’I am disappointed..' ismail durbar - Page 2

Originally posted by: liquidice

well why is he causing all this commotion now...he knew it frm the beginning

I agree with Liquidice.

1. he should have known the rules prior to signing up as a mentor

2. there was a whole group of Ekalavya group added as well..

3. if abhijit and aneek fail to perform better than the remaining candidates, they will be eliminated anyway. Now if they perform better than the current candidates, what is the chance of them failing to these one of the earlier rounds?? / failing to those who already got eliminated? pretty slim i think! In fact, they have not got multiple chances to sustain I say... neither do they have training obtained from HINDI show mentors yet! One should not feel threatened by them I think :) if one is here to win the final..

Originally posted by: punjini

No. The industry needs good music directors. 😊

so i guess he was wrong last year then, even if he was just makig it up for impression sake.😉

actually, if we go there, then we will sooner or later end up saying that the industry needs audiences who'll pony up for good music, not just for the chalu nightclub stuff.😆

Originally posted by: chatbuster

lol. did he forget all of last year while he was thanking sgmp for bringing up good singers? how he was saying that the industry needed great singers? what's the problem now? industry doesn't need good singers anymore? 😉

He's not saying they are bad singers or that they degrade the show. But there's a certain system, and the system should be fair for all. He simply says that instead of joining in the middle, they should have been there from the start - if they are good, then they would have made it to finals in any case, and it would have been fair that they went through all that the others did in this competition.

Last year we had previous winners too - Vinit, Debojit, Ujjaini, Raktima, and 4 others. These people also got wild cards, but only so much to get them into the competition in the beginning. They had to start from the initial rounds like everyone else. ID did not complain about them because they hadn't got an undue advantage over the others by getting directly into final 12.

Amanat is also a regional winner (the Middle East-Pakistan region). What that did for him is get him an entry as the Dubai contestant. But he also had to start from the beginning. He didn't get directly into final 12. Why different rules for Amanat and for the other 2?

Don't mind, but I get a feeling your arguments are biased against ID. Whatever he says or does, there's an argument ready to contradict that. Aisa kyon bhai? 😉