Mean for Mauli and Sumedha (Spoiler) - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

4.5k

Users

36

Frequent Posters

sumesh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Subclavian110



because Mr. T knows his house is weak, and if the most likely to be fully eliminated! Mr. T needs this show because it exposes him to people.....once his girls are eliminated his face is gone and he can't stand being unpopular again!

It might sound harsh but its the truth. Of course the walkout involving the debo situation was wrong, but ID is totally justified for this year because mauli is the worst singer on the show, and these three kids are definitely the cream of the crop.



r u referring Mr.T to Bappi?😕

anyways will ID react same way if his gharana people werent in danger zone & otehr 3 gharana good singers come to bottom 3?😕

oh puhalese...all mentors are selfish when coming to their gharana not only just bappi da...😛They do hype their contestant their own way too...BTW he said Mauli & Sumedha ok?😉

I never seen him praising much abt Sumedha but he has praised mauli many times😉Its HR who said last week he dotn wanna see Mauli in bottom 3...Its so funny mentors change their decision when their gharana people come to danger zone..that means they r selfish like bappi da too !!!

If ID questioned abt rules in wild card entry & created lods of hungama then why cant Bappi da too..atleast he didnt make any walkout drama or something...am sure bappida didnt mean so harsh too...he just said abt his opinion !!!😛(BTW we r arguing to something we didnt seen; better to argue after seeing this on TV)
sumesh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: jugalbaj

What is Mauli singing this week and also Raja on Friday. Anybody who know please post.



Friday: Dance theme

1) Aneek - shakalaka boom-2
2) Amanat - bijuria
3) Sumedha - Where s da party 2nite

Saturday : Qawwalli theme

1) Aneek- tumse milke dil ka
2) Amanat - Parda hai parda
3) Sumedha - Nigahen milane ko dil by Asha bhosle from movie dil hi to hai
4) Raja - Piya jaji ali by ARR


so far this much songs confirmed...no clue abt wht Mauli gonna sing..
imran310 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: anshu03

This is bull***t, what ID said was (if so) then it is very mean. You cannot insult singers in front of others and he is no one to judge who is better than Sumedha and who is not. People have casted their votes and have spoken so he has no rights. I mean I have heard mussarat sing atrociously, the O Priya song was a bigger mess than anything (close to mauli) and he forgot the lyrics and stopped that was bad.
I think the are just trying to kiss a** since the 3 are Paki's and they want to show how just they are, in a way they are correct at they 3 are good singers but those eliminated were also good. Well its the format of the show and they should have kept it that way. If they felt Mauli or Sumedha should have gone and not one of the 3, then why not raise a voice when Apurva went out or Nirupama/ Abhijeet went out.

This sucks, just coz they are Indians, injustice can be metted out but coz its our overseas brothers, there cant be any injustice, but the fact is that if mauli stays and others go beofre each time it is great Injustice. I hate this sucking up, even our politicians do it. To please the some they have reservations in IIT & IIMs, just to please a few they dont mind doing injustice to the majority.

WHy they did not speak when other contestants were being chucked out and Mauli just stood there ?? When Aneek was in bottom 3, why did ID not say that he should not be there and that he sings better than Amanat / Mussarat / Junaid etc etc. I think Apurva sang much better than Junaid and he should have stayed.

This only means that the channel does not care for the people's money, they have voted thinking that their FAV will be eliminated and now their votes have gone to waste. So they could have easily saved their money if they knew that this is a non elimination round.

CHeating CHeating cheating !!!

