What is your opinion for this weeks show - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

5.9k

Users

47

Frequent Posters

koenigbobo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11

todays show was kinda sad !!
4 me bottom 3
mauli ( she wuz lukiin damn hot 😳 buh her singin wuz

junaid ( maybe be cuz depression ! he cudnt giv his best)

hapreet ( cuz of his punjabi pronouncation lol 😆 even tho hes punjabi buh the way he wuz singin ais alaga hes uncomfortable wid the song! dis time he wuznt gud)

and toppers were

amanat ( he sng without mistake 😛)
raja: as usuall wid his own style
mussarat/sumedha

ratings:

amanat: 10

raja: 9.5

aneek:9

mussarat: 9

sumedha:9.5

poonam:9

junaid:7

harpreet:7

mauli:5 ( sorry mauli)

Edited by koenigbobo - 18 years ago
SGMPfan2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12
I thought this was Mauli's forte so she sang the dance # really well! She's good at this type of stuff - item # dance #s so she did well tonite.
Sumedha sounded good too.
Amanat was having fun with Sonu's Bijuria song :) I don't know what ID was talking about him looking confused or whatever??? ID's comments about Amanat confused him....I thought he was good tonite! He might be having that breathing issue again tonite but it really didn't show IMO.
Poonam - she was kind of up and down tonite. At some times she was screaming and at others she sang well. A mixed bag of a performance.
Will comment on the others once I watch the recording :)

Didn't get all the super duper crying at the end at all!!! Such a confusing show tonite..oh brother!
vicuk thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13
Aneek and Raja 10
Poonam 9.5
Sumedha and mussarat 9
Amanat and Harpreet 8.5
Mauli 6
Rinkalp90 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#14
starting from begining


Mauli: 7, it funny cause she sings her gerner songs nicely but when she sings slow and emotional songs, shes all down.. but she still doesn't get out or in trishanku!

Sumedha: 7 she was all right
wow i was shocked how ppl where welcoming her in her hometown.. soo many ppl 👏

Harpreet: 10! AMazing.. soni De Nakhre.. wowow hats off!!!!
especially he sang this part very well..."oh keinde pump pump pump up, oh jannah jannah" loved it.. 👏


Junaid: 9 i enjoyed it..

Raja: 9 i didn't know the song..but i liked it..
again amazing welcome by his hometown..

Mussarat: 10 loved the fast version of it.. wow.. 👏

Aneek: 9 i love how they both sang HR's song... 😊

Poonam: 9 i just love her voice

Amanat: 10 oh god.. again.. i have no words to describe how good it was.. i just loved it.. 😃

trishanku:
nonsense.. it was scripted.. how come Aditya said "whoever did this was trying to creat conflicts between Paki and India" right away.. he didn't even think about it.. and he just said it like he knew what he was saying

then ID said something when he was commenting Poonam and Amanat perferm.. he said that he wanted to mention something but he will later..
and right after all the trishanku comes out, Adi ask ID to talk.

it was soo emotionall.. when Junaid, Amanat, and Mussarat were talking..
especially outt of all other contenstand.. Raja was more emotional..

Happy BeLated Birhtday Mussarat!!!! 😊

nonsense.. can they make less obvious..?
Edited by Rinkalp90 - 18 years ago
SabkaDost thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15
What is the point - I mean does it really matter? A number of polls and comments put mauli the lowest and she still got the green light. So far, she is getting low points on this poll, but my opinion is that she would still get green light next week. Anyways,

Harpreet and Sumedha - 9
Poonam and Raja - 8
Aneek and Amanat - 7
Mussrat and Junaid - 5
Mauli - 1
somia thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16
my comment on this week's show....
so far
bakwaas
😛
Kiran. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

I think this is the FIRST time I am posting my comments here😳. I am not a qualified person to judge sur, taal, etc....so plz bare with me if my comments don't make any sense😆😳😭

Friday Episode:

Best performances were by Harpreet👏, Aamanat👏, Sumedha👏, & Mussarat👏.

Harpreet 10/10.
He is my favorite in this contest. Though I liked all his previous performances, but today was his best performance. I am glad he has gained more confidence now. Like Vishal said, he is becoming a rock star. Harpreet may not be the best out there but today he was definitely one of the best. Harpreet finally got some deserving comments from VS👏

Sumedha 10/10
I am not really a big fan of her singing but today she proved that she is versatile👏and one of the best out there. Aisa lag raha tha ke original track ko sun rahe hain😃 She rocked today.👍🏼

Aamant 10/10
He was simply superb😃. As HR says "superb, mindblowing, fantastic"😃 Who says that Amanat is not versatile. This is the second time he has proved that he can sing any type of songs.👏 Aamant is a very talented singer. Last week too he gave tremendous performances. He did not deserve to be in the bottom three

Mussarat 9.5/10
Not many can sing HR songs. Mussarat did full justice to HR song. He sang it with full energy. HR songs does suit his voice😳. can't really comment on sur/taal but I can say I fully enjoyed his performance.

Poonam 8/10
She has a uniqe voice but I feel today she lacked the energy that was needed for that Khallasssss song😳

Aneek, Junaid, Raja, and Mauli were good but didn't really impress me.
Raja needs to choose diffrent type of song. I am glad VS finally told Raja to prove his versatility.
Mauli is good when she sings item numbers......so today's performance was good.
Junaid lacks the confidence/energy. Today he seemed so depressed😭

Overall, most of the performances were enjoyable.😛


`reenu` thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: somia

my comment on this week's show....
so far
bakwaas
😛

Totally agree with you

mdroy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19
Mauli: 6 or 7 - -not so great even in "her genre"

Sumedha: 9 - -she was good

Harpreet: 10 -- I don't really care for the song as it screams Govinda but
he did a good job.

Junaid: 8 - he was ok

Raja: 9 it was a little odd

Mussarat: 8 he was out of sur a coupe of times but probaby sang it better
than the original 😉

Aneek: 9.5 i It was good though I did not care for the song

Poonam: 9 good but sur slipped a couple of times

Amanat: 10 I thought he was perfect and I wished that Raja and Harpreet
woud have gone up there and done the Sonu dance whie he was singing.

I think the editing, makes it seem scripted.

Regardless, I feel so bad for the Pak contestants to be made to feel this
way.
SmarterDesiKid thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Harpreet = 10/10
Junaid = 9/10
Raja = [cuz of lyrics] 8/10

Aneek = 10/10 [better than HR]
Mussarat = too fast, 9/10

Poonam = I found this one great, 10/10
Amanata = 9/10

Sumdha + Mauli = skipped


And why they start with Result after song?
This so far shows it's been planned...

Also, how does Aneek go from bottom three to a differnce of 500 votes to first? in just 3 days of voting? If this happened next week, I wouldn't have said this cuz it'll be more convincing

and how in the world did Mauli have #1 in International...

and if International voting kept Junaid safe, that would mean that basically 60-80% of voting = in India = [after all this expanding drama] give Pak even a less chance of making it to final 4/3/2/1

That would also mean that Mauli is getting a lot of votes from India, cuz international voting = aroun 20-40% of total votes, and with a majority of them, combinded with India votes = Mauli safe, so bunch of Ind. viewers = vote 4 Mauli

[90% = not make sense..if you don't want to think too much, just read my performance scores😆]

Edited by SmarterDesiKid - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".