Vishal judgement??? - Page 2

Originally posted by: Gulshan0108

hey friends, dont u think Vishal is too harsh with his comments.. He needs to encourage new talents instead of critising them unfairly..
Himesh & Ismael always give the right comments...

Sorry, I disagree.
I appreciate Vishal's honest comments and constructive criticism. His comments are usually right. Plus, Vishal does not praise his own contestants excessively, which shows that he is a neutral mentor. That may not be a good thing in the later stages of the show but at least he stays away from the theatrics and excessive drama. I find him polite, not harsh or rude. Maybe others feel differently.

Vishal is slowly emerging as one of the best mentors on the show. 👏

I thought tonight, Vishal wantedly said that he didnt like Mussarat's singing just to provoke HR and Asha B. also looked in a mood to wake the evil in HR awake 😆 😆 but later he applauded for the positive comments he got from Ismael D. & Bappi L. also Asha B. He wanted to put forward his wish that he wants HR's contestant for a week so that he can train him and he knew HR will turn hyper listening that 😆 😆

Originally posted by: sonyaee

Sorry, I disagree.
I appreciate Vishal's honest comments and constructive criticism. His comments are usually right. Plus, Vishal does not praise his own contestants excessively, which shows that he is a neutral mentor. That may not be a good thing in the later stages of the show but at least he stays away from the theatrics and excessive drama. I find him polite, not harsh or rude. Maybe others feel differently.

Vishal is slowly emerging as one of the best mentors on the show. 👏

yeah and i have seen like hit it is one of d best gharanas how dere singers have improved so much n stuff

yey yey yey HIT IT!

Originally posted by: Gulshan0108

But wen Himesh says dont do zis , ke knows wat he is saying.. remember during some last episode he said to the contestants zat they should not have attempted Kishore or Lata songs coz they r legends.. n its difficult to b at zat same level... so better not attempt difficult songs..

no he sed ZAT because he realised how everyone was getting criticised so bad n he realised ZAT singers from his gharana r not gud enuf

Originally posted by: yu.r.fat.

its cus shakky wants to encourage people hes been to all this process of loosing in a talent show n look where he is now, one of d reputed music directors in bollywood.

and i think dey have some sort of a deal vishal speaks n gets all d hatered frm d contestants for d harsh comments and shekhar always luks cute and smiling to d camera flattering all d girls so dey save dere gharana..clever vishal n shakky 😉😃

HIT ITTT all d WAYYYYYYY!

Good theory Mal 😆😆😆

Originally posted by: LonelyHeart

Vishal is a bit to harsh but i guess he wants the contestants to be level headed about their performance. Because he did compliment Poonam but for the others I guess you are right. He needs to encourage a bit more.

But lets look at Others to. Only Shekar who is the quite one but does encourage the participants😳 . Bappida sometimes I feel he needs to comment more rather then saying "riaz karo" Ofcourse that needs to be done too but something more. ID And Himesh judgement 😕 they just surprise me sometimes in +/- way... I liked the way Asha bhosle backs up her judgement 👏

Yes, there's no need to 'sugarcoat' all the comments.
With Vishal, you know when he really thinks a performance is outstanding and when its not.

His remarks are straightforward and he tells the truth. Doesn't mean he is rude. But he is not encouraging like other mentors.

Vishal let Shekhar speak today.
Vishal said after one performance, 'Shekhar, aur tum?' 😆

You know whats funny. After ID complimented Mussarat's performance, HR started clapping and Shekhar did as well. 😆 This was after HR and Vishal's argument on Mussarat's song choice and Rahat Fateh Ali Khan.

Rebel Shekhar 😛 😆

yea seems vishal sai is rude but it is only for the contestants benefit
he also wants them to improve so he will tell their minus points
i have seen way more ruder judges than vishal in singing comptetions
he is nothing compared to them
and vishal is the stricter one from vishal-shekhar
so he will be more strict and say it as he feels

He makes up for the softie on his side, if anyone has to be blamed it has to be the softie 😉