How u would like mentors to behave?

Recently happened to see three scenarios in different channels with respect to How mentors behave with a contestant if he has sung bad..I have tried to write three scenarios .. How you would like the mentors to behave?Would you want them to behave in a different manner than the three scenarios mentioned below..Please share your scenarios😊

Scenario 1 Sweet talk like.. A contestant who has sung very bad and mentor start encouraging...Oye raje bete, You are too good, You just started where Rafi saab left....Jayo baaki guruon ka aashirwaad lo...Good boy..feel proud of you..

or

Scenario 2.. Would u like them to be very objective..A contestant who has sung bad and mentor saying..The way you have sung is good for bathroom singing..where u are the only audience..

or

Scenario 3..you would like them to be very critical: A contestant who has sung bad and mentor saying: Beda garak..sara sikhaya mitti mein mila diya..arey mujhe gadha shishya mil jata to tere se to achha hi gaata...Ja jake koi vada pav ki rehrhi laga le..wo na chaley to paan ki dukaan laga le..arey bhaag yahan se..ye stage tere liye nahin hai...

I would like to see an in-depth, objective analysis of where the song went wrong or where the song appealed. I would like to hear whether the mistakes can be corrected by practice or is there something fundamentally wrong with the voice?

No extra comments like "khoda tha pahad aur nikla yeh" which make no sense. But a few words of encouragement will not hurt.

Mujhe scenario 2 aur 3 mein zyada farq nahi laga

Originally posted by: punjini

I would like to see an in-depth, objective analysis of where the song went wrong or where the song appealed. I would like to hear whether the mistakes can be corrected by practice or is there something fundamentally wrong with the voice?

No extra comments like "khoda tha pahad aur nikla yeh" which make no sense. But a few words of encouragement will not hurt.

Thanks Sahana ji for your post..That would indeed be ideal..

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Mujhe scenario 2 aur 3 mein zyada farq nahi laga

😆 You are right..Scenario 2 is also bad but better than the 3..

same as they are now .. thori bohut fighting se interest barh jata he .. omg .. LMAO .. i nact forget that scene when HR said ( Ek min ,, Pehle me apni baat poori karta hun phir aap boliye ga .. ) he is rocking man ..

like Vishal Shekhar & Bhappi da 😊

sum fist fights won't screw up their reputation, so I'd recommend that...and judges actually saying "YOU STINK" instead of saying "Good Performance"...just to help Contestant's improve
If they get a good comment from the judges = confidence they'll be in = when out, SHATTERED...if bad comment, they'll be confident their out = no rona-dhona...they can do that during the commercial break, so 5 minutes doesn't go to water dropping and stuff...[Which saves time for the fist fights, are verbal fights...]

Doesnt matter 1,2,3,4 or 5 as long as it gets the contestants to understand the mistakes

certainly these contestants can misplace their efforts into dressing up or other stuff

If the contestant is aware that there is a public dressing down in store, effort certainly wont be missing

jisko chot lagi woh uth ke chal diya, dekhnewala aiso ro raha hai jaise ki mar gaya 😉

Originally posted by: sareg

jisko chot lagi woh uth ke chal diya, dekhnewala aiso ro raha hai jaise ki mar gaya 😉

😆😆 Is this some well-known quote? I like it.