WHY IS SAMEER ON THE SHOW - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

125

Views

7.3k

Users

51

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

AznDesi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Kusum MB

CAN SOMEONE PLEASE PLEASE REMOVE THIS TROUBLEMAKER SHAH GUY FROM THIS FORUM!!!!!!!! THIS IS PATHETIC. HE IS ACTING WORSE THAN A KID. 😡



hahaha Kusum phikar maat karo woh toh sirf zara sa 🤢🤢 "Passing Gas" 🤢🤢 hai HAWA KA JOHKA ouse udda dega!! 😉😆😆
CricFan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
I think Sameer is the weakest of the remaining three contestants. He sings through his nose and has very limited range. Out of the three only Sanchita is deserving.
advil thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: CricFan

I think Sameer is the weakest of the remaining three contestants. He sings through his nose and has very limited range. Out of the three only Sanchita is deserving.

But he also has fans who like his singing. I dont believe he sings through his nose and he has sand pretty well so far or else he wouldn't have made it this far.

Even though my personal choice is Sanchita, I dont think he is that bad..infact he is a very good performer and has good stage presence.

Monica3 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

GUYS PLZ INDIA FORUMS ISN'T MADE TO BASH OTHERS LIKES AND DISLIKES !!AS A MATTER A FACT NOBODY HAS A RIGHT TO COMMENT ON OTHERS OPINIONS 👏 !!!!!IF U THINK PPL ARE BASHING SOMEONE U REALLY LIKE DON'T TAKE IT THE WRONG WAY 😭 😡 !!!!!I PERSONALLY DON'T THINK SAMEER SHOULD WHEN 😭 ,ALTHOUGH HE IS PRETTY GOOD BUT I JUST DON'T THINK HE'S BETTER THEN THE OTHER CONTESTANTS(pawni i miss u) 😕 !!!!oh and plzz don't take that as me bashing sameer it's only my opinion!!so don't comment on others opinion plzzzzzz 😊 😭 😳

***Please use smaller font size and also please don't use all caps. It amounts to shouting on the forum***

Edited by Bhaskar.T - 18 years ago
AznDesi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Monica3

GUYS PLZ INDIA FORUMS ISN'T MADE TO BASH OTHERS LIKES AND DISLIKES !!AS A MATTER A FACT NOBODY HAS A RIGHT TO COMMENT ON OTHERS OPINIONS 👏 !!!!!IF U THINK PPL ARE BASHING SOMEONE U REALLY LIKE DON'T TAKE IT THE WRONG WAY 😭 😡 !!!!!I PERSONALLY DON'T THINK SAMEER SHOULD WHEN 😭 ,ALTHOUGH HE IS PRETTY GOOD BUT I JUST DON'T THINK HE'S BETTER THEN THE OTHER CONTESTANTS(pawni i miss u) 😕 !!!!oh and plzz don't take that as me bashing sameer it's only my opinion!!so don't comment on others opinion plzzzzzz 😊 😭 😳



1 second please just let me pull out my magnifying glass..... havin a hard time reading your post.... hehe just kiddin 😉 anyways yeah we welcome Constructive critism and good reasons why people think other kids are better. So we can counter with why we think he is better 😉
Edited by Bhaskar.T - 18 years ago
r326 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: AznDesi



1 second please just let me pull out my magnifying glass..... havin a hard time reading your post.... hehe just kiddin 😉 anyways yeah we welcome Constructive critism and good reasons why people think other kids are better. So we can counter with why we think he is better 😉

haha..yea..a healthy discussion is pretty fun as long as ur not bashing anyone and its in good taste

Edited by Bhaskar.T - 18 years ago
Sandy_sq thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: Venky_iyer

I totally disagree with u cuz Sameer has a talent that touches my heart!!! His singing is so sweet (especially the fooltoo singing) and i think that Divakar really is getting sympathy votes.!!!!

i completely agree with you. I feel sameer has ABSOLUTELY NO TALENT. just compare. Shreya ghoshal, when she was 11 years old(same age as sameer) singing Suniyo Ji Arj Ma and compare that perfection with sameers songs. I it a disgrace to music if i even compare something like this let alone say sameer is better.

