The Mauly factor..

Page

Next Last

sur_sangam

@Sur_Sangam

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Mauly was asked by Himesh to sing the song "Maya Maya" after she was not able to sing "Mein idhar gayi, mein udar gayi" too well..Vishall pointed out that it was not the right thing to do...if you have to give a second chance it should be given to every body..You think Mauly deserve special treatment? How far Mauly can go like this? What do u think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

Fariha

@NYCgirl_19

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

well personally I really liked mauly and her singing. But well to be honest I think she didn't deserve the special treatment. Well I think she is a great singer but everyone is equal in a competition and have all the rights as other competitors do. So why did Mauli get a second chance? I understand that the judges didn't want her to get eliminated as they had high expectations but Anita sang really well. I am not being biased or anything but I think eliminating Mauli would have been fair if we judge by the singing. Everyone has to get eliminated oneday so I think if Mauli chooses wrong songs and does not perform good, no one will be able to save her. At this tough competition only singing could save someone. Anita was REALLy good and if she oto a second chance I bet she could have done a lot better. Wel I think the judges were kind of biased. Well its just my opinion and please forgive me if I said too much or hurt someone's feelings.

Edited by NYCgirl_19 - 18 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Kiran

@adityalover

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

i agree with Vishal...
she can't sing maya maya in every episode n get away wid it. 😆 .That girl Anita sang way better than Mauli..soo sad she was out 😒

Quote

Parveen Sibal

@sibal52

Navigator

Posted: 18 years ago

and the second maiya maiya was not as good as the first. Stop special treatment to the*****

***Edited for posting racial comments***

Edited by Barnali - 18 years ago

Quote

deep

@deep9

Explorer

Posted: 18 years ago

I totally agree wid ur view point...Its not fair that every time mauli should be singin the "mayya mayya " song..If the round demands something you have to sing according to that , else everyone should be allowed to sing wht they choose...that would be fair...

mauli should have been eliminated this time...

Quote

77124

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

It may not be fair. But Mauli IS a really good singer she just needs to learn to use her own tone and voice in other songs!

I've seen some of her local shows on youtube and she sounds BRILLANT in them! She's singing complete slow songs! Way different than Mayya Mayya.

Quote

Fariha

@NYCgirl_19

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar
I think Dauli should get special treatment... She is representing USA in Agniprikhssa..... Maiyya Maiyya.....

well I am from USA too but I am judging people based on their singing not what country they are representing. I really like Mauli but there are other good singers that are being treated unfairly because of her. I was happy that she was representing USA in Agni Pareksha but her performances were not up to the marks so I guess she didn't deserve the special treatment.

Quote

anonmember

@anonmember

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Its not the first time. Mussarat also got a second chance. Remember his 'gulabi aankhen'? It was Asha ji's request (I think) and Vishal did not object to the mahaguru's request. This time around, it was HR who requested Mauli to sing again.

I don't think its fair. Also, why ask her to sing the same song she sang earlier? It should have been a different song.

Quote

rocker1

@rocker1

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Poor Vishal - every time he asks that people should not be given a 2nd chance, and even if they are, then judgment should not be influenced by the 2nd song - but that is what happens every time.

It happened it Mussarat, it happened with Jyoti, and it happened with Mauli.

Quote

Anuradha Ravi

@Anuradha

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: sonyaee
Its not the first time. Mussarat also got a second chance. Remember his 'gulabi aankhen'? It was Asha ji's request (I think) and Vishal did not object to the mahaguru's request. This time around, it was HR who requested Mauli to sing again.

I don't think its fair. Also, why ask her to sing the same song she sang earlier? It should have been a different song.

He did object.. He said the judgment should be based on the first performance and not the second 😊

I do agree with Vishal on this part.. Yesterday Vishal's comments were just on dot.. The 2 points which put forth - I totally agree with him

Quote

1 2 3

The Mauly factor..

Related Topics

Explore Topics