebody behind the camera is in love with Mauli? or is it that Mauli lands wherever the camera is focussed? Half of the time, during the Qawalli round the angle of the stadium was from her side and she was busy laughing and horsing around during other's performance. The reason I'm saying somebody is in love with Mauli is because she is there in each and every frame, be it for ID's daughter's B'day party (with her now "infamous" Maiya song 😕 ) or at the earlier event at the school, where again they showed her singing the M.... song (I can't even repeat the name of the song without cringing) to the students... but conveniently cutshort Sumedha's song... again I digress...

By the way, what was with the extra air time with Himesh and Gujarat lingo. It's been 2 months, and they are always meeting backstage. I think this is Mr. Bips training her, like he welcomes the already welcomed guest on the show, well into mid time. She is the only contestant who is bad in her singing which is anyway taking up air time, but (here my eyebrows are reaching my hairline) she takes extra air time to air her teeth!!, oops sorry mods, didn't mean to get that out, can't seem to find the delete button here.

Bappi L. seriously needs to take a crash course in music. His sense of who is good is so highly toxic, he's going to burst.

The reason I feel they want to give high points to Ms. high octave is because the final points tally will decide the elimination.
Hazardous thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: SmarterDesiKid

Harpreet = 10
Juanid + Raja = dun know [nephew kept making me take him outside to play, so couldn't see these two performances]
Amanat = 9 [didn't like putting his name in the song, rest = great]
Poonam = 9ish
Aneek = 9.5
Mussarat = [skipped this one too]
Sumedha = 10
Mauli = 9.5

Oye Suny!How could you skip Junaid,Raja and Mussarats performance!You were supposed to skip Mauli's!😡😡😆

SmarterDesiKid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: ms_naughty_devi

Oye Suny!How could you skip Junaid,Raja and Mussarats performance!You were supposed to skip Mauli's!😡😡😆

Go blame my Nephew, he kept making me take him outside to play...
And by the time I could make him tired, I missed those performances, and Muss's, couldn't here cuz of all the noise [family]
And I had nothing better to do than watch her performance, and after seeing she got 10-10-10 on the update, I had to see what she sang

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".