SRGMP has started disappointing!!!!

Dipti.Mishra thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

I feel nothing is going okay with SRGMP these days. The following are evident:

a> Zee has started compromising on quality to gain TRPS. Thats ridiculous. It was far better than Indian Idol or Fame Gurukul etc coz it had so far been so genuine has got excellent singers for us. What could be a better example than Shreya GHoshal herself. BUt now none of these singers hv the potential to make it like Shreya... they are simply pathetic (except a few really good ones). If Zee choses to make SRGMP like Indian Idol then i can only feel sorry for it. :(

b> Mauli is a bad singer. I would not call her extremely poor though coz remember the alaap that she song in between the song whihc even Shekhar pointed out was sung extremely well but the rest of the song was pathetic. she is becoming so stereotype. She literally croaks n her voice is like cacophony to the ears.

c> I sincerely appreciate VS judgement coz thus far they hv been the best judges... not at all biased. They without hesitating praise contestants from the other clans as well which is really appreciable.

d> The decision abt Saberi n Rimi was also wrong. I think Saberi was better than Rimi

e> Anand ji hs been a bad judge. he has made choices basd on audience appeal which is so very wrong. at last we want good singers not the ones who would rock the world.... singers like these hv a very small shelf life.

f> The Music Directors are dicttaing teh show. They are influencing the choosing factor of the main guru. Thats unfair.

g> HR should be thrown out of the show. He is an irritating chracter trying to bring in politics into the show. The way he was instigating Reecha was so disgraceful. This shows how immature he is. He keeps beating his own trumpet all the time n tries to control the show as if he is the head of the show.

i> I m surprised as to how come ID is becoming like HR hradually. I had always expected ID to be soemone sensible n not supporting the wrong decisions. He is suppose to be far more sensible but he is turning to be HR part II.

j> I hv serious doubts on the final singers who would be making it to the Agnipariksha. The quality of only a few of them is outstandingly good.Rest of them hv little far n hv no idea of sur n taal. This is simple so irritating. Much is expected out of SRGMP

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

520

Users

4

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

joypaul thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
In girls, some decisions were not really good, but then I'm not very disappointed since the gap in singing quality among girls is not that big. However, most of the boys are extremely good and I hope Raja & Harpreet come back, although there are other boys too who are good like Sunil, wasi, Sikander, but had to be eliminated due to fierce competition.

Yes, some of the judgements have not been good, but the show in itself is not disappointing. Whatever, the drama, etc. I love this show. In fact, the singing quality is improving each week 👏 👏 and I'm sure it'll just get better in the Aginipariksha round.
rocker1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I think we have great talent among the boys. A couple of talented singers missed out due to luck, but that's unavoidable when we have only 5-6 spots. But among the girls we missed out some good singers like Reecha and Saberi, and instead we have Mauli and Sumedha (who's only sung once). Oh well, let's hope they live up to their hype.

And yes, I agree that the talent is improving every week, and people are reaching their peaks. The show is matching C2005's standards, and may even exceed them.
arun_8687 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
The last two episodes have been very good.

But dont think the show's anywhere near C'05 yet. We haven't had a single spellbinding performance yet, Amanat was close to it yes'day but he too wasn't flawless

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".