public voting?? is it a joke?**spoiler** - Page 2

Yes I believe this would have happend.Someone earlier said about Deboit won because of the emotions.That is very correct. My person likings were more towards Nihira then Himani.Public should understand and there is nothing that they can not do.If they stop public voting then Zee TV looses lots of money. 1 sms costs 5 to 6 rs frowm which zee gets 3 rs.

Anyway after Apurva its Mauli who is geting out of this compition.I can not believe Apurva is our. I just loved his singing. My brother's sister in law met her and she told him.

Originally posted by: Bhavesh.Chauhan

i agree as well. however, i still think it would be much much much better if the public is only allowed to vote once each week. that would be much fair.

in political elections, the public is only allowed to vote once.. why should a singing competition be any different in terms of fairness and selecting the "best".

Oh..that one. they have agreements with mobile companies. The channels get huge amount of money from them (portion of sms bills). it is all for money.

Originally posted by: xyzt

Being a gujarati and staying in mumbai he could not gather the vote base in the western part of the country.The gujaratis might have voted for mauli while the maharashtrians might have voted for abhijit kosambe.I think if abhijit was not brought into this contest as a wild card entry then he migt have made it much further into the contest.And he was not hyped by his mentors and did not possess the good looks of junaid or the x factor of mauli.

there you go. so true.
from final two episodes of c2005 I saw that north eastern states voted for debojit, hindi speaking belt was voting for vinit and from south hemachandra was getting lots of vote. Hem got out because i think inherently south-indians does not care that much for an hindi program. I can remember despite being a bengali , debojit got only 2% vote from Calcutta. but he got tons of vote from the north eastern states because it was first time a resident of north indian states was creating such ripples in the TV media. It is not that rest of the India were being saint or something. They just did not have the passion which north eastern states had.

Originally posted by: xyzt

prerna15,
vinit,Hemachandra and himani might have been better singers but they came till top 4.And also they were not voted out so early in the contest.HImani has been the girls winner so not much of an objection there.Apoorva has been voted out after just two rounds.He is a good singer.
And in last week he was better than mauli,junaid,nirupama and poonam.He did not make it to the top 12 of 14 singers which is surprising.He is better than musarat.I don't know on what basis the Indian public is voting.He may not be the best singer but one of the best Indian singers.Going by singing mauli or junaid should have gone.But if these singers remain while better singers are eliminated then the program will suffer.So I hope the public will make the right decision later.

Let us hope that the undeserving singers will be eliminated soon.

Well, that's why I said I'm not in favour of that public voting thing at all. It would have been way better if the singers were judged by professionals in the field of music. Then those undeserving singers would have been out instead of Apurva. & I can bet that Debojit also would never have been the winner of C-05.

I'm feeling really sorry for Apurva. He didn't deserve to be out so soon, I completely agree with this.

yea. i too felt that apurva has a wonderful voice yes there are sum better ones there but this was not the right time to eliminate him.... i personaly think, mauli, shoud have been eliminated coz she does not know how to sing, the only song that she sings is maiya miaya and im tired of it jeez, apurva didnt deserve it. he shud have stayed. and "ahem ahem" we all know who shud have been eliminated

Mauli, Joy, Junaid, Nirupama, Poonam, Musarrat are not good singers. They all should get out, before Apoorva and I sure sooner or later they all are gonna go.

The final few should be (the order is not indicative of anything)

Raja
Aneek
Abhijit
Harpreet
Amanat

As long as final 5 are these people, ultimately junta wont have any complaints. They will forget the order in which the rest got eliminated.

There is no foolproof method to ensure a 100% fair judgement. I cannot agree to the 7+7+7 points awarded to Poonam last week by the mentors when seemingly not so good performances were awarded higher points.

But still the votes were not much deviation from fairness. The bottom three did correspond to fairness to me at least.

Let us keep in mind that this is the final and none of them is sings that bad.