Bhaskar.T thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
Some of you have started attacking each other in the topic. Please stop this.

You want to do criticism do it in a constructive way. Why are you attacking fellow members too.

I have trashed such posts but if carried on again then we will have no choice other than closing the topic. With action against such members.



-SalShah4eva- thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago

Originally posted by: rewasen

With all due respect to Sameer,I fail to understand how did he make it to top 10?Whatever be the reason(age),he does not sound good at this point.Technically,his singing might be in place but when it comes to his voice its not the kind one would like to hear.I have tried hard to understand what is so good about his singing and will any music director like him to sing in his/her film.Neha was anyday better than him,than how come the judges came up with a decision like this N now Abhijeet is complaining that the public voting is wrong and the best singer will not be choosen.

It is the judges who started falsely judging by eliminating Neha n letting in Gurpreet,Armaan,Protik n Sameer.If Diwakar ppl say is gettn sympathy votes what is Sameer gettn,is Sameer a better singer than Abhro n sanchita.Nobody has ever questioned this.

i have it wat u mean sameer is not good hw is not singing good if no hw wil never in 3 place remember this who ever post this one if u dont like sammer then u hurting his fans rite so ya .....and ppl have sympathy with diwakar becz he cant see but listen ppl dont have syampathy with sameer this differnt why compair with sameeer....wat u think diwakar sing good i dint think so sorry if i hurt diwakar fans ......

rewasen thumbnail
Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
With all due respect to Sameer,I fail to understand how did he make it to top 10?Whatever be the reason(age),he does not sound good at this point.Technically,his singing might be in place but when it comes to his voice its not the kind one would like to hear.I have tried hard to understand what is so good about his singing and will any music director like him to sing in his/her film.Neha was anyday better than him,than how come the judges came up with a decision like this N now Abhijeet is complaining that the public voting is wrong and the best singer will not be choosen.

It is the judges who started falsely judging by eliminating Neha n letting in Gurpreet,Armaan,Protik n Sameer.If Diwakar ppl say is gettn sympathy votes what is Sameer gettn,is Sameer a better singer than Abhro n sanchita.Nobody has ever questioned this.

i have it wat u mean sameer is not good hw is not singing good if no hw wil never in 3 place remember this who ever post this one if u dont like sammer then u hurting his fans rite so ya .....and ppl have sympathy with diwakar becz he cant see but listen ppl dont have syampathy with sameer this differnt why compair with sameeer....wat u think diwakar sing good i dint think so sorry if i hurt diwakar fans ......



I did not post this topic to hurt anybody and my question was and still is a genuine one.If I dont like Sameer as a singer that in no way mean I dont like the kid or I am a Sameer basher.To come to that conclusion is foolish.If my post hurt anybody I apologize,but u too said that u dont like Diwakar but I wud not take you as a Diwakar basher or someone who hates him.(i hope i am right here).
to say Diwakar is gettn symapthy votes is only partially correct,if we exchange the his voice with Sameer's do u think he wud have got these many votes.DEFINETLY NOT

i support him only n only for his singing and there r many like me.he is the most lively kid out there,that goes without denying.ppl expect him to be sad,meak n depressed coz he doesnt have sthing which normally otheres have n its 2 much for ppl to take it n then they give it the name of sympathy.there are so many vote appeals for Sameer coz,he is naughty,cute and sabse chota...i have no problems with that n nobody seems to be having any problem with that,it has got nothing to do with music.
then why blame Diwakar,only becoz d kid has an amazing capability to take criticism in the postive way.

may sameer win or may sanchita win,thats ok.i support Diwakar that doesnt mean i am here to hurt ppl who dont support him.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".