I always loved Amanat & Junaid singing but cannot take injustcie anymore, if they bend the rules for them just coz they are from accross the border then it sucks, i know its not their fault but something the channel guys have to do in order to appease many people and garner more TRP.



if zee allow voting from pakistan and the pakistanis still got the least votes then no one would care. but the pakistanis are at a huge disadvantage with only online voting. plus i KNOW that if pakistanis were able to vote thru sms and landline the trio would never reach the trisunku.
nightowl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: sumesh



Friday: Dance theme

1) Aneek - shakalaka boom-2
2) Amanat - bijuria
3) Sumedha - Where s da party 2nite

Saturday : Qawwalli theme

1) Aneek- tumse milke dil ka
2) Amanat - Parda hai parda
3) Sumedha - Nigahen milane ko dil by Asha bhosle from movie dil hi to hai
4) Raja - Piya jaji ali by ARR


so far this much songs confirmed...no clue abt wht Mauli gonna sing..

oh wow amanats singing bijuria...cant wait

t4s sumesh😊

Barnali thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#35
I am closing the topic to trash few posts. can we keep the discussion more clean by not using these abusive words for each other.

Barnali thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#36
Moderator's Note:
Plz u all are being requested repeatedly not to resort to personal attacks. but somehow none of u are heeding to this request of the Dev team.

One more thing we would like to request u all. If u find any post making a personal attack on u or any other fellow member plz report.Dnt go ahead to retort back resulting into things turning worse. The end result of such actions is that the threads get closed.

I hope after this u all would keep the discussion away from abusive words and profane language. 😊


SRGMP dev team


imran310 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: anshu03

How suddenly you have woken up to this fact and not in the earlier weeks ???

The only reaosn these 3 came in bottom was that the janta did not relate to the song, had never heard them before and were not at all connected to them.


actually i had noticed that the pakistanis wouldnt be able to vote before the agnipariksha started. my friend who works on the set of saregamapa had told me that the whole plan was not to let the pakistanis vote because they would never vote for indians.

but i do agree with u that one of the reasons that JAM received the fewest votes was because the janta did not relate to the songs.
CaLiiZ*DiiMe thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#38
can we drop the whole "why junaid, amanat, and mussarat got least vote" and "the unfair decision of not eliminating anyone" discussions now
its soo sickeningggg!!
gopalbhai thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#39
Let us consider this, when these contestants performed last week, then also it was quite clear whose performances are likely to be appreciated by people. ID did not say that time that there should be no elimination next week. If he had done that i can believe he is right now but he did not sat this at that time. Simply because the results are now against his favor he is raising issue after declaring the voting results.
Now, if a good singer gets eliminated it is an injustice to the participant but if you prevent a good singer from elimination in spite of the participant getting eliminated as per the rule, you are destroying the very basis of the competition it is not just singing alone that makes up this competition. Adherence to the format also is an important part.
joie de vivre thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#40

Ismail's comment was below the belt.....More was at stake for Ismail than for Bappi...Mauli is unarguably the weakest singer on the show,and Sumedha isnt the strongest..They can at the most go a bit more further in the competition,but they do not have a snowball's chance in hell of winning the competition...Definitely not when singers like Raja and Poonam too are vying for the votes....And Bappi knows this,he might be unreasonably supportive of Mauli,but he is not delusional.....It would be optimistic to the point to insanity on Bappi's part, to, even for a moment, think that Mauli or Sumedha have even an outside chance of winning it

Whereas Amanat is a complete singer,and does have a good chance of winning it,provided he is prudent in his song selection henceforth.... So I have every reason to believe that Ismail was more threatened than Bappi....Besides,if Ismail cares so much about the "fairness" of the competition,he SHOULD have protested when Joy was ousted last week,when Joy was clearly the better singer than Sumedha(debatable) and Mauli(without a shadow of doubt)..This wouldnt be the first time that a deserving singer was in the trishanku...So all the hullabaloo that was whipped up was solely because the three singers were foreigners...Some people on the forum protested that it was highly unfair that the Indian audience didnt vote for songs which did not strike a chord with them,didn't they??..Well,now it's clear that preferential treatment is not doled out to the local contestants,because had three Indian singers been the trishanku,Ismail ,or any of the mentors for that matter would NOT have raised any eyebrows,or championed fairness and judiciousness that is expected of the voters

Edited by joie de vivre - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".